You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Government
Keep US ground forces out of Middle East conflicts
2017-04-20
[American Thinker] I am as opposed to Radical Islam and the barbarian actions of these 7th century throwbacks as anyone. However, I am tired of hearing from so called pundits and tea leaf readers that "If we don’t stop them in (pick a country) that we will have to fight them here in this country". Let’s be realistic -- this is not a uniformed army with tanks and howitzers and ships being loaded in some foreign port preparing to invade this country through the harbors of Boston or New York or Savannah or the beaches of Long Island. These are not people with sophisticated logistics systems ready to resupply this imaginary army over thousands of miles of ocean.

What we are faced with are small numbers of homegrown or smuggled terrorists ready and willing to cause havoc and die for their beliefs. These are the people we should be concentrating our defensive efforts against. Although the Liberal Democrat judges of this Country are willing to allow these people into the country with no effort to identify them, that is a problem not related to any overseas adventure requiring American military personnel on the ground. I am all in favor of dropping munitions of one type or another on specific ISIS targets as was recently done with MOAB in Afghanistan but I am vehemently opposed to subjecting soldiers and Marines to ground combat in situations without a clear objective of winning. Korea, Vietnam and other misadventures in the Mideast have shown the folly of "nation building" "limited objective warfare" "regime change" and other political euphemisms for lack of will as a substitute for victory.

The recent call by the commanding general in Afghanistan for thousands of more troops on the ground is frighteningly reminiscent of the call for more troops in Vietnam. The ego of some of these generals results in the deaths of untold American military. "Just give me a few more thousand troops and I will defeat the enemy" has been the cry since the time of Caesar. Unfortunately, many of these generals disregard the politicians' overwhelming fear of defeat at the polls which will cause them to make fatal decisions, snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. Millions, yes millions, were lost by the French and British in World War I because of the same ego-driven stupidity of the generals and politicians.

Now addled politicians Lindsey Graham and John McCain are calling for ground troops to be sent to Syria in addition to Afghanistan. We were advised many years ago to stay out of any ground combat in Southeast Asia -- advice that was ignored with horrendous consequences. Take a look at recent events in Iraq, a manufactured artificial country. Must we relearn the lessons of history with the blood of our military?
Posted by:Besoeker

#7  good book
Posted by: Frank G   2017-04-20 20:22  

#6  Book - The Disciple - Iran sets of a nuke in Iran to start the 'holy war'. Good read.
Posted by: Bobby   2017-04-20 13:15  

#5  It's very simple. We don't go there. They don't come here.
Posted by: Abu Uluque   2017-04-20 12:22  

#4  A bigger concern is a small ground level nuke going off "unexpectedly" in Beijing, Tokyo, Baghdad, Istanbul or like places. Who to blame then?
Posted by: Anguper Hupomosing9418   2017-04-20 10:04  

#3  Kinder gentler war is one that never ends.

But it keeps the engines of industry humming.
Posted by: Skidmark   2017-04-20 10:03  

#2  Too late. If you had nuked the **** out of Saddam back when, would you be in the position you are now? Kinder gentler war is one that never ends.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2017-04-20 09:10  

#1  Munitions of one type or another? Well then two to 300 megatons out to get the job done. I'm not advocating using nukes but in the end I fear it is going to end up there. Eventually some non state actor, be it ISIS, al Queda or one of the groups they will spawn (they breed like cockroaches and have more doctrinal disputes than Menonites) will get their hands on one or more nukes. And use them/it in the belief that either we will not know where to hit back or retaliate and generate even more holy warriors.
Posted by: Cheaderhead   2017-04-20 06:09  

00:00