You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Europe
Solana sez he has no proof of CIA renditions
2006-05-03
The European Union's foreign policy chief said on Tuesday he had no proof U.S. intelligence agents had transferred al Qaeda suspects through Europe and that he had no powers to investigate the allegations.

A Washington Post report last year that the CIA had run secret rendition flights and secret prisons in eastern Europe for al Qaeda suspects unleashed a spate of investigations, but none have so far produced a "smoking gun", or solid proof.

"I have no information whatsoever that tells me with certainty that any of the accusations, allegations, rumours, that have taken place are true," Javier Solana told a committee of European Parliament lawmakers probing the allegations. "I do not have the information - I do not have the competence - to ask the countries how they have handled these questions," Solana added.

He said the European Union treaty only allowed the bloc's executive branch, the European Commission, or at least a third of member states acting in concert, to raise the issue. Solana advised lawmakers to question NATO Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, but de Hoop Scheffer told the parliament's foreign affairs committee: "I have no information on so-called, alleged, quote-unquote, CIA flights or alleged renditions."
"Don't ask me, ask him!"
Solana's comments were sharply criticised by some EU lawmakers. British European parliamentarian Sarah Ludford said Solana had a political duty to probe the allegations. "It just paints such a pathetic picture of the EU," she said of Solana's assertion that he could not ask questions about the allegations and the possible complicity of some EU states.
You mean it paints a more pathetic picture of the EU.
Solana told EU lawmakers pressing him on whether EU countries had used information obtained under torture that he believed they were respecting the prohibition. "I have been tortured and I know what that means ... to say 'no' to torture," Solana said, referring to his past as a young socialist activist under Franco's dictatorship in Spain.

Solana said the accusations of CIA abuses were "certainly not marginal issues for the transatlantic relations." He said the US had given assurances about not using torture on CIA flights but that he would welcome similar assurances on not using incommunicado detentions.

Solana's powers are limited as he has no formal role as EU foreign minister.
Which doesn't stop him from yapping, and doesn't stop the EU parliament from giving him money.
According to Claudio Fava, an Italian EU lawmaker responsible for drafting the parliamentary committee's first interim report last week, more than 1,000 CIA flights had transited the European Union since 2001. Amnesty International has given the same figure, and the Council of Europe, another rights organisation investigating the allegations, said last month that one European state had admitted handing over terrorism suspects to foreign agents.
They think, since they can't prove anything.
A team led by Fava probing the alleged CIA abduction of a Kuwaiti-born German on Saturday visited a hotel where he stayed in Macedonia in 2004 and questioned whether his 23-day stay there was voluntary. Fava said on Friday there was no "hard evidence" to confirm Masri's claim he was kidnapped by Macedonian agents before being flown by the CIA to Afghanistan for interrogation.

The European Parliament committee has no legal or judicial power but can recommend sanctions against states.
Posted by:Dan Darling

#2  Actually they don't want to be embarrassed by their strong support and participation in said renditions.
Posted by: SPoD   2006-05-03 16:13  

#1  I don't do very much. But it pays well...
Posted by: Javier Solana   2006-05-03 12:24  

00:00