You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Britain
Britain: Terror suspects claim detention caused mental harm
2008-05-21
(AKI) - The European Court of Human Rights is to consider claims from eleven terrorism suspects that they suffered psychiatric damage when they were imprisoned by the British government.

On Wednesday the court will hold a public hearing in Strasbourg to investigate the claims in a case brought against the British government.

The applicants, none of whom have British nationality, were allegedly involved in extreme Islamist terrorist groups with links to al-Qaeda, the court said in a statement. Six of the applicants are Algerian, and the others are French, Jordanian, Moroccan and Tunisian. Another was born in a Palestinian refugee camp in Jordan, and is stateless.

All eleven were detained after al-Qaeda's 11 September, 2001 attacks in the US. They were imprisoned at various times between December 2001 and October 2003 and initially held at Belmarsh Prison in London under Britain's 2001 Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act.

All the men were allegedly involved in Islamist terrorist groups with links to al-Qaeda such as the Salafite Group for Prayer and Combat (GSPC) formed in Algeria in 1998, the Tunisia Fighting Group. The men are also said to be linked to a group of Algerian terrorists centred around al-Qaeda and GSPC member Abu Doha, known for his senior role in terror training camps in Afghanistan. He was also linked to a Frankfurt-based cell accused of plotting to bomb the Strasbourg Christmas market in December, 1995.

The eleven are suspected of supplying false documents, purchasing IT equipment and helping young British Muslims travel from the UK to train for Jihad (holy war) in Afghanistan. Three of the men were subsequently transferred to Broadmoor secure mental hospital following a deterioration in their mental health, including a suicide attempt. Another was released on bail in April 2004 under conditions equivalent to house arrest, owing to serious concerns over his mental health.

A visit by Europe's top human rights watchdog, The Council of Europe's Committee for the Prevention of Torture, criticised the applicants' conditions of detention in Belmarsh Prison and Broadmoor Hospital and reported allegations of ill-treatment by staff. In a report, The Council of Europe committee concluded the applicants' poor mental state was exacerbated by the indefinite nature of their detention.

The British Government categorically rejected the suggestion that the applicants were treated in an inhuman or degrading manner at any point during their detention.

As well as the mental harm they claim their detention in Britain caused them, the men also allege their detention was unlawful and they had only limited knowledge of the case against them and ability to challenge it.

Eight of the men still in prison or at Broadmoor were released after Part 4 of the 2001 Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act was repealed. This followed a March 2005 ruling against it on human rights grounds by the House of Lords, Britain's upper house of parliament, sitting as the country's highest court .

The eight men were then placed under control orders, a series of restrictions on the freedom of movement of terrorism suspects. The control orders were brought in by Britain's Prevention of Terrorism Act 2005 to replace indefinite detention.

More recently, six of the men were place in immigration custody pending deportation to Algeria and Jordan, the European Court of Human Rights (photo) said. Two of the men have returned voluntarily to their home countries, a court official told Adnkronos International.
Posted by:Fred

#7  And a harem, as is every muslim's right.
Posted by: ed   2008-05-21 21:48  

#6  So if the Brits give em lotsa money they'll be all better, right?
Posted by: tu3031   2008-05-21 21:29  

#5  The mental damage was caused prior to detention.
Posted by: JohnQC   2008-05-21 16:22  

#4  We've adequately established over the last few weeks that Britain has left the west. Welcome Britistan.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2008-05-21 13:01  

#3  More to the point, this is the West?

If so, the West as a whole is lost.
Posted by: lotp   2008-05-21 12:04  

#2  Such delicate flowers... ready to fight the kufrs by maiming and killing random innocents, and seeing themselves as Lions of Islam™, spearheads of the Glorious Struggle™... but who can't stand being held in 21st century western jail conditions, and whose whining claims are taken seriously enough to be used by the tranzis to wage lawfare.

Damn, I wonder how they would cope in any third world hellhole prison... do you think they would fare well say in a gang-managed latin american prison, where convicts routinely hack each others with machete (or battle over turf with firearms and grenades), or, God forbid!, in an earlier-era western jail (think of the reform-through-work literal slave camps of victorian GB, used to better the "dangerous classes" in hardships inconceivable today for a correctional facility, and yet, those were not for actual criminals,... or the post-WWII juvenile reform facilities in France, a mix of hardcore, ruthless violence between the kids, and less than spartiate living conditions with a militaristic management)?

Those are the "hard boyz" of Jihad™? Damn.
Posted by: anonymous5089   2008-05-21 05:44  

#1  one must posses the rudiments of a mind before any "mental" damage can occur otherwise you are excluded from the 'mentally damaged pool'.
Posted by: RD   2008-05-21 01:22  

00:00