| Submit your comments on this article |
| --Tech & Moderator Notes |
| What Korea says about US |
| 2010-05-31 |
| by Steve White The sinking of the South Korean navy corvette Cheonan this spring was and remains an act of war. The investigation conducted by South Korea, careful and painstaking, makes clear beyond any reasonable doubt that elements of the North Korean Navy sank the ship. The Western rim of the Pacific now is contemplating what South Korea and the U.S. will do in response. Go to the U.N.? Stage new exercises? Tighten sanctions? Persuade the Chinese to withdraw their support of Kim Jung-Il? All that is important. None of that matters. What matters is this: our enemies have taken our measure. We are undone. To borrow the inscription on the wall: Mene, Mene, Tekel, Upharsin. We have been weighed and have been found wanting. The North Koreans, the Chinese, the Iranians, the Pakistanis, and the Russians understand what we have become in two short years. In that time we went from having a resolute leader who somewhat understood the world and who somehow managed to move a divided country to doing what was right in Iraq, to now having an irresolute, inept leader who puts politics ahead of both understanding and principle. In a country that remains as sharply divided as before, this is a recipe for disaster. We have been looking for that disaster to unfold in the Persian Gulf, but it may well unfold instead on the Korean peninsula. South Korea has a well-trained military but is saddled with generals who look to American generals for guidance and approval, and political leaders who are as feckless and unprincipled as our own. The South Korean people, liberated from authoritarian rule just a generation ago and only now enjoying the fruits of their labors as a new, first-world country, not only do not want a war with the North -- they cannot conceive of it. They see the confrontation with their northern cousins more like the ‘sitzkrieg' of France versus Germany in early 1940. That is not stable, but they do not see that. Bad as that lack of vision is, what is worse is that the left side of the South Korean political divide is more strident then that of America, hard as that is to believe. Their Left is as willing, indeed more so, to sell their own country down the river as is our own. That means that South Korea does not have the inner confidence to solve this problem and will instead look to the United States. Does anyone think that Barack Obama possesses the wisdom, political will, and leadership necessary to manage the new menace that North Korea insists on being? No. We know it. Our enemies know it. We know that a full, conventional war in South Korea would be horrific, which is why we shy away from it. We understand that the city of Seoul, home to ten million people, is essentially held hostage by North Korean artillery. North Korea could use weapons of mass destruction. It could infiltrate the south with commandos who could attack military bases or further the attacks on civilians. It would be cold comfort to the people of South Korea to see hundreds of thousands of their own citizens dead, dying and wounded in a war that they eventually would ‘win'. We also know that ‘winning' a war with North Korea means occupying it, and that in turn means feeding the survivors. Those survivors may not be grateful for being ‘liberated' from an army-first policy of juche, no matter how many concentration labor camps are emptied. Most of the North Korean people are but a couple hundred calories per week away from abject starvation. A peninsular conventional war will quickly wreck -- indeed, it must do so -- the transport, electricity and storage that provides the little amount of food that North Korean civilians eat. They know it; their leaders have used food as tool of political control. It is exquisite and masterful, the consummate demonstration of absolute power that should land those responsible in Dante's eighth circle. So the North Koreans should welcome us as long as we can quickly feed them, correct? No. Never mind the enormous logistics of occupying North Korea. Never mind that the same terrible infrastructure will hamper any relief effort. Never mind issues such as finance and reconstruction. The North Korean people have been taught for sixty years that we are the enemy. Starvation, fear, and brutality have been institutionalized. The people have been told that they are the pinnacle of human achievement, that the South and Americans are ogres, and that juche requires their absolute adherence to the Dear Leader. Some of that, much of that, will stick. North Koreans lack initiative and do not respond well to the modern, western world. We will not be welcomed even if we were to occupy the North quickly. Nothing goes right in planning a war, something that Iraq taught us, and while Iraq also taught us that patience and continued re-examination will eventually find a strategy that will work, there is no one in Washington today with those qualities. North Korea will fall apart, the misery will be as absolute as one can imagine, and thanks to the western press and the western Left, America will be held responsible. One might argue that we would not occupy North Korea. The South Koreans would have the same problems as we; the cultural barriers are almost as profound, and they too are defined as the enemy. Nor could we count on any assistance from China. China has its own plan, and allowing North Korea to be occupied is not one of them. Even before one considers a North Korean defeat, we must recognize that China has many ways to aid and abet a North Korean attack without being so direct as to invite retaliation. China believes that the 21st century belongs to them much as the 20th century belonged to the United States and the 19th century belonged to Britain. China patiently seeks hegemony in the Western Pacific. If using North Korea to start a war so as to push us from that region will succeed, that is what the Chinese will do. If starting a war so as to discredit us in the eyes of the rest of the world will succeed, that is what they will do. If using the threat of a war causes American leaders to concede and