Hi there, !
Today Wed 05/02/2012 Tue 05/01/2012 Mon 04/30/2012 Sun 04/29/2012 Sat 04/28/2012 Fri 04/27/2012 Thu 04/26/2012 Archives
Rantburg
531197 articles and 1854392 comments are archived on Rantburg.

Today: 56 articles and 118 comments as of 1:18.
Post a news link    Post your own article   
Area: WoT Operations    WoT Background    Non-WoT           
Syria Troops Kill 10 Rebels in Damascus Region
Today's Headlines
Headline Comments [Views]
Page 4: Opinion
0 [336064] 
8 17:11 Rjschwarz [336072] 
Page 1: WoT Operations
1 15:19 gorb [336083]
7 23:14 canalzone [336112]
2 21:12 trailing wife [336088]
0 [336071]
0 [336065]
0 [336078]
0 [336106]
3 22:49 JosephMendiola [336109]
0 [336082]
0 [336066]
0 [336065]
2 08:33 Besoeker [336067]
0 [336064]
0 [336064]
0 [336084]
0 [336066]
0 [336068]
0 [336067]
0 [336068]
0 [336084]
1 07:57 trailing wife [336066]
0 [336064]
Page 2: WoT Background
2 21:10 trailing wife [336105]
3 21:23 tu3031 [336108]
5 15:26 Alaska Paul [336096]
1 07:33 trailing wife [336065]
3 22:37 JosephMendiola [336079]
0 [336066]
0 [336082]
1 00:46 SteveS [336066]
1 03:31 Water Modem [336067]
6 23:28 canalzone [336106]
1 00:41 SteveS [336070]
5 15:13 Frank G [336066]
0 [336066]
0 [336071]
10 22:35 JosephMendiola [336094]
8 20:21 SteveS [336085]
7 15:33 swksvolFF [336064]
5 06:16 Gruth McGurque5303 [336121]
1 06:36 Gruth McGurque5303 [336070]
Page 3: Non-WoT
2 22:40 JosephMendiola [336100]
5 18:56 tu3031 [336100]
0 [336067]
6 14:28 Jack Poodle7946 [336066]
6 13:14 Pappy [336064]
0 [336071]
0 [336067]
0 [336078]
0 [336065]
0 [336063]
4 18:47 tu3031 [336080]
7 20:56 gorb [336108]
5 18:07 Zhang Fei [336064]
India-Pakistan
What is Liberal Islam?
The word "Liberal Islam" provokes very diverse responses in Pakistain. Some laugh it away as an oxymoron, the more secular of us see it with cynicism as consisting of 'moderates' and non-practicing Moslems, and the orthodox treat it scornfully as heresy, justifying that Islam was already revealed as the perfect and unchanging religion, the complete code of life for all times to come. Amidst all this skepticism, the existence of Liberal Islam as a real phenomenon within the Islamic theological tradition is neglected. The marginalization of this mode of Islamic thought from public discourse and the resultant dominance of orthodoxy has resulted in grave consequences all over the world.

The practice of Islam as it exists all over the world, including Pakistain, can broadly be categorized into three traditions. The first is the Customary tradition, which is noted by the incorporation of regional practices and beliefs, such as reverence for saintly figures, forms of music and beliefs in spirit and magic. The other rapidly spreading tradition is Revivalist Islam, also called fundamentalism or Wahhabism, which aims to rid religion of all un-Islamic influences and envisions a return to the past in which Islam in its 'true' form was practiced. The third and much-neglected tradition of Liberal Islam is critical of both Customary and Revivalist traditions and maintains that Islam is compatible with the spirit of modernity if interpreted properly. It is a tradition within Islam that subscribes to liberal and modern values, such as opposition to theocracy, support for democracy, guarantees of the rights of women and non-Moslems in Islamic societies, defense of freedom of thought, and belief in the potential for human progress.

There are different approaches that theologians of Liberal Islam have taken to support their claims, and the tradition itself encompasses a heterogeneous group of thought. I see it as forming a whole spectrum of beliefs, progressing in a ladder-like fashion. Let's begin with the Brute-Force Liberal Islam. This approach separates religious law from public life and politics without attempting an adequate theological explanation of how or why it is justified in religion. Ataturk and his modernization of Turkey is a poignant example of it, and this is also very commonly adopted in Pakistain by the 'moderates', who can neither let go of Islam nor secularism, and hence live with an uneasy compromise.

