You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Short Attention Span Theater-
Witch King "Slain"
2004-01-15
If the Beeb had been at the Pelennor

Minas Tirith -- The Lord of the Nazgûl was reported “slain” Thursday March 15 at the Pelennor Fields just outside Minas Tirith. Witnesses say that Lady Éowyn of the Rohirrim “threatened” the chief of Sauron’s Nine Ringwraiths and “challenged” him. They say he “told” her that no living man may “hinder” him, at which point she “revealed” she was a woman. It is reported that she “slew” his mount and they “fought” until a Halfling, Meriadoc Brandybuck, “struck” at the Witch-King’s knee whereupon he “collapsed” and Éowyn “slew” him. Éowyn and Brandybuck were unavailable for comment; both are reported to be “badly wounded.”

Our embedded journalist Ilmendol reports that thousands of Rohirrim, Gondorians, and Rangers were slain, including King Théoden of Rohan, Lord Forlong of the Lossarnach, and Halbarad, “King” Aragorn’s standard-bearer. “This war is a quagmire,” Ilmendol said. “And what of those Halflings Faramir met at Henneth Annûn?”
Posted by:Korora

#30  Aris, remember that Gandalf pitied even his slaves. And Orcs were 'bred' in the 1st age by Morgoth / Melkor by tormenting, twisting, and torturing elves.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2004-1-15 11:00:37 PM  

#29  Kinda like the Jihadis and Paleo bombers. They have been programmed to kill and destroy. Reprogramming them will require all the kings horses and men, so to speak. Heh heh.
Posted by: Alaska Paul   2004-1-15 6:28:51 PM  

#28  Actually Aragorn set aside part of Mordor (the only fertile part, the areas around lake Nurnen) for the "slaves of Mordor".

***
And the King pardoned the Easterlings that had given themselves up, sent them away free, and he made peace with the peoples of Harad; and the slaves of Mordor he released and gave to them all the lands about Lake Nurnen to be their own.
***

When reading this, I felt it to mean the human slaves of Mordor, though it is perhaps slightly ambiguous.

The matter of Orcs is a complicated one, which Tolkien himself philosophically (and theologically) strove with near the end of his life -- and probably too long and (even more) off-topic to discuss here.
Posted by: Aris Katsaris   2004-1-15 1:40:59 PM  

#27  LOL! Seems like HL did one on the Dessert Planet too.
Posted by: Shipman   2004-1-15 1:28:44 PM  

#26  Shipman--The Harvard Lampoon was, back in 1969:

"Toes. I love hairy toes," she moaned, forcing him down on the silvered carpet. Her tiny, pink toes caressed the luxuriant fur of his instep..."
Posted by: Angie Schultz   2004-1-15 1:24:03 PM  

#25  Is anybody but me bored of the rings?
Posted by: Shipman   2004-1-15 1:14:52 PM  

#24  how about Sap for Mithril? We could send in the Ents and the dark trees again.

Posted by: rkb   2004-1-15 12:09:58 PM  

#23  No Blood for Mithril!
Posted by: Steve   2004-1-15 11:21:32 AM  

#22  LH: Seriously, in LOTR it says that after the victory King Aragon sets aside part of Mordor for the Orcs and Trolls to live in...

Oh, I see. A reservation. And what will happen when mithril is found on the reservation, hmmm? What about the rights of the orcs and trolls then?
Posted by: Angie Schultz   2004-1-15 9:58:17 AM  

#21  Yeah? Then why didn't he let the ents find their chicks?

FANGORN NEEDS WOMEN!
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2004-1-15 9:30:41 AM  

#20  just to point out anon, this is a war against SAURON, not against the ORCS. (Seriously, in LOTR it says that after the victory King Aragon sets aside part of Mordor for the Orcs and Trolls to live in - Tolkien werent no pacifist, but he werent no genocidaire either)
Posted by: liberalhawk   2004-1-15 9:09:13 AM  

#19  I suppose Barad Dur is just a li'l old cultural monument, too.
Posted by: Mike   2004-1-15 8:39:45 AM  

#18  'The Duly Elected Wiccan President of Minas Morgul and Angmar'

Lol! And I suppose he's from the Republic of Mordor, which is a beautiful country filled with innocent goblins and orcs?
Posted by: Anonymous   2004-1-15 2:22:31 AM  

#17  Al-reuters refuses to use the term "witch king" and instead refers to him as 'The Duly Elected Wiccan President of Minas Morgul and Angmar'.
Posted by: 4thInfVet   2004-1-15 12:42:57 AM  

#16  ...Would thisss be from Reutersss, my...precioussss...?

