|
A Muslim Call to the Israelis
These days the Middle East is once again the scene of bloodshed. Israeli troops are employing the most ruthless and cruel methods against Palestinians. The Israeli Army is ruthlessly bombing Palestinian settlements, shooting at children and trying to make Palestine uninhabitable.Some Palestinian radicals, on the other hand, are attacking Israeli civilian targets and spreading violence with their terrible suicide attacks aimed at women and children.
Our heartfelt wish as Muslims is for the anger and hatred on both sides to die down, for the bloodshed to stop and for peace to come to the Middle East. We oppose both the Israeli killing of the innocent and the bombing of innocent Israelis by some radical Palestinians.
| You need to stop wringing your hands and start wringing some necks -- the necks of your Muslim brothers who continue to blow up women and children in pizza parlors. Right now much of the intelligent civilized world understands that you don't really mean it, since you write fine words in English and spit vitriol in Arabic. Start telling your brethen Paleo pals in Arabic that if they don't stop killing innocent Israelis, you're going to kill them. And then kill a few. And then we can judge how serious you are. |
In our view, the most important condition for this blind conflict to come to an end and for real peace to be established in the Middle East is for both sides to genuinely and honestly understand and implement their own beliefs. The conflict between Israel and Palestine has taken on the identity of a 'religious war' between Jews and Muslims, whereas in fact there is absolutely no reason for such a war of religion. Both Jews and Muslims believe in God, love and respect the same prophets, and possess the same moral principles. They are not enemies. On the contrary, they are allies in a world in which atheism and hatred of religion are widespread.
| But the Jews have to believe in God your way, or you're going to kill them. Or they have to submit to being dhimmis, pay the tax and not object too much when a Muslim commits some atrocity against them. That was the history of Jews for a thousand years in Iraq, Egypt and Syria. So far you're espousing the fine principle of "what's mine is mine, and we'll talk about what's yours." Don't be surprised if the Israelis turn you down. |
Based on that fundamental principle, we call on the Israelis (and all Jews):
1) Muslims and Jews believe in one God, the creator of the universe and all living things. We are all God's servants, and to Him we shall return. So why hate each other? The holy books we believe in are different, but we all abide by those books because we believe they are the revelations of God. So why should we fight one another?
| Why do Sunnis fight Shi'a? Why do both hate Alawites? Why do Muslims of one sect commit murder against Muslims of another sect? You guys all believe in the same holy book and you can't even get along. When you can figure out why you're fighting each other and then put a stop to it, you'll be close to where Christians are today (Northern Ireland excepted). And then perhaps you can call for a truce with the Jews. |
2) Instead of Muslims, would the Israelis rather live among atheists or pagans? The Bible is full of passages describing the terrible cruelties inflicted on the Jews by pagans. The terrible genocide and cruelty inflicted on the Jews by atheists and unbelievers (such as the Nazis, anti-Semitic racists or communist regimes such as Stalin's Russia) are clear for all to see. The atheist forces in question hated the Jews because they believed in God, and that is why they oppressed them. Are not Jews and Muslims on the same side against these atheist, communist or racist forces that hate them both?
| The atheists, communists and racist forces are exploding young people in pizza parlors. That's been the province of fine Muslim terrorist groups so far -- Hamas, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad, the Al-Aqsa Martyr brigades. I could go on. These are the people trying to murder Jews. The Atheist Alliance, so far as I know, hasn't been creeping into kibutzes to murder sleeping Jewish children. You seem like an intelligent soul, Peter, so you tell us -- who should the Jews take a stand against first: a peaceful atheist or a Muslim wearing a bomb belt? |
3) Muslims and Jews love and respect the same prophets. The prophets Abraham, Isaac, Joseph, Moses or David are at least as important for Muslims as they are for Jews. The lands where these holy figures lived and served God are at least as holy for Muslims as they are for Jews. So why drown those lands in blood and tears?
| Because one side is willing to live in peace, and the other side demands the whole enchilada. It's the Paleos and their brethen Arabs who demand that Palestine stretch from the Jordan to the Med. Look at the average map of the Middle East, rendered by a Muslim cartographer: do you see any space for "Israel"? |
4) The fundamental values of Israel are also sacred to us Muslims. The word 'Israel' is the name of the Prophet Jacob, who is praised in the Koran and remembered with great respect by Muslims. The Magen David (Star of David) is the holy symbol of the prophet David for us too. According to the Koran, synagogues are places of worship that Muslims must protect. (Koran, 22:40). So why should members of the two religions not live together in peace?
