You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
When Islam Breaks Down
2004-04-14
Print it out and keep it. You’ll want to come back to it, again and again.
Posted by:tipper

#7  This is excellent, but I completely disagree with this..no really, I do!

Devout Muslims can see (as Luther, Calvin, and others could not) the long-term consequences of the Reformation and its consequent secularism: a marginalization of the Word of God, except as an increasingly distant cultural echo—as the “melancholy, long, withdrawing roar” of the once full “Sea of faith,” in Matthew Arnold’s precisely diagnostic words.

I think we have just passed through another stage where we are free to decide if we want religion based on its spiritual merit, rather than because "we are heretics" if we do not.

You can choose the pagan lifestyle - but at some point, if you are smart, you start to see the wisdom in Christianity - not because you will go to hell - but because it makes sense.

I think this generation is beginning to understand Christianity as it was once understood: faith, hope, charity, forgiveness, sin and redemption... rather than as the Santa Claus that we pray to for presents.

I liken it to the civil rights movement. The idea of civil rights - is a good one. Jessie Jackson came and perverted it to a point where it is a joke - special rights for minorities at the expense of whites- unrecognizable from the good intentions of its foundings. But the concept of civil rights is still as good as it always was. The foundation of the idea is solid. It's the better way.

And so I see that with Christianity. Perhaps we had to be free to fall to the depths of paganism to which we have fallen to once again understand that concepts of sin/sinners and redemption that Jesus taught to us. Only, now, we do it entirely of our own free will - not because the State makes us do so.
Posted by: B   2004-04-14 2:16:24 PM  

#6  mhw: Dalrymple is City Journal's UK correspondent. He is a psychiatrist and apparently works in a hospital in a rough neighborhood. His writing is anecdotal, but very perceptive.
Posted by: 11A5S   2004-04-14 1:56:38 PM  

#5  Quoth antiwar, "whatEVER".
Posted by: docob   2004-04-14 1:46:14 PM  

#4  nice writing but I don't understand the perspective

does the writer live amongst muslims or work amongst muslims and is this just a view of one neighborhood in one city in one country
Posted by: mhw   2004-04-14 1:31:23 PM  

#3  This is a very fine piece of writing. Everybody here should read it.
Posted by: Secret Master   2004-04-14 11:34:47 AM  

#2  This is brilliant, and fairly spot-on, as far as I can tell.
Posted by: The Doctor   2004-04-14 10:56:28 AM  

#1  Antiwar, this isn't written in crayon but give it a go anyway. This is why we fight.
Posted by: Doc8404   2004-04-14 10:30:12 AM  

00:00