You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
Merkel signals Germany won't send troops to southern Afghanistan
2006-11-22
Big snip to just Merkel's comments; see following story for the basics. AoS.
Chancellor Angela Merkel made clear Wednesday that Berlin does not plan to send troops to volatile southern Afghanistan. She argued that Germany is needed in the north to maintain stability and insisted there is no "purely military solution" to the country's problems.

The German social workers military is fulfilling "an important and dangerous task" in the north, providing security and backing reconstruction, Merkel said in a speech to parliament. "We don't want to raise questions over the success of this mission in the north under any circumstances, and I see no one who would seriously want to jeopardize the relative security that we have achieved in the north," she added. "About 40 percent of the Afghan population lives in this region."

"The Bundeswehr will continue to take responsibility there within the framework of its mandate, but I do not see any military commitment that goes beyond this mandate," Merkel said.

Merkel pointed to the importance of pursuing civilian rebuilding alongside the battle against insurgents. "We need more time than we thought and hoped for the development of Afghanistan," she said. "But I also say that we want to, and we must, lead this mission in Afghanistan to success, together with our allies."

"We in Germany know that we must fight for that, with the military, but we must also fight for the hearts of people in Afghanistan," she added.

Merkel insisted that "there can be no purely military solution, but without a militarily secured environment there can be no reconstruction in Afghanistan."

She pointed to other German efforts in the country, such as help in rebuilding the country's police. "The issue of Afghanistan is too important for us to let it dwindle into a military north-south debate," Merkel said.

Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier backed Merkel and said Germany might do well to project "a little more self-confidence" about what it is already doing. "I think we have good reasons not to give up, to limit our commitment in the north," he told parliament. "Of course I know that where we are responsible, we are still far from finished. But if stabilization has succeeded at all anywhere in Afghanistan ... then it is in the north."
I have no problem at all with ensuring that the northern part of the country is secure and that reconstruction moves ahead. Security begets reconstruction; we know that. What I object to is that Germany wants the big pat on the back whilst leaving their 'allies' -- the Dutch, Canadian, Brit and Ami troops -- to face the biggest dangers in the south. There ought to be a rotation on this; let each contingent take their turn in whacking the Taliban. It would be good for the German military to get some real combat experience instead of just laying bricks.
Posted by:anonymous5089

#2  Glad to see a comment from Germany, SGL. As best I can tell, the only reason Merkel takes this position is that the populace is overwhelmingly pacifist.
Posted by: fmr mil contractor   2006-11-22 17:43  

#1  I have to agree 100% to your comment. Hope our silly (German) government reconsiders
it's stupid position. ( no problem if they get some pressure in the next meeting on this issue either !!).
Posted by: SGL   2006-11-22 15:34  

00:00