Submit your comments on this article |
Home Front: Culture Wars |
What Natalie Portman Gets Right And Wrong About Jews |
2015-09-01 |
[The Federalist] Natalie Portman apparently thinks Jews spend too much time talking about the Holocaust and anti-Semitism. In an interview about her new movie with the British Independent, the Oscar-winner made provocative and newsworthy observations. However, they were also problematic for a variety of reasons. Portman's most insightful comment is also her most incendiary: "'I think a really big question the Jewish community needs to ask itself, is how much at the forefront we put Holocaust education. Which is, of course, an important question to remember and to respect, but not over other things...'" Portman is right that for the sake of Jewish continuity, American Jewry should spend less time talking to our children about the Holocaust as some implicit explanation for why it's important to be Jewish. The Holocaust was absolutely evil, and there is always the risk a genocide could be attempted again (this time, more likely by the Iranian regime). However, there is also so much more to being Jewish than the suffering inflicted by hateful outsiders. Young Jews should experience the beauty and vibrancy of our religious, cultural, and intellectual heritage; they should embrace Judaism for positive reasons, rather than out of some sense of historical guilt. Portman is right that the Holocaust needs to be taught as part of a full-spectrum Jewish education. |
Posted by:Besoeker |
#7 The outcome of Nat's line of thought: "Never Again!" "Never what again, grampa?" |
Posted by: M. Murcek 2015-09-01 22:04 |
#6 Personally, I think Jewish problem is that we spend too much time talking and not enough time winding our enemies guts on a stick The best I have heard in a long time. Generations of Jews were systematically gassed and executed into near non existence as a group. Portman is wrong, Never forget, never forgive, never! |
Posted by: 49 Pan 2015-09-01 18:03 |
#5 A lot of people can tag 1492 with the Spanish funded trip of Chris Columbus (just ask American Indians), but don't connect the 1 - final expulsion of the invading Islamists/Moors (Reconquesta) and 2 - expulsion of the Jews (who helped finance the Reconquesta. Boy, now there's one way to wipe out a war debt.) |
Posted by: Procopius2k 2015-09-01 09:29 |
#4 The worst thing is that the Holocaust was not a singular event, just the largest in a string of pogroms, massacres and oppression that has formed an unbroken chain stretching thousands of years, right up to the present day. Attention needs to be paid to the systemic not to the one case. |
Posted by: AlanC 2015-09-01 07:30 |
#3 That's not just a Jewish problem g(r)om. |
Posted by: Ebbart Glererong5900 2015-09-01 05:28 |
#2 Personally, I think Jewish problem is that we spend too much time talking and not enough time winding our enemies guts on a stick---does that makes me a bad person? |
Posted by: g(r)omgoru 2015-09-01 02:31 |
#1 Considering half of Hollywood Jews can look at Iran and go meh, instead of be horrified shows that the Holocaust lessons are not taken so seriously these days. |
Posted by: rjschwarz 2015-09-01 01:52 |