You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
BYU Professor on Paid Leave for 9-11 Theory
2006-09-08
A controversy over words at BYU this morning. A professor is on paid leave for suggesting the government is responsible for the destruction of the World Trade Center. The man on paid leave is Dr. Steven Jones. He's a physics professor involved in the so-called "9-11 Truth Movement."
He's also one of the guys who was involved in the big cold fusion hype some years back.
Jones believes unnamed government agencies orchestrated the fall of the twin towers and he says there's evidence to back it up. Two weeks ago he published his theory in a paper called "Why Indeed did the World Trade Center Buildings Collapse?" In it, the professor says the towers fell not because of planes hitting them but rather pro-positioned demolition charges.

He sites research conducted at BYU on materials from ground zero, asserting those materials show evidence of thermite, a compound used in military detonations. He says terrorists could have never set those charges.

The State Department has released a rebuttal to Jones' theory in a 10-thousand page report.

BYU made this statement last night:

"Physics Professor Steven Jones has made numerous statements about the collapse of the World Trade Center. BYU has repeatedly said that it does not endorse assertions made by individual faculty.

"We are, however, concerned about the increasingly speculative and accusatory nature of these statements by Dr. Jones."

The university added, "BYU remains concerned that Dr. Jones' works on this topic has not been published in appropriate scientific venues."

It is rare for some in Dr. Jones' position to be under review because he has taught at BYU for more than a decade. He began his career at the university in 1985 and has been known his cold fusion research. But other professors will teach his classes while he's on paid leave. He will be allowed to conduct research in his field but the university is reviewing his actions.
The university gets one thing exactly right: if he 'research', publish it in a peer-reviewed journal. Put it all out there for people to see, and let peers and experts decide whether it measures up. That's what real academics do.
Posted by:Steve White

#13  For the time being, destabilizing and suborning the USA to OWG is the common agenda of both Secular SOcilaists + Radicla Islamists - iff and when the USA goes down, the gloves will come off between Secularist and Theocratist/Dei-ist. RIGHTWINGNEWS.com > CINDY SHEEHAN'S book PEACE MOM = Cindy has fantasized about going back intime and KILLING THE INFANT DUBYA in order to save the world from the future WOT. Cindy > Dubya = ANTI-CHRIST???
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2006-09-08 21:58  

#12  Interesting to me is that he's a Physics professor, not a Materials or even Civil Engineer. Wonder who's giving him his "evidence" of thermite? I'm not real familiar w/ thermite, but why would anyone at Ground Zero EVEN tested for it, unless a conspiracy theorist themselves?
Posted by: BA   2006-09-08 21:55  

#11  TW, I re-read the article linked here and saw no mention of BYU not offering tenure. Did I miss it??

The professors' union must be quietly howling!

Not necessarily. At some schools perhaps, but not at BYU and some other place and especially not in the hard sciences. A full professor in the hard sciences who goes batty is anathema to other scientists, generally. In this case Jones was batty about conclusions he was drawing from sketchy scientific evidence -- more or less the equivalent of a dog with rabies. You put them down quickly for the good of the community.
Posted by: lotp   2006-09-08 19:11  

#10  Cold fusion scammer, 9-11 conspiracy theorist or crackpot full-goose-Bozo raving loon? You be the judge.
Posted by: Zenster   2006-09-08 18:02  

#9  Which reminds me : as mentioned earlier, the most well-known french satellite/cable documentary channel started its 9/11 commemoration evening by airing "loose change 2nd edition" on prime time. Feel the love.
Posted by: anonymous5089   2006-09-08 17:30  

#8  The article makes the point that BYU does not give tenure, so no, the good professor is not tenured. Which makes his position very precarious indeed. I suspect he won't be on the professorial roster for the next school year, establishing a lovely precedent for the profession. The professors' union must be quietly howling!
Posted by: trailing wife   2006-09-08 17:27  

#7  Maybe he believes that Texas oilmen bombed Pearl Harbor.

That would be the Germans.
Posted by: Pre-Law Student   2006-09-08 16:30  

#6  Cause, meet effect.
Posted by: DarthVader   2006-09-08 15:30  

#5  Ain't tenure institution wonderful?
Posted by: gromgoru   2006-09-08 15:14  

#4  Not quite a paid vacation, Glenmore.

He's a full professor, which is the highest academic rank and implies tenure. Paid leave of this sort is virtually unprecedented and indicates a serious professional rebuke in the making. The nature of the rebuke is suggested by words like "increasingly speculative and accusatory" and "remains concerned that Dr. Jones' works on this topic has not been published in appropriate scientific venues". These are cardinal sins in the scientific research community.

Jones was already controversial re: cold fusion but there was at least some argument to be made that that was legitimate scientific research and theorizing. By his 9/11 conspiracy theories he has clearly stepped out of bounds for a researcher.
Posted by: lotp   2006-09-08 15:13  

#3  Can I too get a paid vacation (not in a rubber-walled 'resort') for espousing crackpot conspiracy theories?
Posted by: Glenmore   2006-09-08 14:47  

#2  How many times does al-Qaeda have to admit carrying out the WTC atrocities, before the conspiracy crackpots finally get it. I would question the teaching credentials of a denier. Maybe he believes that Texas oilmen bombed Pearl Harbor.
Posted by: Snease Shaiting3550   2006-09-08 14:05  

#1  Well at least they didn't put him on leave for espousing that Jesus was married, and to more than one wife; that Adam is God; that you can be a God when you die if you're married in the temple; or some crazy theory like that.....
Posted by: mcsegeek1   2006-09-08 13:52  

00:00