You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
West Bank militants free US student hostage
2006-06-11
NABLUS, West Bank (Reuters) - Palestinian gunmen on Sunday released a U.S. student they had seized hours earlier as he was on a sightseeing visit to the conflict-battered city of Nablus in the occupied West Bank. Benjamin Bright-Fishbein, an undergraduate student of Brown University, was freed into the hands of Palestinian security forces who then handed him over to the Israelis outside Nablus, a militant stronghold during a Palestinian uprising.

Looking drawn after the ordeal, Bright-Fishbein told Reuters that his lone visit to Nablus had been "a mistake, a big mistake."
Ya think?
The militants got Bright-Fishbein to make a videotaped statement in which he said he would be killed if Israel did not release Palestinian prisoners. The faction of al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades that grabbed him had said he was an Israeli.

Bright-Fishbein recounted how he had been abducted by a gunman called Ahmed who bumped into him in a coffee shop where the student, who speaks Arabic, had been smoking a water pipe. "He (Ahmed) had a pistol, a grenade and a machinegun. I didn't want to be in his company, but it seemed I didn't have any choice at that point," Bright-Fishbein said.
What on earth was he doing there in the first place?
For the videotaped statement, Bright-Fishbein was dressed in the skullcap of a religious Jew. Looking into the camera he said "If the prisoners are not released, they will execute me."

Reports that a hostage had been seized sparked a frantic manhunt by Israeli troops and Palestinian security forces to try to track down the kidnappers. "In the end, I got the impression that they were in over their heads and they were going crazy talking on the phone. They clearly had no idea what they were doing. They were not organized," he said.
Sounds like the Paleos all right.
Gunmen have frequently seized foreigners in the West Bank and Gaza Strip to press for jobs or to make political demands. Hostages have usually been released unharmed after a few hours.

Bright-Fishbein said that he visited Nablus by himself because he had heard it was an interesting place, but could find nobody else to come with him after finishing a study semester in Jerusalem.
"Benny, are you nuts? Come to Tel-Aviv, the girls are plenty there!"
"But I hear Nablus is an interesting place."
"So's hell, but you don't want to visit there either. Come to Tel Aviv!"
"Umm, you guys go ahead, I'll catch up with you later."
Palestinian security sources said an investigation had begun into who carried out the kidnapping.
We wait with baited breath as to the outcome ...
Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades are part of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas's Fatah movement, but they are splintered into numerous groups that often have little coordination with each other.
Love the Reuters understatement.
Posted by:Steve White

#8  Going to Cairo doesn't imply the young man spoke Arabic -- he could have signed up with a tour that had English-speaking guides. He is clearly, however, nearly terminally stupid. As has been said before, being Jewish doesn't guarantee you're smart. I've Jewish friends who tacked a visit to Cairo and a Nile cruise onto their visit to Israel, back in the 1980s before things got crazy; I don't think they'd be so foolish as to do such a thing now.
Posted by: trailing wife   2006-06-11 19:18  

#7  Bright-Fishbein

Is the RB name Hudna still in effect? I mean jeeeeebus....
Posted by: 6   2006-06-11 18:49  

#6  Fishbein, who spent time in Cairo and is currently studying at Jerusalem's Hebrew University, went to Nablus as a tourist, Roagbe said. Fishbein wears a traditional Jewish skullcap, but does not speak Hebrew, he added..

Strange sort of American Jew. Studying at a Hebrew university but doesn't speak Hewbrew. Does speak Arabic. Spends time in Egypt. Strange mix. Strange story.

Decided to visit a rat's nest at war? What's he studying?
Posted by: Thinemp Whimble2412   2006-06-11 09:31  

#5  Interesting, DMFD. I guess ol' Zarky's death is already starting to pay dividends.

Posted by: Desert Blondie   2006-06-11 06:54  

#4  From the Ha'aretz article:

The PA security forces subsequently handed the American over to the Israel Defense Forces. Defense officials believe once the militants discovered the person was indeed an American citizen, they took steps to end the matter quickly.

"Apparently, the kidnappers did not want to end up like Zarqawi," a defense official said.
Posted by: DMFD   2006-06-11 01:27  

#3  [slaps forehead] Thanks GK, I still don't know how I missed that joke while editing the piece!
Posted by: Steve White   2006-06-11 01:01  

#2  Fishbein- yes
Bright- NO!
Posted by: GK   2006-06-11 00:58  

#1  Those nice Paleo boyz couldn't help themselves 'cos they're all splintered an' all. No chance that this is part of a coordinated state-sponsored attack on a sovereign nation, or even the proper duty of a believing Muslim.

Standard fifth-column taqiyya.
Posted by: Seafarious   2006-06-11 00:10  

00:00