You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Middle East
Germany: We’ll free prisoners for Arad
2004-01-26
The German government has promised to free two Lebanese and an Iranian currently serving life sentences in Germany, and also to try to persuade France and Switzerland to release Lebanese prisoners they hold, in exchange for the return of missing Israeli navigator Ron Arad or his body.
That's another advantage to the death penalty: once their necks've been stretched, nobody's going to take hostages to get them unstretched...
The German pledge is included in the prisoner exchange deal reached by Israel and Hezbollah through German mediation. The deal comprises two stages. In the first stage, to take place on Thursday, Israel will release 435 Arab prisoners - 400 Palestinians, 23 Lebanese and 12 nationals of other countries - and one German, in exchange for the return of businessman Elhanan Tennenbaum and the bodies of three slain soldiers - Benny Avraham, Adi Avitan and Omar Suwad. The following day, Israel will also hand over the bodies of 59 Lebanese buried in Israel, as well as any information it has on 24 Lebanese who have been missing since 1982 and maps of mines laid by Israel in Lebanese territory. The second stage deals with the attempt to find information about Arad and bring him back to Israel. A joint German-Hezbollah committee will be set up to conduct the search for information, with indirect help from "other sources" - an apparent reference to Iran.
Which is said to be where he went...
If solid information is obtained - meaning DNA samples to confirm his identity and proof of whether he is alive or dead -Israel will release Samir Kuntar, the only Lebanese prisoner who is not being freed this week, and also the only one convicted of murdering civilians in Israel rather than soldiers in Lebanon.
This is a damned dirty deal. And as soon as it's done, Hezb is going to kidnap somebody else...
However, the agreement is deliberately vague on this point, saying in another place that Kuntar will be released once the discussion of his case ends, and that the parties hope this will be in two to three months. If Arad is located, negotiations will begin over his return to Israel. Any deal would include the release of the three prisoners held in Germany, all of whom were involved in the murder of an Iranian dissident in a Berlin restaurant in 1992. Israel will also have to release additional Arab prisoners, mainly Palestinians.
Posted by:TS

#7  Or you float the rumor that half of 'em are spies and watch them get shot as 'collaborators'; the IDF saves on bullets as an added bonus!
Posted by: Raj   2004-1-26 12:56:13 PM  

#6  5 - unless they've managed to turn some of these into spies
Posted by: Frank G   2004-1-26 12:15:42 PM  

#5  A Middle-Eastern dictatorship could simply "bargain" to execute prisoners until the hostage is released. Lacking that capacity, the best overall alternative is not negotiating. But the West hasn't been abused enough yet to have either kind of gutsy response.
Posted by: Tom   2004-1-26 8:46:36 AM  

#4  4.
Israel just released 4or5 hundred terrorists.Then had to bury more Israelie dead.
Posted by: Raptor   2004-1-26 7:31:04 AM  

#3  I count three, and I'm sure there are plenty more.
Posted by: Scooter McGruder   2004-1-26 3:41:26 AM  

#2  There's at least two of us...
Posted by: Fred   2004-1-26 2:47:56 AM  

#1  Am I the only reader who thinks that trading hundreds of fully-functional jihadi gunnies for a live hostage and three dead ones makes no sense?

It's a nice gesture that the Israelis want to get their soldier's bodies back, but doing so is not worth putting these murderous jihadis back into circulation.

Now, giving them the bodies of a couple hundred DEAD jihadis in return for the dead troops might be a better deal.
Posted by: Rivrdog   2004-1-26 1:23:56 AM  

00:00