You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Muslim soldier: Army has not addressed harassment complaints
2010-05-19
Excerpt: During his two years in the military, Klawonn said he has filed more than 20 complaints of harassment for being Muslim.


....the enemy within....

I'm going to disagree.

In the Algerian civil war, one of the several reasons why the French lost (other than DeGaulle, feckless leadership and stupidity) was that the French tended to view every brown-skinned person in Algeria as an enemy, and acted accordingly. After a while, most brown-skinned people there were their enemy.

The quickest way to turn all American Muslims into enemies is to treat them as enemies.

If an American of Muslim faith joins our military, he/she is a soldier with exactly the same obligations, responsibilities and rights as any other soldier. Prudence demands that such individuals demonstrate their loyalty to our country, but we expect loyalty from every soldier.

This particular soldier has a valid complaint: he was moved off base for his safety but then was treated poorly. The chain of command should fix that, in part because it's right and in part to demonstrate that loyalty and respect are two-way streets.

This soldier also has a responsibility not just to do his job, but to bear witness to what he believes is his personal faith by demonstrating that a Muslim can be an American soldier. Sometimes that means buttoning your lip and leading by example.

But this man has done nothing to suggest that he's disloyal. Unless and until he does, he has the respect I give to every member of our military.
Posted by:Uncle Phester

#5  "Let's not rush to judgement."
BS aka BHO
Posted by: Besoeker   2010-05-19 19:01  

#4  Thanks Cyber Sarge. My take is that this Muslim Soldier is acting as a cancer on his squad and platoon.

Affirmative Action is preventing his C/O and others from effectively dealing with, what I surmise is, a malcontent who has figured out that he can be a pain in the ass without a downside....

Posted by: Uncle Phester   2010-05-19 18:57  

#3  You don't understand DG. He's preparing an excuse for when he cuts loose with an M16 on fellow servicemen.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2010-05-19 11:19  

#2  Â“Â…said Klawonn, who has retained an attorney through the Military Religious Freedom Foundation to prepare a lawsuit against the military.”

Oh, you mean the same Military Religious Freedom Foundation that want’s the military to remove the emblem of Evans Army Community Hospital at Fort Carson because they say it’s a “reference to the Crusades and could embolden U.S. enemies who want to portray the war on terror as a Christian war on Islam”? The same MRFF whose president said, “We’re fighting al-Qaeda, we’re fighting the Taliban, and we’re turning our own military into the exact same thing”? Yeah…Ok…so that Koran desecration thingey Klawonn alleges may need to be further investigated…just sayin’.
Posted by: DepotGuy   2010-05-19 10:31  

#1  And I am going to disagree with you. 20 complaints in two years of service? What kind of complaints? Also cultural sensitivity cuts both ways. Not saying that threats were warranted but what brought them on? What did his squad and platoon leaders do? I don't think we are getting the whole story here.
Posted by: Cyber Sarge   2010-05-19 08:53  

00:00