You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Down Under
Indonesia admits torturing West Papuans
2010-10-22
If we take it that the War on Terror is actually a war on expansionist, fascist Islamism, then this belongs in war on terror.

Indonesian muslims from Java invaded West Papua when the Dutch left.

They have banned journalists and regularly murder people, burning churches and villages.

They make money off a huge copper mine there, run by US giant Freeport McMoRan - while the West Papuans whose country it is get nothing.

The West Papuans are Melanesian Christians or animists with traditional beliefs and their own language. They have nothing in common ethnically, religiously or linguistically with the Asian Muslim Javanese who now control their country. They want the Indonesians out, but what can you do with sticks and stones against AK-47s?

then you see appalling stories like this.... from the Sydney Morning Herald

the Indos didn't see anything wrong with torturing a West Papuan to the extent they stuck their snuff film on YouTube. One man in the video hasn't been seen alive since.

Indonesian soldiers in YouTube Papuan torture video

JAKARTA: Indonesia has admitted that its soldiers were behind the torture of a Papuan man depicted in a disturbing video that emerged this week.

The swift admission of culpability in the abuses, which involved the man being repeatedly poked with a fiery stick in his genitalia as he screamed in agony, was the result of a preliminary investigation, the Security Affairs Minister, Djoko Suyanto, said yesterday.

''Based on our preliminary report, we found that soldiers on the ground overreacted in handling those people who had been arrested,'' Mr Suyanto told reporters. ''What they did was unprofessional.''

The video, posted on the YouTube website but obtained independently and exclusively revealed on Monday by the Herald, sparked a storm of criticism abroad and in Indonesia.

It was taken by an Indonesian soldier, his hand steady as the abuses were carried out. Metadata from the video indicated that it was taken on May 30. The victims were speaking in the Papuan dialect of Lani, common in Puncak Jaya regency of Papua.

In the video, the man, since identified as Tunaliwor Kiwo, also has a gun pointed in his face and is told he will be shot, while another terrified Papuan man nearby, believed to be Telangga Gire, has a knife placed at his throat and is told it will be cut. The soldiers are searching for a cache of weapons.

Reports from Papua say Mr Gire is in hiding, while Mr Kiwo has not been seen since the video was taken.

The video was discussed at a gathering of ministers yesterday convened by the President, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono. Mr Suyanto said the soldiers would be punished ''according to military regulations''.

''It has attracted public and world attention. We'll settle it properly,'' he said.

But Phil Robertson, deputy Asia director for Human Rights Watch, said Indonesia's military justice system had a poor record in meting out appropriate sentences to security personnel who have committed abuses.

''All those responsible for what appears to be a horrific crime need to be brought to justice, and the public needs to see that justice is done,'' he said.

''It's hard to tell what's more shocking about the video - the horrific abuses depicted or the perpetrators' apparent confidence that their actions are acceptable.''

The scandal over the torture video comes after several months of disturbing reports trickling in from Puncak Jaya, an inaccessible Highland region of Papua where villages are scattered among soaring mountains of more than 4000 metres.

It is here, in the shadow of the world's only tropical glacier, that the most dogged of the rag-tag units of the Free Papua Movement.

They are poorly trained and equipped farmers in the main, but expert in using the terrain and hiding among a supportive local population, staging sporadic attacks on security posts, stealing weapons and, occasionally, shooting and killing soldiers and police.

In a security crackdown this year thousands of military and police have been dispatched to the area, and activists have been reporting a catalogue of human rights abuses, including the razing of entire villages, the arbitrary burning of churches, brutal interrogations and extrajudicial killings.

Until the video emerged this week, the reports had been unverified due to the difficulty of travelling to the area, which is off-limits to foreign reports and logistically difficult for local media.

This scandal also comes as the US President, Barack Obama, prepares to visit Indonesia next month and just months after the US agreed gradually to lift its longstanding ban on co-operation with Kopassus, the Indonesian special forces unit, which has a record of brutality.

While the country's emergence as a vibrant democracy has led to a vast improvement in its human rights record, the video has rekindled concerns that old habits remain in the security services. It has also refocused attention on the running sore that is Papua, the resource-rich region with a distinctive Melanesian population who remain one of the country's poorest and retain separatist sentiment.

Papua has enjoyed ''special autonomy'' since 2001, with substantially increased funding from the central government at about $1 billion a year. A new body, the Papuan People's Council, or Majelis Rakyat Papua, was established, a quasi-legislature to represent the indigenous population.

But the funding has been squandered by corrupt officials and there has been little improvement in the welfare of indigenous Papuans.

Dr Yudhoyono has spoken of ''constructive communications'' with Papuans and an ''audit'' of special autonomy, and there is talk of the Vice-President, Boediono, leading a new push for peace in the province.

One thing is certain: the current strategy isn't working for anyone.
Posted by:anon1

#3  yes spot on joseph mendiola

indonesia has invaded its neighbours repeatedly. On maps it marks northern australia as south Irian

they would surely invade us if it weren't for the threat of our best ally and friend in the world USA

as it is we give them $1 billion in aid every year... let's call it 'peace money' or 'tribute' rather than aid

and then there is china

wants our raw materials

has infiltrated us with spies

but they don't need to rule us as long as they get what they want via dodgy deals.... which is what they are doing
Posted by: anon1   2010-10-22 20:38  

#2  Melanesia + PNG = ALMOST-AUSTRALIA.

1980's "CROCODILE DUNDEE" = future "AHMED DUNDEE/AL-DUNDE - looks like CHINA + CPLA can't conquer or dominate OZLAND + SOUTH PACIFIC soon enough???

Just sayin.
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2010-10-22 20:30  

#1  Please, please USA, I beg you not to lift the ban on training/working with the Indonesian military unit Kopassus. They are evil men, just evil

electrodes on the genitals type of evil

they killed 1/3 of East Timor's population and terrorised them for nearly three decades

they are doing the same in West Papua - please do NOT look on them as any kind of regional ally. they are not.
Posted by: anon1   2010-10-22 19:17  

00:00