You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Middle East
Sharon considers placing some Arab-Israelis under PA control
2004-02-03
EFL
Prime Minister Ariel Sharon is considering redrawing Israel’s border to place parts of Israel’s Arab population under Palestinian control in a final peace deal. The official stressed that any such move would have to be accepted by Israeli Arabs and come only as part of a final treaty with the Palestinians. However, the idea threatened to arouse the deepest fears of Israel’s Arab minority and drew immediate criticism from an Israeli Arab leader. Roughly 20 percent of Israel’s 6.6 million citizens are Arabs. Unlike their Palestinian counterparts in the West Bank and Gaza, which Israel captured in 1967, Israelis Arabs have the right to vote, receive Israeli social services and can work inside Israel.
They might not want to trade that for the blessings of Hamas administration or the tender mercies of al-Aqsa Martyrs shaking them down for protection money...
Relations with the Jewish majority, however, are often tense. Israeli Arabs have higher unemployment rates and lower incomes than Jews, and complain of frequent discrimination. In October 2000, Israeli police killed 13 Israeli-Arabs during riots that followed the outbreak of Israel-Palestinian violence, which some Israeli-Arabs supported.
I think it's the religion, rather than something congenital...
Sharon has recently floated a series of ideas aimed at reducing "friction" with the Palestinians. The possibility of placing some Israeli Arabs under Palestinian control is part of that goal, Israeli officials said.
Y'mean, like scaring them into better behavior? I dunno. They're not real good on cause and effect...
In return, Israel would seek parts of the West Bank, where more than 200,000 Israeli settlers live among some 2 million Palestinians.
They'd like al-Aqsa Martyrs for neighbors even less than the Israeli Arabs would...
On Tuesday, Sharon was quoted in the Maariv daily as saying he is examining a possible population exchange with the help of drawing a border between Israel and a future Palestinian state. "I asked that it be examined legally. It is a complicated problem. I don’t have an answer on the matter yet, but I am certainly checking it," he told the newspaper. The senior Israeli official said exchanging populations is "an old method that has been used elsewhere."
The Assyrians used to do it all the time...
"It’s not a plan for now," the official stressed. "It will only be on the agenda when there is an agreement between the two sides ... If we come to an agreement with the Palestinians, then it will be raised." Ahmed Tibi, an Israeli Arab lawmaker, said he opposes the idea. "We are talking about a dangerous, anti-democratic suggestion, which will bring about a schism between the state and its Arab citizens," Tibi said.
He couldn’t comment further as he indicated he had a sudden need to change his underpants
He said residents of Israel’s Arab towns "are not pawns that Sharon can play with."
Wouldn’t this be just ducky! Arabs clamoring to live in Israel instead of under Arab rule; Israel affirming it’s Jewish identity; paleos scratching their head over whether this is a good or a bad thing. yummy.
Posted by:PlanetDan

#11  As Bush said (paraphrasing liberally, of course) - "are with you with us or the terrorists?"
Posted by: Frank G   2004-2-3 9:33:15 PM  

#10  DenBeste wrote an interesting but looong discussion
Dave, I think that sums up all of his posts! ;)
Posted by: Anonymous   2004-2-3 8:34:40 PM  

#9  DenBeste wrote an interesting but looong discussion at: http://denbeste.nu/cd_log_entries/2004/01/UpagainsttheWall.shtml
regarding this issue
Posted by: Dave   2004-2-3 7:46:51 PM  

#8  This has been under discussion for a long time. Parts of the Galilie are 90-100% Arab. Among the most interesting arabs are the E. Jerusalemites who, in a secret and free election, would almost certainly vote to be Israelis but who don't dare say so.
Posted by: mhw   2004-2-3 6:04:54 PM  

#7  but it's vital that the Israeli Arabs be integrated into the economy

Not sure I agree.

Saudi Arabia is a Muslim state.

Iran is a Muslim state.

Why can't Israel be a Jewish state?
Posted by: PlanetDan   2004-2-3 5:20:54 PM  

#6  There has been discrimination against Israeli Arabs for a long time; it started long before the intifada began. Many social programs and many financial programs are predicated on the recipient being a military veteran there. Non-veterans have trouble getting loans for housing and for businesses. Since most Israeli Arabs are kept out of the army (and for good reason!), they can't fully participate in the economy. And that is dangerous to any society.

There have been a lot of hidden tensions within the Israeli Jewish community. The Ashkenazim and the Sephardim have fought in the past. The Russian immigrants of the 1970s and 1980s felt aggrieved that they were shunted off to poor towns with poor schools. And the Ethopian Jews, law-abiding, pleasant, loyal—they received some truly mortal insults. It took a lot to drive them to riot, and they did once. There had been a blood drive, and many Ethopians reported to the hospitals to donate blood. Some of them then accidentally discovered that their blood was discarded unused because the doctors worried that they might have AIDS.

For Israel to be successful, it will need to find a way to have all its law-abiding citizens fully participate in the economy. The Palestinian murderers make it difficult (I know—understatement!), but it's vital that the Israeli Arabs be integrated into the economy. I don't know if the Israeli government can do it, and that is a pity.
Posted by: Eric Jablow   2004-2-3 4:59:24 PM  

#5  Sorry. The above sounds harsh. It's more of a BTW gentleman which side of the fence to you care for?
Posted by: Shipman   2004-2-3 4:39:28 PM  

#4  Diabolical. Sharon threatens to sell part of his population down the river.... Hmmmm.... Bet there might be an upswing in coversions. But like Nixon noted.... I don't believe the Arabs vote Likud. LOL.
Posted by: Shipman   2004-2-3 4:37:20 PM  

#3  I just can't stop grinning that Sharon is playing this move. I'm suprised Arafish hasn't said anything yet.
Posted by: Charles   2004-2-3 4:17:43 PM  

#2  Brilliant move, he's telling the Israel Arabs to choose a side.

Probably won't help diffuse the population bomb because I don't think they'll assimilate but it might stop the growing support among the Israeli Arabs for Arafat's mad regime.
Posted by: ruprecht   2004-2-3 4:12:22 PM  

#1  This article just says so much!
Posted by: Daniel King   2004-2-3 2:55:43 PM  

00:00