You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
New statute may lead to dictatorship: Ex-Afghan president
2004-01-08
A strong presidential system enshrined in Afghanistan’s new constitution, tailor-made for Afghan leader Hamid Karzai, could lead to a dictatorship, a former president of the country said yesterday.
That's the risk, isn't it? The alternative is eternal deadlock...
Former president Burhanuddin Rabbani, who led the opposition against Karzai at the constitutional loya jirga (Grand Assembly), said the impact of the new charter, passed on Sunday after weeks of wrangling between rival ethnic factions, would be limited. He accused government ministers of meddling in the 22-day debate and said the constitution was not one that represented a national consensus as claimed by its architects. “The discussions were held on limited issues and they cannot resolve the broader problems,” Rabbani said in an interview. “The consensus was on basic issues and emergency steps were taken to resolve them, but the major and fundamental issues were not solved,” he said. “If this issue is not dealt with, I am concerned that this will push Afghanistan to a dictatorship.” The bearded Islamic professor was among the overwhelming majority of 502 delegates who stood up to show their support for the charter, although the dissent that characterised the debate has refused to go away. Rabbani was instrumental in bringing together more than 200 delegates from ethnic minorities including his Tajik clan, Hazaras and Uzbeks, who argued for a stronger parliament.
Posted by:Fred Pruitt

#7  Taking the advice of Rabbani just because he is a former president is as silly as taking the advice of Jimmy Carter.

LOL. Game's changed Elroy... hand me the rabbit paddle...

New Orleans JFM. You would thrive.
Posted by: Shipman   2004-1-8 3:36:12 PM  

#6  Now-after-Karzai, the guy with the biggest guns gets to pick the next Karzai. Paging Donald Rumsfeld......
Posted by: john   2004-1-8 12:55:46 PM  

#5  Rabbaani was a notorious idiot, power hungry and, at least politically, dishonest. In his last years Commander Massood, despite belonging to his party despised him.

Taking the advice of Rabbani just because he is a former president is as silly as taking the advice of Jimmy Carter.
Posted by: JFM   2004-1-8 12:36:04 PM  

#4  A strong Prez is good when it's Karzai. Now -after- Karzai...
Posted by: someone   2004-1-8 11:51:11 AM  

#3  Hey, Mr. Rabbani -- nobody said it'd be easy. Run for office, keep talking, and it'll be as much of a success as the Afghani people allow it to be. The U.S. Constitution wasn't a product of nationwide consensus either, but it served...
Posted by: snellenr   2004-1-8 11:02:29 AM  

#2  He IS correct. Afghanistan's gonna need a George Washington, not only to lead it, but to set an example by being able to stop leading it.
Posted by: Ptah   2004-1-8 7:46:02 AM  

#1  Sore loser!
Posted by: Anonymous2U   2004-1-8 12:43:45 AM  

00:00