Mike
Posted by: Mike Kozlowski   2004-1-15 12:42:10 AM  

#15  Aris, remember that Gandalf pitied even his slaves. And Orcs were 'bred' in the 1st age by Morgoth / Melkor by tormenting, twisting, and torturing elves.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2004-1-15 11:00:37 PM  

#14  Kinda like the Jihadis and Paleo bombers. They have been programmed to kill and destroy. Reprogramming them will require all the kings horses and men, so to speak. Heh heh.
Posted by: Alaska Paul   2004-1-15 6:28:51 PM  

#13  Actually Aragorn set aside part of Mordor (the only fertile part, the areas around lake Nurnen) for the "slaves of Mordor".

***
And the King pardoned the Easterlings that had given themselves up, sent them away free, and he made peace with the peoples of Harad; and the slaves of Mordor he released and gave to them all the lands about Lake Nurnen to be their own.
***

When reading this, I felt it to mean the human slaves of Mordor, though it is perhaps slightly ambiguous.

The matter of Orcs is a complicated one, which Tolkien himself philosophically (and theologically) strove with near the end of his life -- and probably too long and (even more) off-topic to discuss here.
Posted by: Aris Katsaris   2004-1-15 1:40:59 PM  

#12  LOL! Seems like HL did one on the Dessert Planet too.
Posted by: Shipman   2004-1-15 1:28:44 PM  

#11  Shipman--The Harvard Lampoon was, back in 1969:

"Toes. I love hairy toes," she moaned, forcing him down on the silvered carpet. Her tiny, pink toes caressed the luxuriant fur of his instep..."
Posted by: Angie Schultz   2004-1-15 1:24:03 PM  

#10  Is anybody but me bored of the rings?
Posted by: Shipman   2004-1-15 1:14:52 PM  

#9  how about Sap for Mithril? We could send in the Ents and the dark trees again.

Posted by: rkb   2004-1-15 12:09:58 PM  

#8  No Blood for Mithril!
Posted by: Steve   2004-1-15 11:21:32 AM  

#7  LH: Seriously, in LOTR it says that after the victory King Aragon sets aside part of Mordor for the Orcs and Trolls to live in...

Oh, I see. A reservation. And what will happen when mithril is found on the reservation, hmmm? What about the rights of the orcs and trolls then?
Posted by: Angie Schultz   2004-1-15 9:58:17 AM  

#6  Yeah? Then why didn't he let the ents find their chicks?

FANGORN NEEDS WOMEN!
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2004-1-15 9:30:41 AM  

#5  just to point out anon, this is a war against SAURON, not against the ORCS. (Seriously, in LOTR it says that after the victory King Aragon sets aside part of Mordor for the Orcs and Trolls to live in - Tolkien werent no pacifist, but he werent no genocidaire either)
Posted by: liberalhawk   2004-1-15 9:09:13 AM  

#4  I suppose Barad Dur is just a li'l old cultural monument, too.
Posted by: Mike   2004-1-15 8:39:45 AM  

#3  'The Duly Elected Wiccan President of Minas Morgul and Angmar'

Lol! And I suppose he's from the Republic of Mordor, which is a beautiful country filled with innocent goblins and orcs?
Posted by: Anonymous   2004-1-15 2:22:31 AM  

#2  Al-reuters refuses to use the term "witch king" and instead refers to him as 'The Duly Elected Wiccan President of Minas Morgul and Angmar'.
Posted by: 4thInfVet   2004-1-15 12:42:57 AM  

#1  ...Would thisss be from Reutersss, my...precioussss...?

Mike
Posted by: Mike Kozlowski   2004-1-15 12:42:10 AM  

00:00