You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Israel using 'brute force' to shift balance of power
2009-01-01
(AKI) - Israel is using 'brute force' in its attacks in the Gaza Strip in a bid to change the balance of power in the Middle East, a Lebanese political analyst said on Tuesday. Talal Nizameddin, a political analyst at The American University of Beirut told Adnkronos International (AKI) while Israel is targeting Hamas in Gaza, it also has a broader strategy linked to the 2006 Lebanon War.

"This military operation is intended show that Israel can rely on the military option to achieve its aim, and it wants to show its enemies - and not only the Palestinians - that it can use brute force to change the balance of power in the region," Nizameddin said in a telephone interview from Beirut.

More than 360 people have been killed since Israel began intense air attacks in the Gaza Strip last weekend.

The Israeli Defense Forces said the operations in Gaza were in response to the continued firing of rockets and mortar shells on Israeli territory, and that it intended to destroy the infrastructure of the militant Hamas organisation.

Targets included Hamas training camps, headquarters, large weapons storage facilities, and missile launching pads in the Gaza Strip, it said.

Nizameddin told AKI that the operation could be part of a broader policy targeting Iran, Syria and the Lebanese Hezbollah Islamist movement, as well as Hamas. He said the Israeli action in Gaza could be a precursor to a broader military operation, which could include Lebanon.

"There could be a follow up attack on Hezbollah, or Palestinian groups in Lebanon could fire rockets at Israel, who would in turn retaliate," he said.

Nizameddin also said the latest Gaza offensive could further strengthen the Lebanese Shia cleric Hassan Nasrallah and his ally, Iran. On Monday, tens of thousands of people gathered in the south of Beirut to protest against the raids. The rally had been called by Nasrallah a day earlier.

"If Israel succeeds - and it does not look like it will succeed - but if it does succeed, it would greatly weaken Hezbollah and Iran. However, if there is a ceasefire or the war drags on or becomes more protracted, it could greatly strengthen Nasrallah and Iran in the long run," Nizameddin told AKI.

Nizameddin, lecturer and associate dean of student affairs at The American University of Beirut, pointed out that there could be more protests in the Lebanese capital, particularly as people gather for the Shia celebrations of Ashura this week.

"I do not think we have seen the largest protests yet, until after New Year's Day when we may see the closure of universities and daily protests, but it depends on how events unfold in Gaza," Nizameddin said.

Nadim Shehadi, a Middle East expert from the London think-tank Chatham House, warned there would be widespread political repercussions and Israel's action would put more pressure on Saudi Arabia, Jordan and Egypt.

"This is discrediting all the moderate forces in the region, and all the allies of the United States because of their inability to stop it and they are seen to be in alliance with this ," Shehadi told Adnkronos International (AKI) from Beirut.

"Killing people for the sake of killing people will not achieve any result. On the contrary it will create more anger and more support for the people they are trying to fight."

"When the battles die down, how will they look? What is the political cost?"

He said the United Nations, the Arab League and the European Union were looking "completely useless" and Israel's military action would boost Iran's clout in the region.

"This is weakening all of Iran's adversaries in the region, the Saudis, the Egyptians," he said.

Both Shehadi and Nizameddin were pessimistic about the prospects for peace particularly since Syria suspended Turkish-mediated peace talks with Israel.
Posted by:Fred

#16  "Of course, an Arab can't understand the difference." - Old patriot.

No, it's an obvious fact(to the whole discerning world) that that's a clear and serious flaw in his psychological make-up. That propensity for one track mind thinking and blame projection on to others. Himself being always righteous without par!

Was it a wonder why Ishmael was likened to a donkey in Genesis?
Posted by: Duh!   2009-01-01 23:48  

#15  let the Israelis shwo some real brtue force:

Hub to hub 155' HE, followed by side-by-side D9's scraping the debris for a 2Km "dead zone" along the border wiht Israel. Push the Debris up to build a big berm at the border.

Then tell them for every rocket that hits Israel, Gaza loses a grid square to artillery to widen and deepen the zone.


Posted by: OldSpook   2009-01-01 22:13  

#14  "Brute Force" is flying over Gaza in a dozen B-52s, each dropping 76 500Lb iron bombs, three times a day for a week. Targeted killing involving precision weapons is only "brute force" against those on the receiving end. Of course, an Arab can't understand the difference.
Posted by: Old Patriot   2009-01-01 20:00  

#13  Brute Force - showed remarkable success in dealing with the Carthaginians.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2009-01-01 18:07  

#12  "I'm sure they'll listen to REASON..."
-- Snow Crash
Posted by: mojo   2009-01-01 16:18  

#11  "Brute Force"? Lt. Gen Krulak would approve
Posted by: Frank G   2009-01-01 14:58  

#10  when dealing with brutes, only brute force will do the trick
Posted by: Abu do you love   2009-01-01 14:22  

#9  "Killing people for the sake of killing people will not achieve any result."

Oh, I don't know. Killing the right people seems to do the trick. Ask the Argentinians.
Posted by: Milton Fandango   2009-01-01 12:35  

#8  This article is proof positive that virtually all arabs are full of shit, impotent, ignorant 8th century assholes.

But I may be generalizing.
Posted by: bigjim-ky   2009-01-01 12:22  

#7  "it will create more anger and more support for the people they are trying to fight."

And doing nothing, sitting there takign a beatring from faily rocket and mortar attack... that builds support for Israel?

No. It does not even make the damned slanted newspapers and TV news here in the USA.

The Press does not cover it, so there is no pressure brought to Hamas and its puppeteers in Iran.

Once again, the failure of the press to publsih ALL the news, and their imposing an ideological slant on things has caused harm to the west by presenting the flase as true, and only one side of things.

Israel is damend if they don;t strike, and damned if they do, in terms of "opinion" liek this idiot spouts.

So they make a decision on what will stop the enemy from killing innocent civilians inside israel.

And that means strikes to destroy the enemy and their capability to continue those strikes.

The Palestenians should be thankful that the Israelis are using precision weapons and specific targeting with their attacks. Were they as random and indiscriminate as the Hamas attacks, far more in Gaza would be dead. And were Hamas not putting missiles in apartment buildings and places like that, far fewer Gaza civilians would be dead.

Put the blame squarely where it deserves to be: Hamas and Iran.
Posted by: OldSpook   2009-01-01 10:22  

#6  If Israel were using brute force, there would be several hundred thousands dead Paleos---and the World would've been a better place.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2009-01-01 08:42  

#5  Do Islamofascists understand anything else? They want to dominate the Earth, one way or another, no? Starting with "Juice", i.e. Ain't it better that their gall should be eliminated, rather?
Posted by: Duh!   2009-01-01 05:42  

#4  "Killing people for the sake of killing people will not achieve any result. On the contrary it will create more anger and more support for the people they are trying to fight."


Ohkay. So Iz'rl is killing people for the sake of killing people. Not, say, killing specific people who, say, have been involved in activities trying to kill THEM, and preparing for much more of the same.

Guess I misunderstood. Figures - after all, I'm no Middle East expert from Chatham House.

Posted by: Verlaine   2009-01-01 01:30  

#3  Peace through superior brute force!
Posted by: Spike Uniter   2009-01-01 01:21  

#2  When persuasion doesn't work then it's time to try "brute force".
Posted by: tipover   2009-01-01 01:19  

#1  "Israel using 'brute force' to shift balance of power"

Works for me.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2009-01-01 00:55  

00:00