You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
US State Department pulls China-made PCs from secure networks
2006-05-18
The US State Department has backed down on a controversial decision to install computers made by Chinese company Lenovo on its classified networks, officials said. But the department's purchase of about 16,000 personal computers (PCs) from Lenovo raises serious questions given accusations that China is aggressively spying on the United States, Republican lawmaker Frank Wolf said. Word of the State Department order for the desktop PCs was made public in March, 10 months after Lenovo completed its 1.75-billion-dollar acquisition of IBM's PC division. The department chose to install about 900 of the PCs on its secure network at home and at embassies around the world, according to documents released by Wolf.
*Sigh*
But after a flurry of objections from the US-China Economic and Security Review Commission, a bipartisan panel appointed by Congress, the department opted this week to pull the computers from the network. "This decision would have had dire consequences for our national security, potentially jeopardizing our investment in a secure IT infrastructure," said Wolf, whose House appropriations subcommittee funds the State Department. "It is no secret that the United States is a principal target of Chinese intelligence services," he said.

While welcoming the department's reversal, he said the purchase of the 16,000 computers from the Chinese state-backed company was still troubling. Launching an impassioned attack on China's foreign policies and human-rights record, Wolf said that "of course you would take them (Lenovo) off the list" of companies approved to provide technology to the US government. "No American government agency should want to purchase from them," he said. Last year's acquisition vaulted Lenovo to third place among global PC makers, behind only Dell and Hewlett-Packard. The Chinese firm kept the right to use the IBM name on its PCs and the "ThinkPad" brand on laptop computers.

The takeover was cleared by the US government, despite objections from members of Congress who noted that Lenovo is controlled by Legend Holdings, which in turn is majority-owned by the state Chinese Academy of Sciences. Members of the US-China commission said even the use of Lenovo PCs on unclassified State Department networks was troubling. "It's fair to say that unclassified computer communications could be infiltrated and pose a threat," Democratic commissioner Michael Wessel said. The Lenovo row was highlighted on the same day that China denied as "groundless" allegations that it was trying to steal military and scientific intelligence from the United States. A Taiwanese man, Ko-Suen Moo, has pleaded guilty in the United States to spying for Beijing. He was accused by the US District Attorney's office in Miami of seeking illegally to export missiles and aircraft parts to China.
Posted by:Seafarious

#18  
What is it with this coutries government and corporations handing over the keys to the kingdom to our sworn enemies???

That's a rhetorical question, by the way.

Some day there will be a bill to pay, I hope these a$$hats enjoy their money now. Oof!


-M
Posted by: Manolo   2006-05-18 23:50  

#17  Pretty much a symbolic move. Although I applaud the symbolism. Small potats in comparison to American corporations turning over system admin functions to red Chinese outposts. Sys admin for your 401K, sys admin for heavy hitter trading systems. I'm sure these outposts will remain loyal to the American corporation if shooting starts. Really nothing to worry about at all. Financial transactions will remain unmolested. No problem.
Posted by: It Insider   2006-05-18 23:33  

#16  According to Safire - we used a software trojan to destroy a Soviet pipeline - link here.
Posted by: DMFD   2006-05-18 22:20  

#15  I'm going to inspect my teeshirts for hidden code.
Posted by: 6   2006-05-18 21:40  

#14  Now we know where the Chinese is getting the money for that new carrier (or whatever warship) they are planning.....
Posted by: CrazyFool   2006-05-18 21:24  

#13  U.S. State Dept. be lookin' out for us. KEWL!!
Posted by: as   2006-05-18 21:04  

#12  Somebody needs to have a good study of the software. Finding a back door would be reason to clobber Lenovo. My guess, however, is that the Chinese are already installing back doors all over the place via Internet activity.

That said, I'm not keen on my tax dollars supporting the Chinese to the detriment of the free world. I would have bought an IBM, but I won't be buying any Lenovos. If you can't buy an American or Japanese computer, you need to ask yourself why. As for the Russians, I'm not buying any gasoline from LukOil either. Pisses me off that they're even in my neighborhood.
Posted by: Darrell   2006-05-18 20:03  

#11  What are they going to do with the 16,000 midgits hidden in the computers?
Posted by: Danking70   2006-05-18 19:30  

#10  mcsegeek1 - and of course you've inspected all the code in your machine's BIOS?
Posted by: DMFD   2006-05-18 18:58  

#9  Don't see what the big deal is - most US telecomm and networking companies are outsourcing development to mainland China. So the State Dept. is worried about China introducing a trojan into their PC hardware and firmware, but not their networks?!
Posted by: DMFD   2006-05-18 18:57  

#8  As a systems analyst, I fail to see any security threat from Chinese made PC's or PC's made by a company owned by a Chinese interest. There is no 'magic chip' hiding inside to spy on America. A PC is a PC is a PC. Some are built better than others of course. I own a Thinkpad and find it is lighter, faster, has a longer battery life, a longer wireless range, and just looks nicer than my old Dell. Personal preference.

However, the real question is whether the US government should be doing business with firms controlled or outright owned by the Chinese government. I'll leave that one to the politicos to decide rather than the IT professionals.
Posted by: mcsegeek1   2006-05-18 18:39  

#7  Yup, the mike was in the element ball of the selectric typewriters and everywhere else, IIRC.
Posted by: anonymous2u   2006-05-18 17:41  

#6  This reminds me of the time we let the Soviets(?) build our embassy.
Posted by: SLO Jim   2006-05-18 17:39  

#5  hey! I didn't install a wi-fi! what the......?
Posted by: Frank G   2006-05-18 17:22  

#4  I've always wondered, now I know:

This is how stupid it can get.
Posted by: Foggy Brains   2006-05-18 16:54  

#3   The fact that State would even consider Chinese computers on a secure network is a disgrace.
Posted by: Mike N.   2006-05-18 16:47  

#2  Not gonna be many left. But it could resurrect Acer.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2006-05-18 16:43  

#1  Meet the new Stinkpad, same as the old Stinkpad...
Posted by: tu3031   2006-05-18 16:35  

00:00