You have commented 340 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
Immigration compromise falls apart
2006-04-08
An agreement reached Thrusday between Democrats and Republicans on immigration reform fell apart Friday. The Senate failed to end debate on the legislation in two lopsided votes Friday morning, leaving the prospects for passage dim as the lawmakers head home for their two-week Easter recess. The bill would have increased border security to try to stem the influx of illegal immigrants while providing a process to legitimize those who've lived for a long time in the country illegally.

The two parties blamed the other for the impasse. "There's a political advantage for Democrats not to have an immigration bill," said Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Arlen Specter, R-Pa. "This opportunity is slipping through our hands like grains of sand," said assistant Senate Democratic leader Dick Durbin of Illinois.

In the Friday morning vote, Republicans refused to go along with Democratic demands to limit the number of amendments that could be offered. The compromise proposal, drafted by Republican Sens. Mel Martinez of Florida and Chuck Hagel of Nebraska, would allow illegal immigrants who have been in the United States for more than five years to get on a path to legal status and citizenship without leaving the country.
Posted by:Fred

#13  should have read: ht Frank Shut the F*cking Borders!
Posted by: RD   2006-04-08 21:00  

#12  what RWV said...

Re USA: For the sake of our security and out of respect for our laws, citizens, and legal immigrants Shut the f*cking* Borders to illegals aliens breaking into our Union.

* Shut the f*cking [ht Frank]
Posted by: RD   2006-04-08 20:58  

#11  So sez economics 101

Economics 101 posts via an anonymiser?
Posted by: Pappy   2006-04-08 20:35  

#10  Thank you for your kind words. However, the United States exists because its citizens accept and support its Constitution. It is a nation unique in that its laws were made by the people and apply equally to all its citizens. If people choose not to obey the laws when they become inconvenient,then the social compact frays and the nation becomes something else. I understand the social pain associated with enforcing the laws but I think the adverse effects of rewarding people who have gamed the system will result in greater pain. If you (Glerens Jalet2499 / Thaper Ebbeasing2964 / whoever you are) believe we need 11,000,000 - 12,000,000 more workers to make the economy go, then change the laws to admit them, just make sure that they are people who are willing to obey our laws. Regardless of your enlightened social views, "illegal immigrants" have broken our laws and are criminals. They cannot be rewarded without severely damaging respect for the law. As to "anchor babies", sneaking into the US to have a child for the purpose of obtaining US citizenship is despicable and is only possible because of the current interpretation of the 14th Amendment and the humanitarian impulses not to separate families.
Posted by: RWV   2006-04-08 20:10  

#9  So sez the poster via Germany's Anonymouse.

So sez economics 101. If you don't believe me, ask Mr. Steve White.
Don't let yourself get lumped in with the brilliant RWV, et al., unless you don't care of course.
Posted by: Thaper Ebbeasing2964   2006-04-08 18:59  

#8  Re: Arizona. Monday, April 10th, there will be a massive boycott of schools, jobs, & etc. by portions of the state's Latino population. Keep an eye out for how this plays out in the msm. Radicals calling for AZTLAN, while moderates suggesting keeping the Mexican flag waving to a minimum. (As a teacher I find boycotting the school an abominable idea - activists are shooting themselves in the foot.)

"Treason doth not prosper, what is the reason? If it doth prosper, none dare call it treason!"
Posted by: borgboy   2006-04-08 18:14  

#7  You're the cream of the idiot crop. Congrats

So sez the poster via Germany's Anonymouse.
Posted by: Pappy   2006-04-08 17:56  

#6  Remember them. Specter, McCain, Kennedy, Feinstein, Durbin, etc. I don't live there so you Arizonans please tell me why you keeep putting that fool back in office. Following California and Texas, you surely have the worst illegal problem in the US. Why does this sellout Feinstein keep getting back in ? It's past time for her retirement. And speaking of retirement Massachusetts, get rid of the socialist/communist Kennedy, please.
Posted by: SOP35/Rat   2006-04-08 17:18  

#5  (hint: deport them all, anchor babies included).

You're the cream of the idiot crop. Congrats.
Posted by: Glerens Jalet2499   2006-04-08 14:50  

#4  Wait till the pompous asses in the Senate run into the Representatives who all have to stand for election in seven months.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2006-04-08 11:13  

#3  Meanwhile.... grannies, vets, and other concerned citizens sit in lawn chairs along the border with 7x50's and try to assist the outmanned and outgunned US Border Patrol. Thanks worthless Washington congressional fuc*s. I hope American voters remember each and every one of you at election time.
Posted by: Besoeker   2006-04-08 09:22  

#2  have had their kabuki dance for the cameras and decided the problem was too big for them
Kabuki dance for the cameras.... excellent.
Posted by: 6   2006-04-08 06:29  

#1  The feckless fools in the Senate have had their kabuki dance for the cameras and decided the problem was too big for them. When they get back maybe they should solve the problem piecewise continuous manner: Build the wall, seal the border, and then worry about how to deal with the ones that are already here. (hint: deport them all, anchor babies included).
Posted by: RWV   2006-04-08 00:54  

00:00