You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq
Iraq army units clash over bombing
2006-05-13
A roadside bombing north of Baghdad has provoked fierce clashes between two Iraqi army units. According to Iraqi police sources one of the army units was Kurdish and the other made of Shias.

The US military provided a different account of the incident that occurred after a bombing near Duluiyah, about 75km north of the capital on Friday. The US account said one soldier from the Iraqi army's First Battalion was killed and 12 were wounded in the attack. Ali Ibrahim from the Iraqi police said four were killed and three others wounded. He identified the soldiers as Kurdish but did not specify their unit. The wounded were rushed to the US military hospital in Balad and police said that when the Kurdish soldiers drove up to the hospital, they began firing weapons to clear the way, killing a Shia civilian. When security rushed to the scene, the Kurds decided to take their wounded elsewhere, Iraqi police said. Iraqi troops from a separate Shia unit tried to stop them and shots were fired.

The US statement did not say what prompted the soldiers to try to take wounded comrades away from a hospital that is one of the best equipped American medical facilities in Iraq. A third Iraqi unit set up a roadblock in the area and stopped the soldiers who were leaving, the US said. American troops then arrived on the scene and calmed the situation down. The US said the Iraqi army was now investigating the incident.

Thousands of Kurdish peshmerga militiamen were integrated into the Iraqi army in order to provide security in areas with large Kurdish populations, some of which are located near Shia and Sunni Arab communities. The peshmerga also provides security in the three provinces that form the Kurds' self-governing entity in the north.
Posted by:Fred

#6  This story is slanted against the Kurds.

Note that the Kurdish unit is not identified, nor is the Shia one.

This may be something as simple as the Marines and Navy festivities during Fleet Week.

There are few, if any ethnic units in the IA. The IP, OTOH, has many. My suspicion is that some paramilitary IP got into it. The IP is where the majority of the problems are right now.
Posted by: Chuck Simmins   2006-05-13 22:35  

#5  good comment, old spook
Posted by: 2b   2006-05-13 13:40  

#4  The peshmerga were probably pretty defensive about several assasinations of key kurds by Shia militia recently.
Posted by: lotp   2006-05-13 12:58  

#3  They should ensure integration down to the squad level. Its not that way these days - I think they self-segregate at the battalion level. They need to start cross attaching companies (form a battalion Soviet style from 3 companies - 1 each Sunni Kurd Shia), then interlace platoons the same way. Then interlace the squads in the platoon the same way.

If they dont do this they will only have an amalgamation of militias, not an Army. The US Army figured this out a long time ago regarding regionalism (took a bit longer for race).
Posted by: Oldspook   2006-05-13 12:02  

#2  The main problem I see is that in Iraq you are a Kurd, or a Shia, or a Sunni, or a Salafi. You can't just be "Joe Blow", you have to be somebody's enemy everywhere you go.
Posted by: Snineng Craimp9897   2006-05-13 08:49  

#1  Sounds like a Peshmurga discipline problem. There should be US advisers all over that to nip any incorrect behavior in the bud. In fact, their entire Kurdish chain of command should get re-evaluated and clarified as to policy.

This is a big time red warning flag.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2006-05-13 00:08  

00:00