You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine
Israel's Sharansky Resigns in Protest
2005-05-02
Cabinet minister Natan Sharansky resigned Monday to protest the planned Gaza withdrawal, which he called a "tragic mistake" that will encourage Palestinian violence and deepen the rift in Israeli society. Sharansky, a former Soviet dissident who was minister for Diaspora Affairs and Jerusalem, served in Cabinets during the past nine years and repeatedly criticized Israeli prime ministers for what he said was their mishandling of negotiations with the Palestinians. In his letter of resignation to Sharon, obtained by The Associated Press, Sharansky wrote that he opposes making unilateral concessions to the Palestinians. "As you know, I was opposed to the disengagement plan from the outset, on the basis of my deep belief that every concession in the peace process made by the Israeli side must be accompanied by democratic reform on the Palestinian side," Sharansky wrote. He told Israel Army Radio that he considers the disengagement plan "a tragic mistake that exacts a high price and also encourages terror."
The Paleos are already drawing up their plans to peacefully administer their new territory loot and plunder evrything they can get their hands on and then crank up the seethe-o-meter to ultramax.
Sharansky immigrated to Israel in 1986, after serving a decade in Soviet prisons. While celebrated abroad, he remained a relatively marginal figure in Israel. He never attracted a large political following and continues to speak in strongly accented Hebrew. By contrast, he won praise from Bush for his recent book "The Case for Democracy: The Power of Freedom to Overcome Tyranny and Terror." A hero to world Jewry for his dissident activities in the 1970s, he was included on Time magazine's recent list of the 100 most influential people in the world. Bush, who invited Sharansky to the White House in November, has said Sharansky's book summarizes his feelings about the need to spread democracy around the world. In the interview with Army Radio, Sharansky drew a parallel between his years in the Soviet gulag and Israeli politics. "In order to fight for your ideals, you are sometimes ready to go prison, you are sometimes ready to go into politics, and you also have to be ready to conclude this phase and to look forward," he said. He said he would remain active in Sharon's ruling Likud Party, which has been torn by the Gaza withdrawal, with many legislators and leading activists opposed to the plan. "We now have a very strong position within Likud," Sharansky said, referring to the party rebels. Sharansky did not attend Monday's weekly Cabinet meeting. Sharon told ministers at the start of the meeting that he regretted Sharansky's decision. "I want to express my appreciation to Natan, not for his letter, because I would be very happy if he were to continue in his post," Sharon said. Cabinet Secretary Israel Maimon said the resignation would take effect Wednesday.Since Sharon announced a year ago that he wants to withdraw from Gaza and parts of the West Bank, several Cabinet ministers have been fired or have quit in protest.
Posted by:seafarious

#7  I fail to see how staying in Netzarim and the other Gaza settlements helps Israeli security. Indefensible hostages. Even if Abbas were helping not at all, this would be a logical strategy, to shorten lines of defense and concentrate force. That Bush is rewarding it with affirmation that the green line wont be the final border, and a generally strong relationship, adds to its desirability. As does improvement in Israeli diplomatic and trade ties. IF it also incents Abbas to continue moderation, and strenghtens him against Hamas and IJ, thats all to the good - but its NOT necessary to justify the withdrawl.
Posted by: Liberalhawk   2005-05-02 12:58:41 PM  

#6  I stand corrected.
Posted by: Seafarious   2005-05-02 11:37:55 AM  

#5  Minor correction, Em: withdrawal from Gaza (and the attendant plunder) will crank up the calls for the whole enchilada from the Jordan to the Med.
Posted by: Steve White   2005-05-02 11:32:34 AM  

#4  #2 - Sea's right. All Paleo claims should be laughed down, hard
Posted by: Frank G   2005-05-02 11:01:48 AM  

#3  Bomb-a-rama said after the withdrawal, when the Paleos begin their spasms of violence anew, no one, not even the Arabs, will have any standing to complain when the Israelis whack the Paleos down hard.

ROTFL
Posted by: gromgorru   2005-05-02 10:54:19 AM  

#2  I disagree. Withdrawal from Gaza (and the attendant plunder) will crank up the calls for Jerusalem.
Posted by: Seafarious   2005-05-02 10:17:54 AM  

#1  Cabinet minister Natan Sharansky resigned Monday to protest the planned Gaza withdrawal, which he called a "tragic mistake" that will encourage Palestinian violence..

Ahh, but Sharansky is missing the silver lining: after the withdrawal, when the Paleos begin their spasms of violence anew, no one, not even the Arabs, will have any standing to complain when the Israelis whack the Paleos down hard.
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2005-05-02 10:09:08 AM  

00:00