buckle, that is what they will do. China likes North Korea the way it is. China could easily fix the problems in that unhappy land. Just a few train-loads of fertilizer and food a month would fix the chronic malnutrition. Instead they permit North Korea to buy missile parts and weapons. China could restrain Kim Jong-Il with a telephone call. Instead they permit him to sink South Korean naval ships. North Korea does little without Chinese approval. China approves. China wants us out of the Western Pacific. They want the Japanese tamed. They want oil, markets, strategic depth and the freedom to take on their next adversary, India. North Korea is a tool that can be used and discarded as is convenient. China must defeat America. They can't do that militarily; Chinese leaders have watched our military in Iraq and Afghanistan, and they know that today, their 1990s era military can't defeat ours. They must defeat us politically and more important, psychologically. They are well on their way. The United States thought it was electing a post-racial, post-partisan ‘cool cat' when it elected Barack Obama. It quickly discovered that the elected administration, and its supporters in the press, academia and labor, had decided that, as the Newsweek cover proclaimed, “we are all socialists now'. America must be brought down in their eyes so that it can be rebuilt in a statist, more authoritarian, communalist, ‘progressive' republic that worries about building a ‘New America' and ignores the rest of the world. Call that what you like, that is what they have worked for since the twin goblins of Bolshevism and Fascism rose from the ashes of World War One. A fair portion of this was organized by the Soviets; one need not see a Red under every bed to understand that the Soviets guided a substantial part of the radical, western Left and used it to subvert Europe and America. China is happy to pick up these tools for use alongside their own. North Korea is a tool. The reconquest of Hong Kong is a tool. The threat to invade Taiwan is a tool, as is the occupation of Tibet, the threat to India, the arming of Pakistan, the provision of nuclear plans to Iran, the oil deals with Chavez, and the co-opting of Burma. China has used the North Korea tool well. Through three American administrations, Clinton, Bush and now Obama, it has demonstrated that the United States is inconsistent and irresolute. We try to cut deals, we try to negotiate, we seek to involve regional powers. We apply sanctions that are easily circumvented. We continue to ask China to use its ‘good will' to ‘influence' North Korea. How they must laugh in Beijing. With virtually nothing at risk, China demonstrates that it is dangerous to trust the United States. George Bush was as responsible as any; witness the weak response to the capture of our patrol plane and the removal of North Korea from the terrorist list. Barack Obama continues the fumbling. Now South Korea knows that the United States isn't completely behind it as it decides to respond to the sinking of one of its own warships. Indeed, what would the U.S. do if the attack had been against an American destroyer? Would we demand satisfaction from North Korea? George Bush might have, though our country might not have followed him. Barack Obama? Demand satisfaction? Our allies notice, as do our enemies. It is no coincidence that Iran threatens nuclear war, that Hugo Chavez increases the torment of his own people, that Burma cancels elections, that Pakistan sponsors terror attacks against its neighbors, that Syria provides Hezbollah with long-range missiles, and that Russia plans its own reconquest of old Soviet states. No other country will counter this. Europe is delusional. Britain is weak. Israel is increasingly on its own. India is threatened and not powerful enough to respond outside its own region. Japan is in a long term economic decline. Other regional powers, from Brazil to Turkey, see what is happening and decide to cut their own deals. The sinking of the Cheonan makes clear to the world that the U.S. will not stand behind its ally in responding to an act of war. The South Koreans will not respond on their own. They understand that in the end, they must live with China, and that now China is the strong horse. South Korea over time must move closer to China, and that means moving away from us. Now that the point has been made, the Chinese may well discard Kim Jong-Il and the Kim dynasty. They may install a new warlord and quietly install a Chinese model economy in the North. They can prepare their client for a new job. What does Korea say about the U.S.? We are wanting. |
| Posted by:Steve White |
| #5 WMF > CHINA WILL NEVER APPROVE OF INTERNATIONAL SANCTIONS WHICH LEAD TO THE COLLAPSE OF NORTH KOREA. * SAME > THE SINO-JAPANESE HISTORICAL STRUGGLE AND MIL CONFLICTS OCCURRED DUE TO JAPAN's DESIRE TO ASSERT SOVEREIGN INFLUENCE, STATION MIL FORCES ON CHINA'S VASSAL STATE OF KOREA. SUPPORT OF TOKYO FOR THE ACTIVITIES OF KOREAN PIRATES, CRIME GROUPS AGZ CHINESE INTERESTS. * WAFF > GUARDIAN.UK > [1/2-plus] AUSTRALIANS FEAR WAR WID CHINIA, SAYS LOWRY INSTITUTE SURVEY. Majority of Aussies surveyed continue to suppor US despite recognizing the base decline in US econ + geopol influence. |
| Posted by: JosephMendiola 2010-05-31 21:46 |
| #4 they are wise enough to take advantage of NK's provocations. Not wise, in my opinion, but certainly happy to. I think the game is called Go? |
| Posted by: trailing wife 2010-05-31 15:26 |
| #3 That is a very clearheaded and forcefully written essay. But I think that while the Chinese are not quite as capable of controlling the crazy pitbull on the end of their chain as some believe, they are wise enough to take advantage of NK's provocations. |
| Posted by: Jinens Lumplump6738 2010-05-31 14:19 |
| #2 North Korea does little without Chinese approval. China approves. I doubt this heavily. North Korea does what they want, the days of them being a Chinese client state are over. Agree that NK knew that SK and America would do nothing, though. |
| Posted by: gromky 2010-05-31 05:25 |
| #1 And Obama bowing to China only adds credibility to this idea. |
| Posted by: gorb 2010-05-31 00:53 |