You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Syria-Lebanon-Iran
Prisoner exchange or nothing: Hizbollah
2006-08-31
A Hizbollah Cabinet minister said Wednesday that the guerrilla group would not release two captured Israeli soldiers unconditionally, and that they would only be freed in a prisoner exchange. "There will be no unconditional release. This is not possible," Minister of Energy and Hydraulic Resources Mohammed Fneish told reporters in Beirut. He is one of two Hizbollah members in Lebanon's Cabinet. "There should be an exchange through indirect negotiations. This is the principle to which Hizbollah and the resistance are adhering," he said.
Posted by:Fred

#9  What about Israel and their losses as well?

D@mn fine question, Jan. There should be a fund for Israeli victims' rebuilding and rehabilitation. Screw the Palestinians and the camel they rode in on!
Posted by: Zenster   2006-08-31 23:20  

#8  Negotiations with terrorists Hezbo's or the Lebanese?
I agree with mcsegeek1; If they kill the prisoners, well, they were going to kill them anyway, but at least you haven't released scads of angry jihadists back into the Lebanese population only to strike again.
And why is it money is only being given to the Lebanon side for rebuilding and such? What about Israel and their losses as well?

Posted by: Jan   2006-08-31 13:14  

#7  It would be reasonable for Israel to exchange prisoners captured after the seizure of the two soldiers. It would emphasize the uselessness of the original kidnapping.
Posted by: DoDo   2006-08-31 11:29  

#6  Well since Olmert already lied to the families, his credibility is now sh*t, and he doesn't have the cajones to try this, it'd never work, but:

Demand the immediate release of the soldiers. Start executing Hezzie prisoners one at a time if they don't comply. After each execution, repeat the demand. If they release them, fine. If not, execute until you run out of hezzies. If they kill the prisoners, well, they were going to kill them anyway, but at least you haven't released scads of angry jihadists back into the Lebanese population only to strike again. Lose two soldiers, save hundreds, maybe thousands of Israeli lives. Not a perfect option, I grant you, but at least the lesser of two evils.
Posted by: mcsegeek1   2006-08-31 11:06  

#5  so hizb'Allah have chosen the void.
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2006-08-31 07:48  

#4  So whom do the Hezzies, Huzzie, and Hammies hold prisoner, let alone the Jihadis, Qudies, and Stalinist/Marxist Popular Fronties/Poppies???
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2006-08-31 03:17  

#3  You are absolutely right, RWV. Israel's willingness to release scads of terrorists in exchange for just soldier or two only exacerbates the problem. They need to go in and begin bulldozing a square city block in each of the "refugee" camps every day until the prisoners are released. If they meet with resistance, walk in some artillery to finish the job from a safe distance.
Posted by: Zenster   2006-08-31 01:47  

#2  Veg them and return the veggies.
Its win win.
Posted by: 3dc   2006-08-31 00:32  

#1  Israel should stop their stupid policy of exchanging prisoners at ratios >100 to 1. Aside from conveying their opinion of the relative worth of the prisoners, it encourages the sort of behavior that started the recent festivities.
Posted by: RWV   2006-08-31 00:25  

00:00