You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
FBI Targets Fake War Heroes
2007-05-07
Federal agents are taking aim at phony war heroes who tell tall tales of battlefield valor and pin bogus medals upon their chests, the Daily News has learned. The FBI's Washington headquarters receives at least 15 tips a week about fake heroes - and most of the information comes from veterans who are furious that the scam artists are demeaning real sacrifices, said FBI Special Agent Michael Sanborn. Sanborn said the charlatans are an insult to the nearly 200,000 veterans who have perished in faraway battles and earned their medals posthumously. "These guys gave their lives for their medals," he said. "These other guys bought theirs off eBay."

The FBI investigates all the tips and, on average, more than a hundred each year lead to pretenders who tout their bogus heroics at Memorial Day rallies and other military galas, said Sanborn, a Marine Corps captain who has been hunting impostors for a decade.

The latest to be accused is Louis Lowell McGuinn, a 62-year-old Vietnam vet from Flushing, Queens. Prosecutors say he promoted himself from private to lieutenant colonel and wore the Army's highest medals for valor on his dress blues during an October gala at the Hotel Pierre. McGuinn became the first person in the nation to be prosecuted under a new law, the Stolen Valor Act, which exposes convicted fakers to a year in prison.

McGuinn's lawyer says he plans to defend his client by attacking the merits of the law.
When you can't attack the evidence, you attack the law ...
"They're going to be sitting in the jury box waiting to hear about the crime that was committed," said attorney Paul Dalnoky. "He served and this is how the government thanks him?" Dalnoky would not acknowledge that his client broke the law. But the lawyer added, "We all do it. With women. Applying for a job. It's all puffery."
Then you won't mind the prosecutor displaying the photos, the fake medals, etc., to the jury. Nope, the jurors won't care at all, will they.
Authorities say McGuinn wrongly parlayed his medals into lucrative security consulting contracts. "This is a problem that has gone on as long as there have been soldiers," said Doug Sterner, a military historian who keeps track of medal winners and helps the FBI ferret out the phonies. "Soldiers tell war stories."
This wasn't a war story.
Posted by:Anonymoose

#11  Mom Hey, you kidS! Get off my lawn!!!!

heh Ima not the only one
*ima recovering crab apple*
Posted by: RD   2007-05-07 22:24  

#10  This kind of fakery should be a hanging offense. My father sacrificed a lot for the Combat Infantryman Badge, which he considered a higher decoration than his Bronze Star.
Posted by: Mike   2007-05-07 14:16  

#9  Re: mustache... I'll take your word for it, Moose. But a guy in dress blues with facial hair so very far out of regs would still cause me to raise an eyebrow.
There are just some things that will instantly attract the critical notice of an NCO, even a retired one.
I notice stuff like this all the time on TV dramas. This makes me a very cranky person sometimes...

Hey, you kidS! Get off my lawn!!!!
Posted by: Sgt. Mom   2007-05-07 11:49  

#8  Nothing and I mean NOTHING frosts me quicker than a faker or a poser. I actually get angrier at those that have served and puff up their bonafides to find glory outside the military. Trouble is that NO reporter will ever investigate a “War Hero” unless he is exposed first. This is especially true of those that are Anti-Bush.
Posted by: Cyber Sarge   2007-05-07 10:49  

#7  Sgt. Mom: Actually, that style of mustache was popular with some Vietnam War attack helicopter pilots, who were given some latitude in their high-performance, high-risk job. A very bold bunch, known for their daring and heroics.

Which makes this scoundrel even more reprehensible.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2007-05-07 09:51  

#6  ...I've been following thsi stuff for a while, and folks, it is unbelieveable what some of these idiots have gotten away with. What amazes me to no end is the number of them that had long, solid and perfectly respectable careers in the military, then suddenly promote themselves from E5 to 0-10 with two CMOHs.

Mike
Posted by: Mike Kozlowski   2007-05-07 09:27  

#5  The pic of a faker named Thibideux set of my bullshitometer, even before I read the caption, because his mustashe was so far out of regs.
Well, regs in this century, anyway. (Might have passed in the 19th century, though)
Posted by: Sgt. Mom   2007-05-07 08:16  

#4  The mind of a lawer, excuse me , I have to go vomit now.
Posted by: bigjim-ky   2007-05-07 08:03  

#3  "We all do it. With women. Applying for a job. It's all puffery."

Yeah. None of us has any integrity, right? Better hope I'm not on the jury, fartbreath.
Posted by: Bobby   2007-05-07 07:07  

#2  Authorities say McGuinn wrongly parlayed his medals into lucrative security consulting contracts.

Wouldn't that qualify as fraud?
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2007-05-07 05:25  

#1  I guess faking it as a relative of the former finance minister of Nigeria has played out.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2007-05-07 00:22  

00:00