| Instead of trying to convert us on Rantburg, you should fly to Mecca and preach to the crowds on their Haj. There's quite a crowd right now, you might still catch them. Tell them how holy Jacob and David are, and how they should learn to live in peace with the Jews. If you live, let us know how it went. |
5) The Torah commands Jews to establish peace and security, not to occupy other lands and spill blood. The people of Israel are described as 'a light unto the nations.' As Rabbi Dovi Weiss has said:
"The Jewish people are commanded by Almighty God to live in peace with all peoples and nations on the face of the globe. Our agenda is simple It is to humbly worship the Creator at all times. As Torah Jews we are called upon to feel and express our sense of compassion when any person or group of human beings suffers."1
| And where is the mullah, the iman, the wise, holy Islamic scholar who is preaching similar words to his flock? Every Friday in the mosques in Egypt, in Jordan, in Saudi Arabia, the holy men preach words of hate and destruction to the assembled believers. Show me the Arab equivalent of Dovi Weiss. |
If the Israelis continue to treat the Palestinians as they are now, they may be unable to account for that to God. Those Palestinians who kill innocent Israelis, on the other hand, may be unable to account for those murders. Is it not a duty in the eyes of God to put an end to the fighting, which is dragging both sides deeper into satanic violence?
| The Israelis have offered peace several times: you might argue about some of the terms, but there they were. Yasser Arafat rejected those terms each time and kick-started the cycle of violence. Explain to us how peaceful Muslims can abide this. |
We invite all Jews to consider these facts. God commands us Muslims to invite Jews and Christians to a 'common formula':
Say, "O People of the Book! Let us rally to a common formula to be binding on both us and you: That we worship none but God; that we associate no partners with Him; that we erect not, from among ourselves, Lords and patrons other than God." (Koran, 3:64)
This is our call to the Jews, a People of the Book: As people who believe in God and obey His commands, let us come together in the common formula of 'faith.' Let us love God, the Lord and Creator of all of us. Let us abide by His commands. Let us pray to God to lead us further on the path of righteousness. Let us bring love, compassion and peace to each other and the world, not hostility, blood and tears.
| Read what you just wrote: you pretty much demand that the Jews become Muslims. That isn't going to happen. When it doesn't, you'll justify the renewed violence. It's in the Quran somewhere, I'm sure you can look it up. |
That is where the solution to the Palestinian question and other conflicts in the world lies. Come, let us find a solution together. The deaths and suffering of so many innocent people remind us every day what an urgent task this is.
HOW CAN THE PALESTINIAN QUESTION BE RESOLVED?
Based on the principles of toleration and moderation we have outlined above, it is possible to solve the Palestinian question, which has caused so much bloodshed in the Middle East over the last 50 years. In our view, the establishment of peace depends on these two conditions:
1) Israel must immediately withdraw from all the territories it occupied during the 1967 war including East Jerusalem. The occupation that has existed since must come to an end. That is an obligation under international law, U.N. Security Council resolutions and the concept of justice. All of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip must be recognized as belonging to an independent State of Palestine.
| There's no reason for Israel to withdraw to the 1967 line, or to the 1948 line, or to the original UN mandate line of 1947. Your brethen Arabs started four wars and lost all four. When you lose, you don't get to tell everyone how the peace agreement will be shaped. Your first step is to acknowledge that you lost the wars, and try to figure out what the Israelis will let you have. |
2) East Jerusalem, which is home to the important temples of all three theistic religions must be administered by the Palestinian administration, yet this city should have an exclusive status. Jerusalem must be made a free city in which members of all three religions can carry out their obligations in peace.
| When the Arabs ran Jerusalem Jews were prohibited from visiting their holy sites. Now that the Israelis run Jerusalem, both Jews and Muslims have complete access to their holy sites. If the PA gets control of East Jerusalem again, how long before Jews are banned from the wailing wall? There's a history there that you won't even acknowledge. |
When these conditions are brought about, Israelis and Palestinians will have recognized each others' right to exist, shared the Palestinian lands, and resolved the status of Jerusalem, the subject of a great argument, in a manner satisfactory to the members of all three religions.
Our hope is that the constant hostility of the last 50 years or so, the prejudice, killing and slaughter will come to an end, that the innocent Palestinian people can secure a homeland that can provide them with the peace, security and well-being they deserve, and that Israel will abandon its policy of aggression and occupation, that wrongs its own people as well as the Palestinians, thus allowing it to live in peace with its neighbours within its legal pre-1967 borders.
| Again, there's nothing especially binding about the 1967 borders. You lost. They won. Figure out what you can negotiate for and be happy with that. |
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1-"The Torah Demands Justice for the Palestinians" Presented by Rabbi Dovid Weiss of NKIAt Time Square in Manhattan on Friday afternoon, June 1, 2001. http://www.netureikarta.org/speeches.htm
Posted by: Peter 2005-01-19 |
