You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Fifth Column
Iwo Jima if covered by media today
2004-10-12
By Gov Zell - man I love this guy. EFL - read the whole thing.
What if today's reporters had covered the Marines landing on Iwo Jima, a small island in the far away Pacific Ocean, in the same way they're covering the war in Iraq? Here's how it might have looked:
DAY 1 - With the aid of satellite technology, Cutie Cudley interviews Marine Pfc. John Doe, who earlier came ashore with 30,000 other Marines.

Cutie: "John, we have been told by the administration that this island has great strategic importance because if you're successful, it could become a fueling stop for our bombers on the way to Japan. But, as you know, we can't be sure this is the truth. What do you think?"
Clueless talking head. How odd - I'm shocked, SHOCKED! I tell you, the CIC or at a minimum the CNO did not clearly explain it all to Pfc. Doe.

Pfc. Doe: "Well, I've been pinned down by enemy fire almost ever since I got here and have had a couple of buddies killed right beside me. I'm a Marine and I go where they send me. One thing's for sure, they are putting up a fight not to give up this island" ...

Cutie: "Our military analysts tell us that the Japanese are holed up in caves and miles of connecting tunnels they've built over the years. How will you ever get them out?"

Pfc. Doe: "With flame throwers, ma'am."

Cutie (incredulously): "Flame throwers? You'll burn them alive?"

Pfc. Doe: "Yes ma'am, we'll fry their asses. Excuse me, I shouldn't have said that on TV."

Cutie (audible gasp): "How horrible!"

Pfc. Doe (obviously wanting to move on): "We're at war ma'am."

(A Marine sergeant watching nearby yells, "Ask her what does she want us to do — sing to them, 'Come out, come out, wherever you are. Pretty please.' "
Don't you just love a smart-assed SGT?

Cutie to camera: "No one has yet really confirmed why this particular battle in this particular place is even being waged. Already, on the first day, at least 500 Marines have been killed and a thousand wounded. For this? (Camera pans to a map with a speck of an island in the Pacific. Then a close up of nothing but black volcanic ash). For this? For this?" (Cutie's sweet voice becomes more strident as it fades out.)

DAY 2 - At 7 a.m., Cutie's morning show opens with a shot of hundreds of dead bodies bobbing in the water's edge. Others are piled on top of each other on shore. After a few seconds, one can see Marines digging graves to bury the dead.

Cutie: "There is no way the Marines could have expected this. Someone got it all wrong. No one predicted this. This has been a horrible 24 hours for our country. This is a slaughterhouse. After all this fighting, Marines control only about a mile and a half of beach and the casualties are now over 3,500 and rising rapidly. We'd like to know what you think. Call the number on the bottom of the screen. Give us your opinions on these three questions:
1. Were the Marines properly trained?
2. Is this nothing of an island worth all these lives?
3. Has the president once again misled the American people?
"After the break, we'll ask our own Democratic and Republican analysts, both shouting at the same time, of course, what they have to yell about all this. It should make for a very shrill, provocative morning.

"But before we leave this horrible — some will say needless — scene, let us give you one more look at this Godforsaken place where these young Americans are dying. Volcanic ash, cold, wet miserable Marines just thankful to be alive. And still no flag that we had been promised on that mountain. Things have gone from bad to worse in this obviously misguided military operation. One thing is certain, there should be and there will be a high-partisan — make that bi-partisan — congressional inquiry into this."
And more - read it all. Zell at his best.
Posted by:Doc8404

#6  Don't forget the hopeless quagmire America was heading for in the Battle of the Bulge...
Posted by: True German Ally   2004-10-12 11:10:51 PM  

#5  I had these same thoughts the other night watching a History Channel show on the Aleutians campaign in WWII. It was an absolute clusterfuck, with troops shipped in for the assault straight from North Africa-- no winter gear at all, no time to acclimate-- and it occurred to me: One battle. As many casualties in one attack as we've had in a year and a half in Iraq. A total balls-up, yet no criticism from the press.

Miller could have written the same parody, with the same effect, about any of hundreds of other WWII battles.
Posted by: Dave D.   2004-10-12 6:49:31 PM  

#4  Eleanor Roosevelt really did have problems with flame-throwers and naplam and being just plain mean and brought it to the press on occasion.

BLOOD FOR ELEANOR!
Posted by: Shipman   2004-10-12 5:39:00 PM  

#3  This is so absolutely accurate. The same parody could be done for the months after D-Day (it was partially done by the master Victor Davis Hanson). The press are idiots who care not a whit about long term perspective. They need to be muzzled in times of war.
Posted by: remote man   2004-10-12 4:51:27 PM  

#2  You have to love Zell Miller. He is a no bullshit Marine.
Posted by: A. Bungfodder   2004-10-12 4:08:13 PM  

#1  Beautiful!

And unfortunately all too true.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2004-10-12 3:36:22 PM  

00:00