You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Olmert: Iron Dome anti-Kassam system at advanced stage
2008-02-19
A significant amount of money is being invested for the completion of the Iron Dome anti-Kassam system, currently under development by Israel's Rafael (Armaments Development Authority), Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said Monday. "The plan is that these means will give us the capability of stopping short-range rocket attacks including Kassams. This is applicable to both the northern and the southern fronts," said the prime minister during a Kadima faction meeting. Olmert emphasized that the system was at an advanced stage of development with an investment of nearly one billion NIS.

Regarding the Gaza blockade, Olmert said Israel was continuing to impose sanctions in a controlled manner in order to prevent a humanitarian disaster. He stressed that Gazans would not live normal lives as long as Israel is under fire. "We view Hamas as being responsible for everything that happens in the Gaza Strip, irrespective of whether its operatives are involved in every single incident," he added.

Olmert also praised the 2005 disengagement from Gaza. "Despite the [continuing] Kassam fire, it was a very good move since there are no longer 30,000 soldiers protecting 1,200 citizens," he said.

Concerning the peace process, Olmert expressed hope that an agreement on basic principles would be reached between Israeli and Palestinian negotiating teams this year.

Nevertheless, Olmert again stressed that Jerusalem would be the last issue raised in negotiations and that this had been agreed upon with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas. "I will not hesitate to carry out painful compromises in order to reach true peace," he said, adding that a peace agreement cannot be signed before terror in Gaza ceases entirely.

Olmert mentioned Sunday's decision by a ministerial committee he led to approve a budget of NIS 350 million to fortify 3,600 Gaza belt homes against Kassam rockets. He noted that five million shekels had already been transferred for this purpose.
Posted by:Fred

#9  LH, expending $100,000 of weapons to shoot down a $100 rocket is an invitation for Hamas to bankrupt Israel. Even if only 10% of the Kassams are worth intecepting, the economics still holds. Hamas are rubbing their hands in anticipation of increasing rocket attacks 100 fold. The solution lies in offense, not defense.
Posted by: ed   2008-02-19 21:32  

#8  I still think the most cost-effective solution would be some five inch radar controlled automatic smoothbore cannons, shooting "Beehive" rounds.

"Shotgun" the kassams in midair (PULL, Blam, PULL, etc)

I got the idea from a WW2 story my father told me, he was an Army Engineer island-hopping
(Building runways to blast the next island, said he was always three islands behind the fighting)

They had a Japanese "Night Bomber" that came over every night as harrassment, usualy didn't hit anything, but kept them awake, and when he asked for help, they sent him a "Skysweeper" (I had to look it up) a radar controlled 5 inch naval rifle (Big gun) mounted on a semitrailer, with two other trailers, (Powerplant, and control), they set this up and that night when the Night Bomber camse over, shot him down with only three shots.
Posted by: Redneck Jim   2008-02-19 14:53  

#7  And which Hizb'allah is known to have received from Iran, and which Hamas covets if they haven't yet received theirs.
Posted by: lotp   2008-02-19 13:50  

#6  I doubt the current system could stop very many of the Kassam projectiles because the Kassems are small (typically 6' long) and they don't reach very high altitudes (say 1/4 mile).

The system the Israelis are making is almost certainly designed to stop actual missiles which would be larger and longer range.
Posted by: mhw   2008-02-19 11:44  

#5  IIRC, in cost benefit analysis of safety projects, a human life is typically valued at 1-2 million dollars based on the NPV of future earnings, sometimes confirmed by studies of actual choices people make in transportation, appliance purchases, etc.

Based on that, using $50k missiles is quite justified if you think the Kassams are actually likely to hit anything.

Thats not even going into the political consideratons. I mean if its not worth firing a 50,000 dollar missile to stop qassams, is it worth much more expensive ground operations?
Posted by: liberalhawk   2008-02-19 11:03  

#4  Personally, I think it would be more effective and cost-effective to just bounce the rubble a little deeper into Gaza every time there are rocket attacks. Level another 1/4 mile with each attack and guarantee Hamas that you'll go all the way to the Mediterranean if you have to.
Posted by: Darrell   2008-02-19 09:16  

#3  Launching 2x $50,000 missiles against a $100 rocket sounds like a winning strategy.
Posted by: ed   2008-02-19 09:06  

#2  Mao: Bamboo Curtain at advanced stage, will capture Kassams when they fly
Posted by: Mao   2008-02-19 08:32  

#1  Iron Dome sounds too 60s Maoist for my taste, but if it works?
Posted by: phil_b   2008-02-19 02:55  

00:00