Hi there, !
Today Wed 12/09/2015 Tue 12/08/2015 Mon 12/07/2015 Sun 12/06/2015 Sat 12/05/2015 Fri 12/04/2015 Thu 12/03/2015 Archives
Rantburg
532859 articles and 1859496 comments are archived on Rantburg.

Today: 73 articles and 177 comments as of 4:07.
Post a news link    Post your own article   
Area: WoT Operations    WoT Background    Non-WoT           
AQIM shares responsibility for Mali hotel killings
Today's Headlines
Headline Comments [Views]
Page 4: Opinion
5 21:35 swksvolFF [10] 
5 16:54 JohnQC [] 
Page 1: WoT Operations
19 22:32 Skidmark [3]
4 19:56 JosephMendiola [2]
10 13:53 rjschwarz []
1 16:51 JohnQC [1]
1 12:10 Frank G []
0 [1]
0 [1]
0 [2]
0 [9]
0 [4]
0 [5]
0 [4]
10 18:32 Procopius2k [4]
0 []
0 [2]
0 []
0 [1]
0 [3]
0 [2]
0 [2]
0 [3]
0 [7]
0 [6]
0 [7]
0 []
4 11:46 Frank G [1]
0 []
0 []
0 [2]
11 21:24 Airandee [4]
0 [2]
5 15:28 Zenobia Floger6220 [1]
1 11:49 Frank G []
0 []
0 [1]
0 [3]
3 06:40 Skidmark [2]
3 11:37 Procopius2k []
1 15:19 g(r)omgoru [7]
Page 2: WoT Background
3 18:59 Barbara [5]
2 13:32 Pappy []
1 19:54 JosephMendiola [5]
3 18:25 Procopius2k []
1 15:14 g(r)omgoru [6]
3 14:58 Bill Clinton [1]
1 14:00 Spomong Bourbon8696 [2]
4 15:16 g(r)omgoru [4]
0 [5]
0 [2]
0 [7]
0 [3]
8 11:04 Procopius2k [2]
5 20:08 JosephMendiola [4]
30 18:46 Barbara [5]
4 20:15 JosephMendiola [1]
5 11:33 Procopius2k []
0 [1]
1 04:07 Besoeker [2]
2 15:07 Frank G [3]
3 19:27 Frank G [4]
0 [2]
1 12:36 Bill Clinton [6]
2 03:53 g(r)omgoru []
3 19:28 Frank G [2]
4 08:35 Procopius2k [4]
2 22:46 JosephMendiola [2]
0 [5]
0 [3]
1 12:29 Pappy [2]
Page 3: Non-WoT
4 17:54 Zenobia Floger6220 [2]
1 07:03 Skidmark [2]
-Short Attention Span Theater-
This Week in Books
Empires of the Sea - The Siege Of Malta, the Battle Of Lapanto, and the Contest for the Center of the World

Roger Crowley
Random House, 2009

If reading the title out loud requires circular breathing, it is because there is much covered in this installment. Actually, there is much, much more than even the title suggests. I will do my best to cover as much as possible without writing a book myself, to pique your interest.

To understand the Siege of Malta, Mr. Crowley begins at Rhodes with the Knights of St. John (page 8).

"The early decades of the sixteenth century were a time of hunger in the Eastern Mediterranean, and food supplies for the capital were critical. "The said Rhodians are inflicting great losses on the sultan's subjects," noted the Venetian diarist Sanudo in 1512, the year the knights captured eighteen grain transports bound for Istanbul and forced the prices there up 50 percent."

Suleiman the Magnificent has just risen to Sultan, and the Knights of St. John had reinvented themselves as seamen-crusaders or corsairs or pirates, depending upon who was commenting on them. The Venetians despised them, as they upset commerce and poked the Ottomans.