Then we have a view-point that Koran and Sunnah if properly understood are already liberal in nature (Liberal Sharia). This is also a popular form of Liberal Islam, and understandably so, promoted these days by Javed Ahmad Ghamidi and the likes of him. It is also, however, the most vulnerable to attacks of conservative-minded scholars, as the proponents generally struggle against the well-developed orthodox theology with all the references to Koran and Hadith and Sunnah worked out in detail.

Progressing on the ladder, we come across Silent Sharia, the idea that Koran and Sunnah are silent on a number of matters, and this silence allows room for progress within Islam. This is another well-known position, but limited in its extent because as it turns out, Sharia with its claim to being a complete code of life is not silent on a whole lot of matters! Abd al-Raziq, an Egyptian scholar, provides an example of this thought when he argues that Sharia is silent on the specific form a government has to take, and thereby he paves the way for democracy in Islam.

Things begin to get heretical from here onwards. We have the Koranists, the group of theologians who claim that the Koran alone is valid as a source of Islamic law and Hadith must be rejected in general for a number of reasons that these scholars present (and debate very furiously!). Ghullam Ahmed Perwez of the Tolue-e-Islam movement is one of the familiar proponents. Being restricted to the Koran allows for greater leverage than having to deal with the whole of Shariah, and also allows for more creative ways of interpretation.

Next we have Contextual Islam which believes that the legal, moral and social dictates of Islamic law are context dependent, and therefore subject to modification with change in context. This may apply to Hadith only, or for some to both Koran and Hadith. There are proponents such as Allama Iqbal who believed that hadiths of legal nature were context-dependent, and Mahmoud Mohamed Taha from Sudan who believed that all the Medinan verses merely refer to the historical applicability of the Koranic essence revealed in Meccan verses to the society as it existed in the Prophet's time and place. Therefore, it is only the general principles elaborated in the Meccan verses that are to be followed, while the rest have to be reconstructed according to the needs of the time.

The most daring of Islamic scholars currently belong to the Interpreted Sharia mode which says that Sharia is divinely revealed, but the interpretations are human and fallible and can be subjected to critique. These theologians argue that interpretation is always based on human perspective and therefore cannot be granted a universal applicability, even though the scripture is divine. Fazlur Rehman of Pakistain is a well-known theologian of this tradition. He said that the Koran is the divine response, through the Prophet's mind, to the moral-social situation of the Prophet's Arabia, and a proper interpretation of the Koran would consist of two steps. The first step would be to understand the Koran's specific responses to specific situations; and the second step would be to generalize those answers and enunciate them as statements of generalized moral-social objectives that can be distilled from the religious texts in the light of socio-historical background. Another established thinker of Interpreted Sharia is the Algerian-French scholar Mohammed Arkoun, who applied Western hermeneutical techniques borrowed from structuralism and postmodernism to the Koran, and preferred a secular analysis keeping in view the historicity of tradition. Arkoun believed that traditional Islamic thought has restricted itself by creating boundaries of interpretations determining what is "thinkable"; Arkoun uses techniques of Deconstruction to uncover the "unthinkable" in Islamic tradition, the meanings which have been marginalized and oppressed. He argues for pluralism within Islam and acceptance of multiple interpretations.

While Moslem scholars have challenged interpretations, there are very few who have contested the literalism that is associated with the scripture; it is possible to maintain, like many Christians, that Koran is not the literal word of God, but was inspired by God and clothed in human language because of the constraints of the human condition. It is also consistent with the view that may see Islam as a mystic tradition rather than a revealed religion. This doctrine has not yet seen any significant adoption among Islamic theologians, but has been expressed in certain neo-Vedantist reviews of Islam and remains a potential mode of thought.

This is another popular version of Liberal Islam in Pakistain, often adopted by people who label themselves (mistakenly) as 'Sufi Moslems'. These adherents of Essence Islam, as I call it, maintain their distance from theological debates by stripping Islam to its bare essence and believe that to follow Islam is not to follow the rules of Sharia, which are human sociopolitical developments, rather it is to follow the essence of what Islam prescribes, such as morality, rationality, justice, modesty, etc., i.e. to be a good human being.

