You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Meshaal: We will not accept Israel's demands for Gaza cease-fire
2009-01-17
Hamas will not accept Israel's conditions for a cease-fire in Gaza and will continue armed resistance until the offensive ends, Khaled Meshal, the leader of the Palestinian Islamist group, said on Friday.

Speaking at the opening of an emergency meeting on Gaza in Doha, Meshal called on the leaders present to cut all ties with Israel. Meshal joined Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in a surprise appearance at the summit, aimed to show their weight in diplomatic efforts surrounding the Gaza crisis.

Hamas was to send a delegation to Cairo on Friday to discuss Egyptian efforts to mediate a cease-fire in Gaza, a Hamas official told Al-Jazeera television.

Meshal's comments contradicted a report published in the al-Sharq al-Awset daily on Friday, which claimed Hamas was prepared to accept a conditional cease-fire with Israel starting on Saturday. According to the report, Hamas has set five conditions for the cease-fire:

1. The reciprocal truce would begin on Saturday and be followed by the immediate transfer of humanitarian aid into the Gaza Strip.

2. The Israel Defense Forces must pull all of its troops out of the coastal territory within the first week of the truce.

3. The flow of trade in and out of the Gaza Strip must be renewed and monitored by observers from Egypt, Europe, and Turkey.

4. The Rafah crossing must be reopened and supervised by Palestinian Authority security forces and international observers, until a Palestinian unity government has been established and can take its place.

5. The truce would be instated for one year with an option for renewal.

Meanwhile, Syrian President Pencilneck Bashar Assad said Friday that the Arab initiative for peace with Israel is "dead" because of its offensive in the Gaza Strip. Speaking at the summit in Qatar, Assad called on the participating Arab countries to sever "all direct and indirect" ties with Israel in protest against its continued operation in the coastal strip.

Ahmadinejad, who is also attending the meeting of Arab and Muslim leaders in Qatar, said the Gaza offensive proved that Israel was in its last throes. Muslim nations "need to cut relations with Israel and America. Just ties. They don't need to do anything more than that," Ahmadinejad said Friday, according to an Arabic translation of his comments.

Earlier Friday, Israeli and Western sources said that Jerusalem has rebuffed some of the conditions initially set forth by Hamas for an Egyptian-proposed truce in the Gaza Strip, including how long it would last and who would manage the border crossings. Jerusalem has expressed reservations regarding the Islamist group's terms, despite Cairo's apparent promise to crack down on arms smuggling to Gaza - one of Israel's key demands - and Hamas's willingness to accept the offer.

The Israeli and Western sources said Israel had objected to putting a
time limit on the truce. Hamas proposed a 12-month agreement that could later be extended. "A time limit on any period of quiet is a mistake," a senior Israeli source said. "We saw that when the previous calm ran out of time, it was just an excuse for some to escalate the violence. An open-ended calm is what is needed."

Another Israeli source said that defense official Amos Gilad, who heads the Defense Ministry's diplomatic-security department, returned from his first day of talks in Egypt on Thursday with a reassuring report of progress. Upon his return, Gilad headed straight to Jerusalem to report to Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, Defense Minister Ehud Barak and Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni. Gilad was back in Cairo on Friday for further negotiations.

The diplomatic-security cabinet was to meet Friday to vote on the offer, but decided to put off the debate until Gilad returns to Israel with an additional report.

Meanwhile, Livni headed to Washington on Friday to sign a deal of understanding with her American counterpart Condoleezza Rice on the joint supervision and treatment of weapons smuggling from Iran to the Gaza Strip. "Prime Minister Ehud Olmert authorized this evening the trip of Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni to the United States in order to promote an American-Israeli outlined agreement intended to deal with weapons smuggling," Olmert's office said in a statement.

UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said Thursday that he believed a cease-fire could be signed in a few days, but this depends on Israel's leadership.

The Egyptian truce proposal, of which Haaretz obtained a copy Thursday, contains three clauses.

First, Israel and the Palestinians would agree to an immediate, time-limited cease-fire, during which the border crossings will be opened for humanitarian aid and Egypt will lead negotiations on a long-term truce.

Second, the long-term truce must include provisions on both border security and an end to the blockade of Gaza.

Third, Fatah and Hamas should resume reconciliation talks.

Egyptian officials told Haaretz they believe the initial, short-term truce should last a few months, to allow plenty of time for negotiations on the long-term cease-fire. However, the proposal does not require Israel to withdraw from Gaza during the initial truce, and Hamas has said it will not accept the proposal unless that omission is corrected.

Salah al-Bardawil, who was Hamas's Gazan representative to the talks with Egypt, said his organization demands that Israel completely withdraw within five days of whenever the initial cease-fire takes effect. Hamas also insists that the agreement include a deadline by which the border crossings must reopen.

Israel, for its part, insists that the crossings not be reopened until the smuggling issue is resolved to its satisfaction. It also wants Hamas to agree to an explicit timetable for concluding a deal on kidnapped soldier Gilad Shalit and to be more flexible in what it is demanding in exchange for Shalit.
Posted by:Fred

#11  Speaking at the opening of an emergency meeting on Gaza in Doha
This courageous "lion of Islam" is speaking for Hamas/Gaza all the way from Qatar.
Posted by: Darrell   2009-01-17 15:45  

#10  Hey idiot-stick: the WINNER gets to set terms, not the loser. Shut your piehole and go back into your manmade cave, hide behind your woman's skirts, and whimper like the sorry-a$$ed loser you are.

Israel: pound Gaza into dust. No need for a cease-fire after that.
Posted by: Old Patriot   2009-01-17 14:59  

#9  It's just a flesh wound. Come back here and fight!
Posted by: DMFD   2009-01-17 13:49  

#8  An Israeli bang bang, shoot 'em up, followed by a hasty retreat will just provide

With time to realise how badly they've been f*cked, and how much worse the next time is going to be.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2009-01-17 13:29  

#7  Meshaal says no to Israeli conditions for a cease fire. Let the war continue. I just hope that international pressure doesn't force IDF out before the job is done. Israel needs to do something like what we dis in Iraq. If they can establish security and set up a government that can maintain that security, then there can be some peace with legs. An Israeli bang bang, shoot 'em up, followed by a hasty retreat will just provide a lull until the Gazans rebuild their weapon inventory.
Posted by: Richard of Oregon   2009-01-17 08:52  

#6  Thank G*d for Meshal.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2009-01-17 06:54  

#5  until a Palestinian unity government has been established and can take its place.

Hummmmmmm...... maybe djues were fibbing about war aims.
Posted by: .5MT   2009-01-17 06:11  

#4  Must be election time in Israel.
Posted by: Slonter Lumumba2615   2009-01-17 01:14  

#3  ION TOPIX > ISRAEL WARNS LEBANON OF LARGER WAR, iff the pro-Paleo/Gaza rocket attacks into Northern Israel from Leb don't cease [full-scale = potent IDF military retaliation]???
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2009-01-17 01:12  

#2  Break them. Once they know they're defeated, they'll agree to a ceasefire with a token facesaving condition. And make sure they hand of Shalit as a 'good faith gesture'
Posted by: Mike N.   2009-01-17 01:03  

#1  Hamas has set five conditions for the cease-fire:

1. The reciprocal truce would begin on Saturday and be followed by the immediate transfer of humanitarian aid into the Gaza Strip.


Still not serious. If they were, item #1 would be "Please don't kill us!"
Posted by: SteveS   2009-01-17 00:48  

00:00