I have been to Rhodes, and what remains of the fortifications is impressive even today. It is an ancient fortification, pre-dating the common use of gunpowder. Suleiman's father attempted to storm the fort and lost badly. However, the fortifications had been updated (page 12):

"Italian military engineers developed their discipline as a science. They mapped geometric angles of fire with compasses and used knowledge of ballistics to design radical solutions. At Rhodes, the engineers developed prototypes of this new military engineering: massive walls, angled bastions of immense thickness that commanded wide fields of fire, slanted parapets to deflect shot, mountings for long-range guns, splayed gun ports, inner defensive layers with concealed batteries, double ditches excavated to the depth of canyons, counterscarps that exposed an advancing enemy to a torrent of fire."

Mr. Crowley goes into excellent detail on the order of battle and how it plays out, including Suleiman's greatest weapon - the pick with manpower. The battle grinds, and grinds until both sides seek a diplomatic solution. This results in a truce between Grand Master L'Isle Adam and Suleiman with conditions so favorable to the knights they, and anyone who wants to, were allowed to leave with all of their possessions minus cannon, and Suleiman's ships would transport them off the island. Leaving the island is a young knight of the name Jean Parisot de La Valette.

In 1565, at the age of 70, Grand Master La Valette would be in charge of the defense of Malta (page 98):

"He had given everything to warfare in the name of Christ - he had been badly wounded in a fight with Barbary corsairs, been captured and spent a year as a galley slave, served as captain general of galleys, and as governor of Tripoli."

Coming of age also was the new King of Spain (page 23):

Charles was seventeen years old. Through the complexities of dynastic succession, he was the inheritor of the largest domain in Europe since the time of Charlemagne. His realms were the mirror image of the Ottoman Empire, and he claimed a litany of titles to equal Suleiman's. It took two long-winded pages to record them..."

Of the Barbarossas (page 27):

"The two brothers Oruch and Hizir, whom the Christians called the Barbarossas - the Redbeards - were adventurers from the Eastern Mediterranean. They had been born on the island of Lesbos on the fragmenting maritime frontier between Islam and Christendom before the seige of Rhodes, and they spanned both worlds. Their father was an Ottoman cavalryman, their mother a Greek Christian. Their commitment to piracy in the name of Islam had been shaped by the Knights of Saint John. Oruch was captured by the knights in an encounter that left another brother dead. He toiled for two years as a shackled slave on the new fortifications at Rhodes and as an oarsman in their galleys, until he filed off his chains and swam away."

Spanning from 1521 to the aftermath of Lepanto in 1571, Mr. Crowley gives excellent detail of the major players and events which took place in and affecting the Mediterranean from a mainly Catholic League approach, which nicely rounds out with his Venetian view of the world in City of Fortune and the Orthodox/Islam view in his book 1453. Indeed, we see how the Venetian approach to Cyprus comes back to haunt them in 1570 in the battle for Nicosia and Famagusta. Andrea Doria and Don Juan of Austria and Bragadin, Mustafa Pasha and Lala Mustapha and Ali Pasha. And the everyman who suffered most from this conflict (page 76-77):

"Crucially, the dynamo of maritime war was human labor; in all the motivations for slaving in the sixteenth century, snatching men for the rowing benches assumed an important role. In the heyday of Venetian sea power in the fifteenth century, galleys had been rowed by volunteers; by the sixteenth, the muscle power was generally conscripted. The Ottoman navy relied heavily on an annual levy of men from the provinces of Anatolia and Europe, and everyone employed chained labor - captured slaves, convicts, and, in the Christian ships, paupers so destitute they sold themselves to the galley captains."

There are excellent maps and drawings so that even a person unfamiliar with the subject would not be lost. The vividly written battles, especially Malta, left me leaning on the chair. There is a nice museum where the people of Malta made their last desperate stand which shows the armor used and the dings left from being struck by bullets (page 174):

"On August 28 an Italian soldier, Lorenzo Puche, was talking to the grand master when he was hit in the head by an arquebus shot. His plate helmet took the full force of the blast. The man fell to the ground stunned, picked up his dented headgear, and asked permission to carry on with a sortie - under the circumstances it was refused."