Such is the diversity and richness of Liberal Islam which has been much ignored. We have here a number of theological traditions in which Islam can be made compatible with modernity and liberalism. The only way these solutions can work is if Moslems are willing to do so, which sadly they still are not. As Daniel Pipes astutely remarks: "Islam can be whatever Moslems wish to make of it." The possibility of a modernist reform is there; templates and prototypes exist. The only question for Moslems is: Are you up for it?
Continued on Page 49
Posted by: trailing wife || 04/29/2012 00:00 || Comments || Link || [336072 views] Top|| File under:

#1  if the salafists are willing to kill the liberals and the liberals are not willing to kill the salafists, it is pretty evident who is going to win
Posted by: lord garth || 04/29/2012 0:09 Comments || Top||

#2  One that wears a boom belt without rusty nails?
Posted by: g(r)omgoru || 04/29/2012 1:30 Comments || Top||

#3  Then why are we friends with Wahhabism(Saudi)if these are the anti western/anti modern strain of Islam?
Posted by: Gruth McGurque5303 || 04/29/2012 6:10 Comments || Top||

#4  > What is Liberal Islam?

Oxymoron.
Posted by: Bright Pebbles || 04/29/2012 8:12 Comments || Top||

#5  Liberal Islam? Someone who takes hostages ... but doesn't eat them?
Posted by: Sgt. Mom || 04/29/2012 8:17 Comments || Top||

#6  Liberal Islam, see heresy.

her·e·sy
n. pl. her·e·sies

1. An opinion or a doctrine at variance with established religious beliefs

2. Any opinion or belief that is or is thought to be contrary to official or established theory
Posted by: Procopius2k || 04/29/2012 10:23 Comments || Top||

#7  Iranian Homosexuals and Mohammad Cat.
Posted by: swksvolFF || 04/29/2012 16:27 Comments || Top||

#8  Liberal Islam is an alliance of two groups that hate western civilization. See liberal and see Islam for details on the groups. Also referred to as the true Axis of Evil.
Posted by: Rjschwarz || 04/29/2012 17:11 Comments || Top||


Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Iran and Israel: Comparing military machines
Posted by: tipper || 04/29/2012 17:42 || Comments || Link || [336064 views] Top|| File under:



Who's in the News
32[untagged]
8Govt of Pakistan
4Govt of Syria
3Arab Spring
3Govt of Sudan
1PLO
1Taliban
1al-Qaeda in Arabia
1TTP
1Govt of Iran
1al-Qaeda

Bookmark
E-Mail Me

The Classics
The O Club
Rantburg Store
The Bloids
The Never-ending Story
Thugburg
Gulf War I
The Way We Were
Bio

Merry-Go-Blog











On Sale now!


A multi-volume chronology and reference guide set detailing three years of the Mexican Drug War between 2010 and 2012.

Rantburg.com and borderlandbeat.com correspondent and author Chris Covert presents his first non-fiction work detailing the drug and gang related violence in Mexico.

Chris gives us Mexican press dispatches of drug and gang war violence over three years, presented in a multi volume set intended to chronicle the death, violence and mayhem which has dominated Mexico for six years.
Click here for more information

Meet the Mods
In no particular order...
Steve White
Seafarious
tu3031
badanov
sherry
ryuge
GolfBravoUSMC
Bright Pebbles
trailing wife
Gloria
Fred
Besoeker
Glenmore
Frank G
3dc
Skidmark

Two weeks of WOT
Sun 2012-04-29
  Syria Troops Kill 10 Rebels in Damascus Region
Sat 2012-04-28
   21 Taliban Insurgents Killed in Clashes
Fri 2012-04-27
  Separate bomb blasts rock Nigeria's newspapers, at least six killed
Thu 2012-04-26
  Libya bans religious, tribal or ethnic parties
Wed 2012-04-25
  Sacked Yemen Air Force Commander Quits Post
Tue 2012-04-24
  India orders deportation of 10 French nationals over Maoist links
Mon 2012-04-23
  Kazakh court sends 47 men to prison for terrorism
Sun 2012-04-22
  Tons of Explosives Seized from Militants Planning Attack in Kabul
Sat 2012-04-21
  Sudan Rebels Kill 79 Troops, Militia in Blue Nile
Fri 2012-04-20
  8 die in Michoacan state as conflict goes hot
Thu 2012-04-19
  Qaeda leader suicide bombs himself and family in Iraq
Wed 2012-04-18
  Hadi Refuses to receive Former Yemen President
Tue 2012-04-17
  UN Camp in South Sudan Targeted by Sudanese Warplanes
Mon 2012-04-16
  US drone strike kills senior al-Qaeda Militant in Yemen
Sun 2012-04-15
  Afghan capital hit by blasts, gun attack

Better than the average link...



Rantburg was assembled from recycled algorithms in the United States of America. No trees were destroyed in the production of this weblog. We did hurt some, though. Sorry.
3.235.42.157
Help keep the Burg running! Paypal:
WoT Operations (22)    WoT Background (19)    Non-WoT (13)    (0)    (0)