You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan/South Asia
Afghanistan, Pakistan Angry at Newsweak
2005-05-17
KABUL, Afghanistan (AP) - Afghanistan's government said Tuesday that Newsweek should be held responsible for damages caused by deadly anti-American demonstrations after the magazine alleged U.S. desecration of the Quran, and it suggested that foreign forces may have helped turn protests violent.
Gee, wonder whose foreign forces they're talking about?
Pakistan joined the international criticism of the magazine's article and said Newsweek's apology and retraction were "not enough."
I agree. How about a fatwa on Newsweek?
The article, published in Newsweek's May 9 edition, said U.S. investigators found evidence that interrogators at the military base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, put copies of Islam's holy book in washrooms and flushed one book down the toilet to try to get inmates to talk. The article sparked protests in several other Muslim countries.
Afghan presidential spokesman Jawed Ludin said Newsweek's retraction Monday was a "positive step" toward clearing up concern about the report. "But at the same time, we feel angered at the way this story has been handled," Ludin told a news conference Tuesday. "It's only fair to say at this stage that Newsweek can be held responsible for the damages caused by their story."
Works for me, Newsweak lied, Afghans died.
Following the article, violent anti-American demonstrations erupted in several Afghan cities, and about 15 people were killed in clashes with security forces. A string of government and relief organization offices were ransacked before police and troops restored order.
Ludin said the government suspected that "elements from within and outside Afghanistan" had helped turn peaceful protests violent.
I think he's talking about the neighbors
More than 500 inmates at Guantanamo were captured during the U.S.-led invasion of Afghanistan to oust the hardline Islamic Taliban regime and end al-Qaida's influence over the deeply religious country.
Afghans' strong feelings about Guantanamo "also provided a reason for the enemies of Afghanistan and for those who are keen to cause destruction in Afghanistan to ... cause the riots," Ludin said. Col. Gary Cheek, commander of U.S. forces in eastern Afghanistan, said Monday he knew of no sign that Taliban-led militants had provoked trouble. But Ludin said the Afghan government found evidence of a "foreign hand" in the eastern city of Jalalabad, where the worst violence occurred. He claimed students in the city, close to the Pakistani border, had returned in disgust to their campus after their protest turned ugly.
Ludin would not say whether Pakistan, which lost influence in Afghanistan with the fall of the Taliban and has sparred repeatedly with Kabul over the ability of militants to shelter on its territory, was suspected of fomenting the violence.
"I can say no more"

"We're still investigating and trying to collect more information," he said. "Then we'll be ready to discuss the related people and organizations." He added, "The president believes this is a reaction to that."
Pakistani officials also expressed anger that the magazine got its story wrong.
"Just an apology is not enough. They should think 101 times before publishing news that hurts hearts," Information Minister Sheikh Rashid Ahmed said in Islamabad.
In Saudi Arabia, the country's top religious authority Tuesday condemned the alleged desecration and urged an investigation into the report. Grand Mufti Adul-Aziz al-Sheik issued his statement a day after Newsweek retracted its report, saying a full inquiry still should be launched "to alleviate the sorrow that befell Muslims." "We condemn and denounce this criminal act against Muslims' most sacred item," al-Sheik said.
Explosives come in a close second

Saudi Arabia is a sometimes close U.S. ally that considers itself the true ruler protector of Islam and the rest of the world in time its holiest sites.
Posted by:Steve

#12  If Abu Ghraib is an issue to the cave dwellers it is because the MSM made it one in their quest to smear Bush and Rummy. 50+ stories by the NYT? Come on. Most of what was photographed happened during a 24 hour period, it was one group of Maryland Nat. Guard and they were uncovered and dealt with by the miltary.
Posted by: Remoteman   2005-05-17 21:58  

#11  good article and good point.
Posted by: 2b   2005-05-17 21:33  

#10   Dhimmitude from Paul Marshall at NR

A great comment on this mess. Read it to the end.
Posted by: 3dc   2005-05-17 19:43  

#9  Nature is cruel. Clinton get's his legacy that the meaning of is is the twin towers crashing down. Rather gets "fake but accurate", Maureen Dowd gets "dowdisms" and she'll soon be irrelevant thanks to NYT's brainy idea that they will actually charge us to read her teenage bitchy gossip. Fiske will get remembered for being the inspiration of the word "fisking", and now isa*cough* gets his legacy..."the ring of truth". Maybe that heading will be show with the dead he is responsible for. Peace advocate Jane Fonda will get her legacy of sitting on the communist gun mount.

These people have no reputation. They have spent their lives making up stories to suit thier agendas. They are bitter, mean, people who have spent their lives abusing the power that they were granted. They made it to the top cheating and lying ... now they get to sow what they reaped. phht.
Posted by: 2b   2005-05-17 19:17  

#8  "the story had the ring of truth to it"

Tried to flush a book, any book, down the toiders lately?
Posted by: Fred   2005-05-17 19:08  

#7  They wanted the story to be true and so they ran with it. They didn't think about the consequences -- that's for the little people to worry about
And there you have it.
Posted by: Shipman   2005-05-17 18:27  

#6  After considerable thinking and some reading around the Web, I'd say this: Newsweek didn't lie, they were sloppy and careless. They relied on a single, anon source who screwed the pooch this time. They wanted the story to be true and so they ran with it. They didn't think about the consequences -- that's for the little people to worry about -- they thought about how this would be another brick to lob at GWB and Rummy.

Andy Sullivan, Kevin Drum and others say that the story had the ring of truth to it, and that's why the rioting occurred. Okay, maybe, we shouldn't underestimate the anger about Abu Ghraib even amongst Muslims who are our friends (and we do have Muslim friends in the world). But Andy, Kevin et al in turn are missing how it is that al-Q and other Muslim terrorists will lie, and they miss how gullible the MSM is (and, frankly, how gullible they are). So yes, some Muslim peasants in the boonies of Afghanistan heard that Qu'rans got flushed and bought the story. That's partly our problem because of Abu Ghraib. That's partly their problem because they shouldn't get their knickers so twisted over a book. And it's partly the MSM's problem because they're both hateful and gullible.
Posted by: Steve White   2005-05-17 17:25  

#5  Sooo, they are going to cancel THE subscription?
Posted by: blackhorse   2005-05-17 16:57  

#4  I wonder with the mad mullahs guns pointed at them if newsweak will ask "what are we doing wrong for them to hate us so?" or if they'll ask... "Hey uncle sam these guys are trying to kill us!!! do something!"
Posted by: Damn_Proud_American   2005-05-17 16:50  

#3  How about holding accountable for their actions those psychotic chanting apes who can't seem to GET A FRICKIN' GRIP?!?
Posted by: BH   2005-05-17 16:45  

#2  Except that it is really Islam that is responsible for the deaths of people killed in the riots. Maybe the Mullahs who gave the 'death to America' sermons are the real guilty parties here.
Posted by: mhw   2005-05-17 16:38  

#1  Heh. Heh, heh...

Good. Now one of the world's most dishonest "news" organizations can try to talk its way off the shitlist of the world's premier death cult. Sweet.
Posted by: Dave D.   2005-05-17 16:35  

00:00