You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
Docs worried soldier was 'psychotic'
2009-11-12
US military doctors had worried that the suspected gunman in the Fort Hood shootings was "psychotic" and unstable but did not seek to sack him, National Public Radio reported today, citing unnamed officials.

Psychiatrists and medical officials who oversaw Major Nidal Hasan, accused of opening fire on fellow soldiers at the Fort Hood base in Texas last week, held a series of meetings between the northern spring of 2008 and the spring of this year to discuss serious concerns about his work and his behaviour, NPR reported. "Put it this way. Everybody felt that if you were deployed to Iraq or Afghanistan, you would not want Nidal Hasan in your foxhole," one official was quoted as saying.
In that case, why the hell was he on orders and not in Chapter 13?
One official who participated in the conversations had reportedly told colleagues that he was concerned Hasan might leak secret military information to Islamic extremists if he was assigned to Iraq or Afghanistan, NPR said.

Another official "wondered aloud" to colleagues whether Hasan might be capable of killing fellow soldiers in the same way a Muslim sergeant in 2003 had set off grenades at a base in Kuwait and claimed the lives to two comrades, the radio reported.

The officials who discussed Hasan's status were not aware - as some top Walter Reed hospital officials were - that intelligence agencies had been tracking Hasan's emails to a radical Islamic cleric since December 2008, NPR said.

The NPR report cited interviews with several officials from Walter Reed Medical Centre in Washington and the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences in Maryland.

Officials considered kicking Hasan out of the program but chose not to partly because sacking a doctor was a "cumbersome and lengthy" process that involves hearings and potential legal conflict, sources told NPR.

Officials also believed they lacked solid evidence that Hasan was unstable and were concerned they could be accused of discriminating against him because of his Islamic identity or views.

With Hasan due to leave Walter Reed after six years and transfer to Fort Hood in Texas, officials thought the larger psychiatric staff at that army base would be better placed to provide support to Hasan and to monitor him, according to NPR.
Posted by:tipper

#8  I've heard secondhand reports that the lives of mental patients in the Middle East kinda suck very hard. Or that may just be the ones who don't murder westerners.

Or local unbelievers, Snowy Thing. But in this case it's a technique aimed at Western juries. I'm not sure it's been very successful in getting lower sentences, though.
Posted by: trailing wife   2009-11-12 22:48  

#7  Need to be looking in the Koran and not the DSM-IV.
Posted by: JohnQC   2009-11-12 15:47  

#6  It's called jihad.
Posted by: JohnQC   2009-11-12 15:40  

#5  I don't buy any of this. It is a socially acceptable way for Muslims to "get over" from punishments by infidels, for heinous crimes, by feigning mental illness. This is because Islam almost equates insanity with heavenly inspiration for Jihad. It has no stigma. "Allah made me do it."

I've heard secondhand reports that the lives of mental patients in the Middle East kinda suck very hard. Or that may just be the ones who don't murder westerners.
Posted by: Thing From Snowy Mountain   2009-11-12 11:56  

#4  Maj Hasan was sane. He had a Koran, he reproduced Koranic statements accurately, he form an ethical system based on those statements and his actions were consistent with his ethical system.

The Islamic apologists are the ones who are daft here. They know the facts but deny the facts - that's insane.
Posted by: lord garth   2009-11-12 09:55  

#3  I don't buy any of this. It is a socially acceptable way for Muslims to "get over" from punishments by infidels, for heinous crimes, by feigning mental illness. This is because Islam almost equates insanity with heavenly inspiration for Jihad. It has no stigma. "Allah made me do it."

This is similar to the defense they use for whimsical violent acts against each other, claiming that it was justified in the Koran, somewhere. I could kill them because somebody made a fatwa against them sometime.

So when someone chimes in that Hasan might have been mentally ill, it should be rebutted that ALL terrorists are mentally ill, but that does not stop anyone from hunting them down and slaughtering them like rabid dogs before they can murder more innocent people.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2009-11-12 03:56  

#2  "Put it this way. Everybody felt that if you were deployed to Iraq or Afghanistan, you would not want Nidal Hasan in your foxhole," one official was quoted as saying.

Officials considered kicking Hasan out of the program but chose not to partly because sacking a doctor was a "cumbersome and lengthy" process that involves hearings and potential legal conflict, sources told NPR.

I can think of at least 13 things which are now much more cumbersone and lengthy.....
Posted by: CrazyFool   2009-11-12 01:27  

#1  David Martin on CBS Evening News reported that Hasan's colleagues at Walter Reed refused to refer anyone to him. Looks bad.
Posted by: Anguper Hupomosing9418   2009-11-12 00:15  

00:00