At Fort St. Elmo, lost earlier in the fight, I walked to Rabbit Medina, an ancient fort located more towards the center of the island, where a band of cavalry quite possibly saved the Mediterranean with a well timed raid led by Vincenzo Anastagi (page 165):

"The leader of this tiny force was an Italian knight called Vinceno Anastagi, a man of intelligence and enterprise, destined to a small immortality after the siege in a portrait by El Greco - and a violent end, murdered twenty years later by two of his fellow knights."

And the harrowing lead up to and the Battle of Lepanto, we have an account among others who participated (page 263):

"On the 'Marquesa', the Spaniard Miguel de Cervantes, twenty-four years old, bookish and desperately poor, was a volunteer; on the morning of the battle he was ill from fever but tottered from his bed to command a detachment of soldiers at the boat station."

If you don't have time to read, or will be on the road, the audio version on CD, narrated by John Lee, is brilliantly read and does well to bring the listener into the story.

Link is to Amazon's sale page.
Posted by: swksvolFF || 12/06/2015 00:00 || Comments || Link || [10 views] Top|| File under:

#1  *It should be noted that the CD audio is abridged to some extent, if I remember the audio correctly.

And, if you will (pages 71-72)

In the four decades following the launch of Barbarossa's first imperial fleet in 1534, thousands of people were snatched from the coasts of Italy and Spain: eighteen hundred from Minorca in 1535, seven thousand from the Bay of Naples in 1544, five thousand from the island of Gozo off Malta in 1551, six thousand from Calabria in 1554, and four thousand from Granada in 1566. The Ottomans could apply sudden and overwhelming force at precise points; they could land at and destroy fair sized coastal towns with impunity and threaten even the major cities of Italy.


Posted by: swksvolFF || 12/06/2015 13:11 Comments || Top||

#2  Sounds like what they are doing in California.
Posted by: badanov || 12/06/2015 14:45 Comments || Top||

#3  I am currently reading Mr. Crowley's book "1453". It chronicles the fall of Constantinople. Nothing has changed. Political infighting by the allies. Corruption. Putting self-interest above unity to fight Mehmet. Taqqiya, Hudna and European denial. Superb writing. Next on my list is Empires of the Sea.
Posted by: Sgt. D.T. || 12/06/2015 15:26 Comments || Top||

#4  ...not to mention the unsuspecting native 'Americans' who would bear an unexpected consequence of the fall of Constantinople. Great demographic tradition of the Eurasian continent, someone pushes west from the east causing a cascading effect. Unfortunately for the soon to be New Worlders, by 1453, the population in Europe had achieved a technological level to keep on cascading westward.
Posted by: Procopius2k || 12/06/2015 15:43 Comments || Top||

#5  Roger Crowley has a new book out:
Conquerors: How Portugal Forged the First Global Empire

I am expecting that topic to be covered. Unfortunately, the release date was delayed and I am not sure if I am going to read it in time for next week.

I think a good argument could be made that if the Barbary State, an official vassal of The Ottoman Empire, did not so heavily enslave Spain and Italy, and if Spain had not had to take on so much debt fighting Barbary/Ottoman navies, the need for African slaves and the need to plunder the New World would have been much diminished.

An interesting scotch ponder would be: What if Constantine had won?

Would the Papal/Orthodox alliance have held? I'm not so sure it would have.

How many of Mehmet's chips were placed on this battle? Would a loss at so young an age create question to his legitimacy as leader?

If the Papal/Orthodox alliance failed, would Constantinople have had the resources to rebuild with defense vs. cannon?

Considering the vast resources saved from fighting The Ottomans, would there have been a Protestant/Lutheran movement, and would it have been defeated?
Posted by: swksvolFF || 12/06/2015 21:35 Comments || Top||


Home Front: WoT
Oh no… we wouldn’t want to engender any hate or vitriol toward Muslims, would we?
Jazz Shaw at Hot Air writes the kind of rant that a number of us here at the Burg have been considering. A most excellent piece and spot on. Read it all.
Posted by: Steve White || 12/06/2015 00:00 || Comments || Link || [0 views] Top|| File under:

#1  Excellent rant, but the authors focus is on political and media aspects, which actually achieve the regimes goal of successful diversion from the facts or core issues.

