You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
Teen detained in Kuwait sues US over no-fly list
2011-01-19
ALEXANDRIA, Virginia -- Attorneys for a Virginia teenager have filed a federal lawsuit, claiming he was detained and tortured in Kuwait after being arbitrarily placed on the United States' no-fly list.

Lawyers for Gulet Mohamed, 19, argued in their lawsuit filed in US District Court in Alexandria that he was a nice boy placing Mohamed on the no-fly list without due process violates his constitutional rights.

A judge immediately scheduled a hearing on Mohamed's case for Tuesday afternoon.
Let me guess: a Clinton or Carter appointee, and the whole watch list system is about to be declared unconstitutional.
"The United States is depriving Mr. Mohamed of perhaps the most basic prerogative of American citizenship: the right to reside within the United States," wrote Nadhira F. Al-Khalili and Gadeir Abbas with the Council on American-Islamic Relations, which is representing Mohamed and has complained on behalf of other Muslim Americans in similar circumstances.

Mohamed was born in Somalia but is a naturalized US citizen who immigrated at age 3 and most recently lived in the Alexandria area. In March of 2009, Mohamed travelled to Yemen and Somalia, where he still has family, to learn Arabic.
Sure, he couldn't find anywhere in all of northern Virginia to learn Arabic...
What? And miss those two sparkling jewels in the crown of Islamic civilization, Yemen and Somalia?
He stayed in those countries for just a few months and settled in Kuwait in August 2009, where he lived with an uncle.
Just picking up the local culture, and maybe a wife or two...
In December, when he applied for a routine visa extension, he was arrested by plainclothes agents and claims he was beaten and tortured. Interrogators whipped his feet and threatened run electrical current through his genitals, Mohamed says.
Perhaps he was just sniffing around the local wimmin, or perhaps he was a little too forward in his beliefs about jihad...
The interrogators wanted to know about his time in Yemen and asked numerous questions about radical cleric Anwar al-Awlaki, an American who is hiding in Yemen and is believed to be a top al-Qaida recruiter.
Wotta coincidence...
Mohamed denies that he any contact with terrorists.
"No, no, certainly not!"
Mohamed says he was twice questioned by FBI agents, who told him that he would remain in Kuwaiti detention indefinitely if he continued to insist on having his lawyer present for questioning.
The Kuwaitis just don't respect Miranda warnings the way we do...
Mohamed alleges that his detention in Kuwait is entirely at the behest of the US government.
Makes for a nice story kid, but you have any proof of that? No?
In fact, he claims the Kuwaiti government tried to deport Mohamed Monday, but US officials would not let him on the plane because he is on the no-fly list.
He could have gone to Pakistain...
CAIR spokesman Ibrahim Hooper said Tuesday Mohamed "is just sitting in detention because they wouldn't let him get on the plane."

The Department of Justice said in a statement that it would not comment on the specific allegations in the lawsuit, but defended the way it adds people to the no-fly list.

"As a general matter, the process used to add anyone to the consolidated terrorist watchlist involves multiple layers of interagency vetting," the statement said. "At the same time, the federal government has well-established redress procedures in place for those seeking relief from adverse effects that may be related to watchlist screening. Today's watchlisting process serves our overall counterterrorism efforts while preserving the civil liberties of all Americans."
Until a screwy judge overturns it all.
Posted by:Steve White

#7  Truthfully, the no-fly list is very screwed up. All sorts of government agencies can submit to it, but nobody is responsible for it, and it is next to impossible to error check or correct it. Note that it is different from the Selectee List and the Terrorist Watchlist.

It is and has been used to deport US citizens while effectively stripping them of their citizenship, without hearing or recourse. While no doubt some of them richly deserve it, doing sneaky "end-arounds" of a log jammed an inefficient process evades the real problem, which is the process.

And when creating these, they didn't even bother to amend the Privacy Act of 1974, which forbids the government to compile secret databases on U.S. citizens. So technically there are major legal conflicts.

On the plus side, apparently some mad bomber was named Theodore Kennedy, so guess who got on the list half a dozen times? Likewise, retired senior US military officers and at least on US Marine serving in Dubai have been blocked from reentry.

Fortunately, the Pentagon does not give a crap what the TSA thinks.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2011-01-19 10:14  

#6  The Washington Examiner adds:

Lawyers with the Council on American-Islamic Relations filed the complaint Tuesday in federal court in Alexandria. The lawsuit names Attorney General Eric Holder, FBI Director Robert Mueller and Terrorist Screening Center Director Timothy Healy as defendants.

The lawsuit says he went abroad in March 2009 to study Arabic and see family living abroad.

He went to Yemen and Somalia, then Kuwait, where he had been living with an uncle since August 2009. He had renewed his visitor's visa there twice before, the suit says.


If he's 19 now, he was 17 when he left... in March of that year. The timing is queer: in the middle of the second semester of (probably) his junior year of high school. Surely it's more normal to wait until after he graduated from high school in the U.S. to do additional language studies abroad. And, had it been an exchange student thing it would have been bang on the semester at the end of January, then he would have been sent home by the end of the summer to finish up his high school program.

I don't think I want him back, either.
Posted by: trailing wife   2011-01-19 09:57  

#5  I think, maybe, he is on the assassination list. I think everyone is pissed off because he did not go back to Yemen.
Posted by: tipper   2011-01-19 09:24  

#4  If he really wanted to come he'd fly to Canada or Mexico and rent a car.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2011-01-19 07:22  

#3  If we had a CIA worth anything we'd be spreading the rumor that the kid is a Shi'a sympathizer.
Posted by: Steve White   2011-01-19 00:46  

#2  I wonder if he is going to sue Kuwaitis for alleged torture.
Do you wanna bet?
Posted by: vendaval   2011-01-19 00:27  

#1  Do not fly means just that.
He could walk or swim.
Posted by: Water Modem   2011-01-19 00:17  

00:00