You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
International
Gorbachev admits it was all propaganda
2002-03-12
  • Mikhail Gorbachev says the Soviet communism he served most of his life was "pure propaganda." The former Soviet leader told a Columbia University audience on Monday that by the time he rose to power, with Soviet satellites in space, the ruling politicians "were discussing the problem of toothpaste, the problem of detergent, and they had to create a commission of the Politburo to make sure that women have pantyhose."

    Speaking in Russian, Gorbachev offered his views a decade after he helped topple this "unreal system" with reforms dubbed perestroika. Before that, he said, Soviet politicians operated with lies. "We, including I, were saying, 'Capitalism is moving toward a catastrophe, whereas we are developing well.' Of course, that was pure propaganda. In fact, our country was lagging behind," Gorbachev said.

    Change didn't come easily, either. Gorbachev said perestroika spun out of control after Boris Yeltsin took over in 1991. Instead of a gradual shift to democracy, Yeltsin promised Russians that they "would start moving toward paradise quickly, directly," Gorbachev said. "Well, we did move directly -- but into an abyss," with the economy collapsing and many former Soviet republics declaring independence, he said. "It is chaos that (Russian President) Vladimir Putin inherited. Chaos in the economy, chaos in the social sphere, chaos in the federation, chaos in the army, chaos everywhere."

    Now, Gorbachev said, Putin must create new economic incentives. "Today is our last hope. If it fails, we could see a very difficult situation in Russia," Gorbachev said.

    The former Soviet leader said his Moscow-based Gorbachev Foundation is making a contribution by developing ties between Russian and foreign high-tech companies. He said such business would help slow his country's "brain drain."
    Take that, Indymedia. Take that, Berkeley City Council. Take that, all you Kommie Kiddies.

    What he doesn't dwell on his how much the ruling elite in the Soviet Union bought its own propaganda, despite the evidence before its eyes. Most of them did swallow it. Especially in the middle and lower echelons of the bureaucracy the country was swarming with true believers. Even the August Plotters were motivated overall by their belief in the system. Gorbachev's claim to greatness - and he was a great man - is that he recognized the need for change before the system fell down around his ears and he had the guts to try and do something about it. Glasnost' led to Perestroika, but the perestroika that was actually called for was more than even he believed. The Soviet Union was headed for something similar to what prevailed during the Yeltsin years even under Gorbachev's administration - all he would have been able to do was try to blunt some of the worst effects. The August Coup finished any possibility of that, and the secession of the Baltic States finished off the Soyuz itself.

    I even think Yeltsin's intentions were good at the first, before the booze and his family and "friends" did him in. His moment of greatness came when he defended the Parliament, an act of physical bravery that Russians will remember. The words he said were the words of a man who wanted to see real democracy and real change in Russia.

    Gorbachev's greatness was moral; it took a deep kind of courage to change a system that was designed to be unchangable. 50 years from now Yeltsin will be a footnote and the world - and Russia - will remember Gorbachev for what he was.
    Screed Warning! Gorbachev always gets me over torqued....

    "Gorbachev began his speech by outlining his country's history, starting with the 1917 revolution..."

    What Gorbachev, as well as most of the CCCP apparatchiki forgot is that Russia's been around much longer than 1917, and most of the horror of the Communist period was presaged in other episodes of opening to the West and reactionary clamp downs:
    -Ivan the Terrible instituted a series of internal reforms of the Muscovite state that might have saved that dynasty, but then allied himself with the forces of conservative reaction after the death of his first wife. He finally killed off his sons as "traitors".
    -the Petrine reforms were followed by a series of reactionary autocrats who reversed most of the spirit of Peter's opening of trade and society to more Western patterns.
    -Alexander II's liberation of the serfs was followed by the reaction under Alexander III which killed off land reform and led to the rural conditions which caused the economic disfunctionalities which helped cause the 1905 and 1917 Revolutions.
    -the establishment of the Duma in 1906 was followed by Nicholas II's attempt to recreate Tsarist absolutism, which resulted in the political disfunction that was obviously leading to a Russian defeat in WW I if the February Revolution hadn't intervened.

    Gorbachev never showed any conception of historical precedent, and as Twain would remark was compelled to repeat it. It is a poor way to make a living pandering to various Westerners who actually pay him to shed these Krokodil Tears at such cited functions.
    Posted by Tom Roberts 3/12/2002 10:39:26 AM
  • Posted by:Fred Pruitt

    00:00