How 620,000 were killed in a four-year war
A recent article published in The Lancet medical journal claimed that about 655,000 Iraqis were killled as a result of the war in Iraq during the first three years and four months -- from March 2003 to July 2006.
As a comparison, the American Civil War lasted four years, from April 1861 to April 1865. Studies have concluded that during those four years about 620,000 people were killed as a result of that war.
On the Confederate side about 94,000 were killed in battles and about 164,000 were killed by other causes (disease, deaths in prisoner-of-war camps, military accidents, executions, etc.). On the Union side about 110,070 were killed in battles and about 250,152 were killed by other causes.
Here is a list of some Civil War battles, showing the numbers of combatants and killed in combat.
Battle of Gettysburg
Confederate soldiers: 75,000 killed: 4,708
Union soldiers: 82,289 killed: 3,155
Battle of Chickamauga
Confederate soldiers: 66,326 killed: 2,312
Union soldiers: 58,222 killed: 1,657
Battle of Chancellorsville
Confederate soldiers: 60,892 killed: 1,683
Union soldiers: 133,868 killed: 1,574
Battle of Spotsylvania
Confederate soldiers: 50,000 killed: 2,725
Union soldiers: 83,000 killed: 1,467
Battle of Antietam
Confederate soldiers: 51,844 killed: 1,546
Union soldiers: 75,316 killed: 2,108
Battle of The Wilderness
Confederate soldiers: 61,025 killed: 1,495
Union soldiers: 101,895 killed: 2,246
Second Battle of Manassas (Bull Run)
Confederate soldiers: 48,527 killed: 1,553
Union soldiers: 75,696 killed: 1,747
Battle of Stone's River
Confederate soldiers: 37,739 killed: 1,294
Union soldiers: 41,400 killed: 1,730
Battle of Shiloh
Confederate soldiers: 40,335 killed: 1,723
Union soldiers: 62,682 -- killed: 1,754
Battle of Fort Donelson
Confederate soldiers: 21,000 killed: 1,127
Union soldiers: 27,000 -- killed: 1,976
Battle of Fredericksburg
Confederate soldiers: 72,500 - killed: 608 killed
Union soldiers: 114,000 - killed: 1,284 killed
This list could be extended to include many more large battles.
How many battles in Iraq have involved such large numbers of combatants and casualties? How many platoon-sized firefights and car bombings would it take to cause hundreds of thousands of deaths?
Posted by: Mike Sylwester 2006-10-25 |