You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
Lance Corporal Matt Croucher hurls himself onto Taliban grenade
2008-03-30
Just a reminder that it's the MoD who's wimpy, not the Brit troops.
A Royal Marine in southern Afghanistan threw himself onto an exploding grenade to save the lives of his patrol.

Miraculously, Lance Corporal Matt Croucher, a marine reservist from Birmingham, survived the blast with little injury when his rucksack and body armour took the force of the blast. He is expected to receive one of the highest awards for gallantry.

The story of his courage emerged last week in interviews with marines occupying a forward operating base near Sangin in Helmand province. They are preparing to leave after serving for six months at the centre of some of the fiercest fighting in Afghanistan. The outpost, Forward Operating Base Inkerman, is better known to troops as "FOB Incoming".

Croucher's action occurred just before dawn on February 9, as the reconnaissance troop from 40 Commando, operating to the south of Sangin, was searching a compound it suspected was being used for making bombs to attack British and Afghan troops.

Walking in the darkness among a group of four men, Croucher stepped into a tripwire that pulled the pin from a boobytrap grenade. His patrol commander, Corporal Adam Lesley, remembered Croucher's shout of: "Grenade!"

As others dived for cover, Croucher, 24, did something nobody expected. He lay down on the grenade to smother the blast. Lesley got on the ground, another man got behind a wall, but the last member of the patrol was still standing in the open when the grenade went off.

"My reaction was, 'My God this can't be real'," said Lesley. "Croucher had simply lain back and used his day sack to blunt the force of the explosion. You would expect nine out of 10 people to die in that situation."

Then they waited. "It felt like a lifetime," said Lesley. When the grenade went off it blew Croucher's rucksack more than 30ft and sent a burning radio battery fizzing into the air. As the noise died down, one of the patrol, Marine Scott Easter, was standing "just completely frozen" and untouched. Croucher was in deep shock but, apart from a bloody nose, had few injuries. "He had shrapnel in his helmet, in the plate of his body armour, but he was basically okay," said Lesley. "His day sack had taken the blast."

Croucher told the News of the World: "All I could hear was a loud ringing and the faint sound of people shouting 'are you ok? Are you ok?'

"Then I felt one of the lads giving me a top to toe check. My head was ringing. Blood was streaming from my nose. It took 30 seconds before I realised I was definitely not dead," he added.

The troop commander, Captain Dan Venables, said they decided to exploit the incident. "I made the decision that after the grenade went off, the Taliban would come to see what had happened. So we lay in wait and ambushed them."

Croucher's actions prompted his colleagues to pass a citation to the Commanding Officer of 40 Commando, Lieutenant Colonel Stuart Birrell, to recommend him for the Victoria Cross. "It's a pretty unusual thing but the lads put me forward for the VC themselves.
Posted by:Fred

#15  But ... he ruined a perfectly good radio that way! Prob'ly get docked from his pay.
Posted by: Brian H   2008-03-30 22:31  

#14  TW, he chose the back because he had a huge backpack, that with the armored vest was enough to absorb the blast, no pack on front, more likely for death or injury, Mighty quick thinker that lad.
Posted by: Redneck Jim   2008-03-30 15:39  

#13  It's never smart to sacrifice oneself to save one's comrades. Which makes doing so even more brave and noble... and dumb if it wasn't necessary. But in this case, one of Lance Corporal Croucher's patrol froze instead of dropping to the ground or getting behind cover, so Cpl Croucher's brave action resulted in the saving of a comrade's life. Although why he decided in that brief moment to lie down on his back on the thing is quite beyond me.
Posted by: trailing wife    2008-03-30 14:05  

#12  Maybe his Mates were standing up and didn't see the grenade so he jumped on it to keep them from getting hurt. I'd share a foxhole with him.
Posted by: Deacon Blues   2008-03-30 13:30  

#11  ...how about demonstrating it the correct way and posting the video so I can understand. I don't quite get it from your descriptions.

The physics is, explosions, like water, will follow the path of least resistance. Ground offers more resistance than air. Their will be some dirt removed, simply because of the force of the blast, but a good 80-90% of the explosion goes into the air, carrying shrapnel, dirt and other. This causes a hourglass shape of explosion. The plane of the explosion will be the "waist" and is generally at ground level. That is why the safest place to be is on the ground near an explosion on the ground. The blast will travel some 4-6 inches off the ground and above. That is why proximity fuses on artillery are great. If the round explodes some 4-5 feet off the ground, the hourglass shape doesn't happen and you get a nice sphere. Also, dropping to the dirt won't save your ass anymore. The same idea is used with a "bouncing Betty" anti-personal mine. It jumps up to waist level (3-4 feet) and explodes above the ground, peppering everything around it with shrapnel.
Posted by: DarthVader   2008-03-30 12:29  

#10  The bravery and competence of "Tommy" has never been in question.

However, the politicals, and the military leadership that has allowed itself to be come politicized, those are a different question.
Posted by: OldSpook   2008-03-30 12:09  

#9  jumping on it is instinct.

supposed to go flat prone with you helm toward it (your best armor point) and arms tucked under (grab yer nuts is what we were told), so as to present the minimum profile. Used to be feet toward it until the Kpot came around (the old WW2 steel jobs were not all that great against grenades).
Posted by: OldSpook   2008-03-30 12:06  

#8  You guys who are huffing that the Lance Corporal did it all wrong, how about demonstrating it the correct way and posting the video so I can understand. I don't quite get it from your descriptions.
Posted by: Titus Cloling7944   2008-03-30 11:05  

#7  Moose, very good advice. I always thought and did the same thing. Just get as flat as you can as fast as you can (terrain depending)...."running" for cover usual is what gets you hurt. But, wow, these young guys are amazing, huh?
Posted by: Guillibaldo Thogum8821   2008-03-30 10:34  

#6  Still and all, a gutsy move.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2008-03-30 07:58  

#5  It seems to me that the MoH thing would probably be wheeled out for PR, and the SS would probably be the MC's way of saying "Brave, but we don't want you to make a practice of it because there are better ways. And some PR, of course!".
Posted by: gorb   2008-03-30 03:20  

#4  When my son was in Marine Corps boot camp in 1996, they told him that if they threw themselves on a grenade and died, they would get the Medal of Honor, but if they lived, they'd only get the Silver Star. (Not that they were recommending doing it.)
I never quite figured that one out.
Posted by: Rambler in California   2008-03-30 02:44  

#3  I got a lecture from a combat NCO once on blast physics, and why there are few if any reasons to jump on a grenade. Even if you are lying prone just two or three feet away from one, there's a good chance that the worst you'll get is a ruptured eardrum and what he called "band-aid" frag.

But you *don't* want to be standing up near one. If you are its blast cone, you are boned. But the blast cone is a 45 degree up angle from where it is on the ground. Outside of that cone, there is a lot less of everything.

He figured that unless you get an airburst, if it manages to hit the ground, the odds favor at least 1/2 to 1 second to get flat, even if the thrower cooked it off before throwing. This is because most throwers give themselves extra time, even if they know what they are doing.

If it is an inexperienced or scared thrower, you could have 2 or three very long seconds to get out of there. Unless you are lying on top of the grenade.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2008-03-30 00:50  

#2  So...does he win the Victoria Cross or will he be charged with an anti Muslim hate crime when he gets back to England?
Posted by: tu3031   2008-03-30 00:48  

#1  agreed, Fred. It's a management/decision loop problem above the front lines to the PM that sucks
Posted by: Frank G   2008-03-30 00:16  

00:00