You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Caribbean-Latin America
Bolivia unveils plan to distribute land to poor
2006-05-17
LA PAZ, Bolivia (Reuters) - Bolivia's leftist government on Tuesday outlined its plan to redistribute idle land to poor peasants, ruling out mass expropriations and proposing instead the distribution of state-owned property.
For now.
The announcement came two weeks after President Evo Morales nationalised the country's energy industry, surprising neighbouring states and foreign oil companies that had expected to be consulted before Bolivia took action.

Land reform is another pillar of Morales' policy to increase the state's role in managing natural resources, but the government sought to soothe landowners' fears of arbitrary expropriations by ruling out seizures of productive lands. "As long as the land fulfills its economic and social function, the state will respect it. But if it doesn't fulfill that role, the state will act with the necessary force," Vice President Alvaro Garcia said.
And the gummint will determine whether the 'land' is 'fulfilling' its function.
He urged Bolivians to discuss the proposal and said rumours about expropriations or government-backed squatting stemmed from blackmail by those opposed to the "agrarian revolution."

The first step of the proposal involves distributing up to 5 million hectares (12.36 million acres) of state-owned property to indigenous groups and then identify unproductive private land for possible redistribution.
Unproductive according to the government.
Wealthy landowners concentrated in eastern parts of Bolivia have expressed concern over the reform plans, which fit into Morales' wider agenda to champion the rights of the poor, indigenous majority from where he draws his support.

While the sweeping May 1 energy nationalisation has been relatively noncontroversial within Bolivia, land reform has exposed the deep divisions between its indigenous people and the richer European-descended elite. Unease has been strongest in the eastern economic powerhouse of Santa Cruz, where fertile soils are home to vast soy plantations, cattle ranches and migrants who moved from the impoverished Andean highlands in search of a better life.
And what's more unproductive than a cattle rannch or a soy plantation?
"It's important that the government avoids creating uncertainty and confrontations," said Gabriel Dabdoub, head of the powerful Santa Cruz business association CAINCO. "We need to unify the country and the important thing is for government ministers to sit around a negotiating table in a transparent way," he told Reuters after the announcement.

Despite assurances that productive farmland will not be earmarked for redistribution, some landowners say the definitions are unclear. "What concerns us is that the rules of the game aren't clear," said Mauricio Roca, acting president of the Eastern Agricultural Chamber, which represents landowners.

A recent report by the Roman Catholic Church found a small group of wealthy businessmen owned 90 percent of the country's territory. The rest is shared among Bolivia's 3 million indigenous peasant farmers, who form Morales' support base."That is the reality we have to fix," Garcia said as he detailed the reform proposals. "This will bring justice for communities and for the peasants."
The thought of using the oil money to buy land from the wealthy and distribute it to the peasants never occurred to you, huh?
Posted by:Steve White

#15  It ain't worked the last 50,000 times it's been tried.

Let's do it again!

Idiots.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2006-05-17 23:29  

#14  And what's more unproductive than a cattle rannch or a soy plantation?

Well if you are Morales ANY LAND NOT PRODOCUING COCA is UNPRODUCTIVE!
Posted by: 3dc   2006-05-17 20:06  

#13  "As long as the land fulfills its economic and social function, the state will respect it. But if it doesn't fulfill that role, the state will act with the necessary force," Vice President Alvaro Garcia said.

This is rather more blatant and openly tyrannical, but fundamentally not much different from the Kelo decision IMO.
Posted by: Xbalanke   2006-05-17 17:23  

#12  "productive farmland" = owned by Morales' friends.
Posted by: James   2006-05-17 11:58  

#11  Oh, muchos gracias, Evo!
Posted by: Farmino B. Hardo   2006-05-17 11:47  

#10  Every Bolivian gets a Donkey and 40 acres of oil field.
Posted by: bigjim-ky   2006-05-17 11:43  

#9  in·sane
adj.
1.
a. Of, exhibiting, or afflicted with insanity.
b. Characteristic of or associated with persons afflicted with insanity: an insane laugh; insane babbling.
c. Intended for use by such persons: an insane asylum.
2. Immoderate; wild: insane jealousy.
3. Very foolish; absurd: giving land to people that don't know how to work it
Posted by: DarthVader   2006-05-17 09:59  

#8  hopefully he's gone to school over this issue and studied the famously unsuccessful Zimbabwe example.
Posted by: bk   2006-05-17 09:50  

#7  Full steam ahead, and Bolivia will soon replace Haiti as the poorest hellhole in the Western Hemisphere!
Posted by: Desert Blondie   2006-05-17 09:22  

#6  Right ed, and make sure you mix in a heaping helpin onf rape and murder like the Zimbies did.
Posted by: mcsegeek1   2006-05-17 09:10  

#5  Fools got it all wrong. First you import Rhodesian farmers, let them make successful enterprises, the seize the farms and assets.
Posted by: ed   2006-05-17 09:02  

#4  Excellent idea! Don't forget the seeds, fertilizer, implements, know-how,...
Posted by: Farmin B. Hard   2006-05-17 08:57  

#3  The Zim Bob model, very impressive.
Posted by: Besoeker   2006-05-17 08:49  

#2  The only place it worked was when the US made the ROC do land reform in the early 1950s. Its one of the key reasons Taiwan is successful and stable today.
Posted by: 3dc   2006-05-17 01:15  

#1  "Pa! It's them danged Agrarian Reformers agin..."
Posted by: Unomosing Glavirong1295   2006-05-17 00:13  

00:00