| Submit your comments on this article |
| Home Front: Culture Wars |
| Critics interrupt speaker's talk on Islam |
| 2007-01-21 |
| One woman was ejected, another nearly arrested A talk on the basic tenets of Islam was repeatedly interrupted Saturday by a few anti-Muslim members of a crowd at the Cesar Chavez Central Library. One woman was forced to leave early in the two-hour program after she accused guest speaker Tarek Mourad of lying, yelling that Islam's holy book teaches Muslims to kill Jews and Christians and that Muslims are trying to take over the Western world. Another was nearly arrested by Stockton Police Chief Wayne Hose, who said he came to the talk on his day off to learn more about Islam. The woman, who would only give her name as Barbara, handed out photocopied pages from a book critical of Islam and on numerous occasions interrupted Mourad's talk to read passages about Islam that conflicted with her Christian views. Hose finally called a police officer to the library in case the interruptions continued and after "Barbara" asked if he was Christian. "Don't talk to me," Hose told her, rejecting her offer of anti-Muslim reading material. "I can't hear what he (Mourad) has to say." Mourad, an engineer from Santa Clara, was invited to the Chavez Library after making a similar presentation in Tracy. He explained the six basic beliefs, including a belief in God and a day of judgment, to the five "pillars" of Islam, such as praying five times a day and making a pilgrimage to Mecca, Saudi Arabia, the home of Islam. His presentation, which happened to be on the Muslim New Year, turned to near chaos during the question-and-answer session. Hose and librarian Mary Jo Gohlke, who organizes adult programs at the library, each nearly pulled "Barbara" from the audience of nearly 70 people after she wouldn't stop reading aloud. Barbara recommended the audience read "Islam and Terrorists," issued by a company that publishes Christian-themed books and written by a convert from Islam to Christianity. "Just go back and listen to Pat Robertson on TV," yelled one man, who walked out in a huff. "You're just quoting from hate material," said Lodi's Nasim Khan. Stockton's Erica Richard, who said she is a Christian, asked for calm and suggested the library schedule a discussion of Christianity. Mourad kept his composure throughout the interruptions, saying Muslims have lived alongside people of other religions for centuries and that much of the religious-based tension in the world today is created for political purposes. "I'm not saying (Islam) is better than Christianity," he said. Violence in the name of Islam is "a real corruption of the understanding of the religion," Mourad said, adding that every society has a segment of miscreants. Afterward, Mourad spoke briefly with Barbara, his chief interrupter, but said she wasn't open to new ideas. "I want to get these reactions," said Mourad, who said most of his previous talks have been to groups of fellow Muslims. "I'm trying to reach outside the mosque crowd. I have no problem with any issues that comes up. I just have to learn how to answer these comments and counteract propaganda like this." Gohlke said she broke into tears because of the interruptions. "I've never had an experience like this in my life," the librarian said, adding she didn't think the subject would generate controversy. "It's so disappointing." |
| Posted by:ryuge |
| #5 ;-p, #4 tw. Of course, you wouldn't have caught me dead in the first place in any joint named after Chavez. ""I've never had an experience like this in my life," the librarian said, adding she didn't think the subject would generate controversy." Don't get out much, does she. |
| Posted by: Barbara Skolaut 2007-01-21 11:38 |
| #4 Our Barbara Skolaut would have been much more effective. Our Barbara wields a scalpel, not a bludgeon. |
| Posted by: trailing wife 2007-01-21 10:33 |
| #3 Violence in the name of Islam is "a real corruption of the understanding of the religion," Mourad said, adding that every society has a segment of miscreants. So Mohammed was one of those "miscreants"? |
| Posted by: Rob Crawford 2007-01-21 10:25 |
| #2 Would any Christian presentations be allowed? I thought not.... |
| Posted by: Frank G 2007-01-21 09:47 |
| #1 I thought Barb lived in Virginia. |
| Posted by: Shipman 2007-01-21 09:35 |