You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
It turns out the scientists have lots of theories why more of the world is overweight
2006-07-02
The World Health Organisation (WHO) last September warned that a billion people were overweight and obese, and the toll could rise to 1.5 billion by 2015, driven by low- and middle-income countries.

Writing on Tuesday in the International Journal of Obesity, a team of US public-health experts caution against focussing obsessively on the "Big Two" -- a slower lifestyle and modern food marketing. "This has created a hegemony whereby the importance of the Big Two is accepted as established and other putative factors are not seriously explored," they say. "The result may be well-intentioned but ill-founded proposals for reducing obesity rates."

They contend the evidence against junk food, supersize-me portions and high-calorie corn syrup is "equivocal and largely circumstantial" and offer some intriguing ideas of their own for other drivers of the obesity tsunami.
Hereupon follows a list of the possiblities for which there seems to be supporting evidence (all of which don't have anything to do with whether or not you, dear reader, are a lazy pig):

-- Industrial chemicals called endocrine disruptors that disturb metabolism, encouraging the formation of fat.

-- Giving up smoking: people who give up cigarettes very often gain weight.

-- Air conditioning, which establishes a comfortable temperature zone. In temperatures above this zone, people eat less. The rise in number of air-conditioned homes in the United States virtually mirrors the increase in the US obesity rate.

-- Fat people marry other fat people. These individuals may be genetically vulnerable to obesity, a trait that could handed on to their children.

-- Sleep depriviation. University of Chicago researcher Esra Tasali notes that waistlines in modern societies started to expand when people started to sleep less. Today, the "sleep deficit" is about two hours per night compared with 40 years ago. To test this hypothesis, Tasali recruited a group of healthy young adults and divided them into three groups. One group had eight hours' sleep; another had their sleep regime extended to 12 hours; and the third was limited to only four hours. The sleep-deprived group swiftly developed cravings for high-calorie sweets, and their metabolisms were akin to those of diabetics.

-- Viral infection. At least 10 different pathogens are known to cause obesity in animals, causing dramatic changes to the metabolic system so that more energy gets converted into fat.

Nikhil Dhurandhar of the Pennington Biomedical Research Center at Louisiana State University believes that something similar may happen among humans exposed to cousins of the common cold. He tested the stored blood of 500 Americans and found that 30 percent of obese people had antibodies for Ad-36, an adenovirus which causes coughing, sneezing and cold-like symptoms. Only 11 percent of people of normal body weight had this telltale of Ad-36 infection.
Posted by:trailing wife

#11  Yep, it's the air conditioning and not the fact that people won't get off their lazy butts and walk.
Posted by: Swamp Blondie   2006-07-02 21:38  

#10  "culpabilizing"

Best new word on Rantburg this year.
Posted by: no mo uro   2006-07-02 20:01  

#9  viral infection! yeah thats it!
Posted by: spazwit   2006-07-02 19:00  

#8  Let's add Nannyism - which scares mothers into holding their children as hostages in their own home. Better a thousand Peds run free than to execute one and free the children.

Let's add Darwinism - since modern living means a lot of kids who would never had made it to reproductive age [childhood diseasess, child labor, etc] are now in their third generation of making more humans.

Note that the WHO doesn't acknowledge that famine and its associated plagues [while still present in Africa] were common prior to the 20th Century and modern food preservation techologies. The world in general was often one or two harvests away from repeatative disaster [real, not Hollywood]. People didn't live long enough to face the complications of 'overweight'. So instead of celebrating success, we all have to listen to more 'experts'.
Posted by: Snetch Unater1043   2006-07-02 16:29  

#7  my samoan friends are by far the largest I have...
Posted by: Frank G   2006-07-02 16:26  

#6  Oh, and the population of Niue is roughly 2,200 people. I suppose they have a vote at the U.N. I wonder if they have a fast food restaurant.
Posted by: Darrell   2006-07-02 15:43  

#5  Just for the record, WHO's 2005 database says the top five countries for obesity are [drumroll, please]: Cook Islands; Nauru; Niue;
Micronesia, Federated States of; and Tonga. Yeah, it has to be either those industrial chemicals or George Bush.
Posted by: Darrell   2006-07-02 15:40  

#4  I detect a voracious appetite for grant money...
Posted by: Glaitch Groting9149   2006-07-02 15:33  

#3  Somehow I just know George Bush will be held responsible.
Posted by: Darrell   2006-07-02 15:32  

#2  Yeah, it's not my fault! Not my fault at all! Not my fault, not my fault, not my fault! Stop culpabilizing me! And I'm not fat, I'm big-boned, dammit!
Posted by: anonymous5089   2006-07-02 15:32  

#1  Right... "too much food, not enough exercise" can't be the reason. It's gotta be something else!
Posted by: Scooter McGruder   2006-07-02 15:29  

00:00