You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Lethal Injection Doctors to be Banned from Hospitals
2010-05-02
A national physicians organization has quietly decided to revoke the certification of any member who participates in executing a prisoner by lethal injection.
Consulting, witnessing, or injecting, apparently.
The mandate from the American Board of Anesthesiologists reflects its leaders' belief that "we are healers, not executioners," board secretary Mark A. Rockoff said. Although the American Medical Association has long opposed doctor involvement, the anesthesiologists' group is the first to say it will harshly penalize a health-care worker for abetting lethal injections. The loss of certification would prevent an anesthesiologist from working in most hospitals.

About half of the 35 states performing executions, including Virginia and North Carolina, require a doctor to be present.
Do they get banned for being there?
Other states have also recruited doctors, including anesthesiologists, to play a role in executions involving lethal injections. In some jurisdictions, anesthesiologists consult prison officials on dosages. In others, they insert catheters and infuse the three-drug cocktails.

While death penalty opponents welcome the move because it raises yet more obstacles questions about lethal injections, capital punishment supporters contend that doctors are not needed during the procedures, which can be administered by prison employees. But as questions mount about the types and combinations of drugs used and whether they cause undue suffering, states have been turning to doctors for advice and assistance. With 3,200 prisoners now on death rows across the country, most of the 50 executions performed each year since 2008 have used lethal injections.

"If I were lying there on the gurney and someone was administering a paralyzing drug ... I would want someone there who knew what they were doing," said Ty Alper, associate director of the Death Penalty Clinic at the University of California at Berkeley's School of Law. "Just like if I was getting surgery - I wouldn't want a prison guard administering the anesthesia."
Posted by:Bobby

#9  Calling Doctor Kevorkian. Calling Doctor Kevorkian. Please report to the lethal injection room immediately. Your patient is waiting.
Posted by: Alaska Paul   2010-05-02 23:52  

#8  Shipman: Just think of him as being ahead of his time. An innovator. Had he been a strong Labourite, Tony Blair probably would have put him in charge of the NHS.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2010-05-02 18:36  

#7  I can feel your character gaining strength from halfway across the country, Shipman. At this rate, that six-pack is going to be a 12-pack, and you'll be beating off pretty girls with a stick. ;-)
Posted by: trailing wife   2010-05-02 14:49  

#6  Naturally, family ties prevent me from maker the comments on this.


/Glares at MODS ferocously
Posted by: Shipman   2010-05-02 10:05  

#5  Yes, yes, of course. Pull their cert if they do the people and state's bidding. However, if they make an 'ooops' in normal practice that results in death of their patients, the same board will hem and haw and wash their hands of issues of malpractice resulting in society turning to tort lawyers to get some form of justice. /sarc off
Posted by: Procopius2k   2010-05-02 09:06  

#4  I think this is a good idea. While doctors can determine that an executed prisoner is dead, for the sake of the death certificate, actually having them kill, including euthanasia, is a damn foolish idea.

The entire reason lethal injection is used is not because it is a better form of execution, but because it is more aesthetically pleasing for the witnesses. But there should be no pretense that execution is easy.

Perhaps the best form of execution is electrocution, because it fries the brain faster than it can feel pain. Other than mechanical error, the only time it might have ever failed was with cannibal Albert Fish, because he had spent a lifetime inserting and leaving needles inside his body.

In the absence of electrocution, a noose or firing squad is still quite acceptable. The gas chamber can be problematic, however, because if the prisoner just breathes normally instead of holds their breath, it can take a long, painful time for them to suffocate.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2010-05-02 08:50  

#3  Dr. George Tiller to the white emergency phone, Dr. George Til...... oh, sorry nevermind.
Posted by: Besoeker   2010-05-02 08:44  

#2  Put 'em in a concrete pit strapped atop a decent sized artillery shell - no doctor required if you can't find a corpse.
Posted by: Bulldog   2010-05-02 08:00  

#1  "hang by the neck until dead" still works
Posted by: john frum   2010-05-02 07:47  

00:00