The real focus should be on specific timelines, and what was known or unknown (intelligence gaps) within the intelligence community and law enforcement, not politics.

By the regime's failure to correctly label the event as terrorism and tossing in claims of Islamophobia and hints racial bias, diversion is created and time is purchased in which new headlines can erase interest in the facts and situation at hand. A campaign of media diversion can be a successful cover for both action, as well as inaction.
Posted by: Besoeker || 12/06/2015 4:50 Comments || Top||

#2  "Local Muslims Fear Backlash After Next Tuesday's Bombings"
Posted by: Iblis || 12/06/2015 13:49 Comments || Top||

#3  Iblis, comments like that make me wish Rantburg had an upvote button.
Posted by: rjschwarz || 12/06/2015 14:06 Comments || Top||

#4  RJ, me too. I spend a fair amount of time on Facebook, and click "Like" for especially funny, righteous or snarky posts and comments. I really wish we could do it here too.
Posted by: Rambler in Virginia || 12/06/2015 15:09 Comments || Top||

#5  We wouldn't want to do that would we? Our AG Loretta Lynch said we shouldn't. Besides, they do it to themselves.
Posted by: JohnQC || 12/06/2015 16:54 Comments || Top||



Who's in the News
45[untagged]
9Islamic State
4Govt of Pakistan
4Govt of Syria
3Taliban
2Boko Haram
1TTP
1al-Nusra
1al-Qaeda in North Africa
1Houthis
1Jamaat-e-Islami
1Palestinian Authority

Bookmark
E-Mail Me

The Classics
The O Club
Rantburg Store
The Bloids
The Never-ending Story
Thugburg
Gulf War I
The Way We Were
Bio

Merry-Go-Blog











On Sale now!


A multi-volume chronology and reference guide set detailing three years of the Mexican Drug War between 2010 and 2012.

Rantburg.com and borderlandbeat.com correspondent and author Chris Covert presents his first non-fiction work detailing the drug and gang related violence in Mexico.

Chris gives us Mexican press dispatches of drug and gang war violence over three years, presented in a multi volume set intended to chronicle the death, violence and mayhem which has dominated Mexico for six years.
Click here for more information

Meet the Mods
In no particular order...
Steve White
Seafarious
tu3031
badanov
sherry
ryuge
GolfBravoUSMC
Bright Pebbles
trailing wife
Gloria
Fred
Besoeker
Glenmore
Frank G
3dc
Skidmark

Two weeks of WOT
Sun 2015-12-06
  AQIM shares responsibility for Mali hotel killings
Sat 2015-12-05
  Still No Confirmation On Reports Of Mullah Mansour's Death
Fri 2015-12-04
  They're here
Thu 2015-12-03
  Syed Farook is religious, sez Dad
Wed 2015-12-02
  Dozens of Houthis killed in major offensive across border from Yemen
Tue 2015-12-01
  Russia Arms Su-34s with Air-to-Air Missiles in Syria for First Time
Mon 2015-11-30
  Suspected Jihadists Attack Cash Truck in Burkina Faso
Sun 2015-11-29
  Pakistan Airstrikes Kill 17 Militants
Sat 2015-11-28
  ISIS top dawg dies in Tal Afar
Fri 2015-11-27
  Top Pakistani extremist killed in 'shoot-out' with police
Thu 2015-11-26
  Drone strike kills Taliban shadow district governor in Nangarhar
Wed 2015-11-25
  One Russian pilot killed, other returned to Russia airbase in Syria
Tue 2015-11-24
  Tensions rise after Turkey shoots down Russian jet, says it will take the issue to the UN, NATO
Mon 2015-11-23
  Chinese police use a flamethrower on 'Muslim terror suspects'
Sun 2015-11-22
  Abu Sayyaf leader killed in Tawi-Tawi clash


Rantburg was assembled from recycled algorithms in the United States of America. No trees were destroyed in the production of this weblog. We did hurt some, though. Sorry.
18.191.195.110
Help keep the Burg running! Paypal:
WoT Operations (39)    WoT Background (30)    Non-WoT (2)    (0)    (0)