You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
US snoops could get wrong ideas by bugging Muslim phone calls
2007-08-21
An Arab journalist, who has worked for various Middle East newspapers for over 25 years from the US, has pointed out the likely pitfalls of the National Security Agency (NSA) using its new powers to monitor overseas communications without any approval from a judge.

Mohammad Ali Salih writes in the Washington Times that he has 12 brothers and sisters, more than 30 cousins, about 50 nieces and nephews and many friends scattered in seven Muslim countries. There are also tens of readers who respond to his writings, in Arabic and English, in print and on the Internet. If the NSA, using its new powers to monitor overseas communications, electronically looks into his communications for catch words like "Allahu Akbar" and "Kafir" it will find them in there. "If the NSA is looking for certain names of terrorists, their supporters, helpers and financiers among my family members, it will not find them. If the NSA is looking for Muslims who are very critical of US policies towards Muslims, especially in the aftermath of September 11, may Allah help all of us," he writes.

Salih, who is from Sudan, writes that his brother begged him to return home during a recent phone conversation, and cursed "Bush and the rest of the 'Kafirs' who are killing Muslims all over the world". Another brother talked about the village's madrassa and said that some Arab businessmen from the Gulf had helped rebuild it. A sister, also on her cell phone, sang a popular local song about Condoleezza Rice that went, "Rice, the best of all prides. If my father agrees, I will marry you. And I'll keep you at home." His father said a prayer for him, "May Allah guide you. May Allah protect you from evil. May Allah defeat your enemies."

Salih points out that his relatives and friends are not exceptional. In Egypt, 92 percent believe that the US intends to "weaken and divide" Muslims. Ninety-one percent support "attacking US forces in Iraq". Another recent poll by Gallup, conducted in 10 Muslim countries, found that an "overwhelming majority...strongly doubted the US is trying to establish democracy in the ME". And an earlier poll by CNN found that people in nine Muslim countries called the US "ruthless and arrogant," with most describing themselves as "resentful" of this. He adds, "But, in spite of its faults, I believe America is God's heaven on earth. Never before in the history of mankind has a nation been so free, strong, advanced, diverse, proud and built on faith. According to many polls, most Muslims, like others, would love to come to America. That includes my relatives and friends, the young among them usually ask me to find a way for them to come to study."
Posted by:Fred

#14  I don't think they're worried we'd get the wrong ideas by "bugging muslim phone calls" - they're afraid we'd get the right ideas.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2007-08-21 18:23  

#13  Don't forget: "Bree-yark means 'We Surrender'!"
Posted by: eLarson   2007-08-21 15:14  

#12  It takes a helluva lot of nerve for a family of Sudanese to lecture the people of the United States of America on FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS. Sheesh, look at what the government of Sudan, ruled by al Qaeda sympathizers, are doing to their own people, most of whom are MUSLIMS. Frickin' hypocrites of the first water.
Posted by: mrp   2007-08-21 12:20  

#11  Sorry, Salih, but we're not handing out hints as to what does or does not trigger the monitors. Nice try, though.
Posted by: mojo   2007-08-21 11:14  

#10  30 cousins, about 50 nieces and nephews, donkeys, goats, and sheep; we are all brothers and sisters sleeping under the same tent. Some of us got traded for water or grain and now the sun never sets on the Salih family.
Posted by: wxjames   2007-08-21 09:17  

#9  Repeat after me: "Gort, Klaatu berada nikto."
Posted by: doc   2007-08-21 08:50  

#8  Muslim Whining Continues. Film at eleven...
Posted by: tu3031   2007-08-21 07:07  

#7  "overwhelming majority...strongly doubted the US is trying to establish democracy in the ME".

And when I get my way, the world will see the "overwhelming majority" was correct, because chaos will reign!
Posted by: Harry Reid (D) Feetist   2007-08-21 06:48  

#6  I hope "30 cousins, about 50 nieces and nephews and many friends scattered in seven Muslim countries" get put on the no-travel list.
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2007-08-21 05:17  

#5  What an ignorant, self-conflicted article. Should make for good reading among mooselimbs who happen to be as ignorant as the writer.
Posted by: gorb   2007-08-21 03:10  

#4  Cool yer jets Mr & Mrs muslim, were gonna find a way to reverse immigrate you in the end.

extra bismillahs and inshallahs
Posted by: RD   2007-08-21 01:50  

#3  This is only the first stage of the NSA's muslim conditioning project. When the NSA computers detect an allah akbar, 100,000 volts is sent down the line.
Posted by: ed   2007-08-21 00:55  

#2  "'The sun rises in the east'. I repeat, Mahmoud, 'the sun rises in the east.'"
Posted by: Steve White   2007-08-21 00:42  

#1  Relax, Mo. We're screening for "eggplant" and "Chinese checkers". Also "yodel", but only on Thursdays after a hard rain.
Posted by: Seafarious   2007-08-21 00:26  

00:00