Archived material Access restricted Article
Rantburg

Today's Front Page   View All of Tue 04/04/2017 View Mon 04/03/2017 View Sun 04/02/2017 View Sat 04/01/2017 View Fri 03/31/2017 View Thu 03/30/2017 View Wed 03/29/2017
1
2017-04-04 Home Front: Culture Wars
High schoolers' assignment: Present argument in favor of the Holocaust
Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.
Posted by Besoeker 2017-04-04 07:37|| || Front Page|| [1 views ]  Top

#1 File under stupid assignments. There is no argument that justifies the Holocaust.
Posted by JohnQC 2017-04-04 09:56||   2017-04-04 09:56|| Front Page Top

#2 For debate team at High School (many, many eons ago), we debated Civil War economic issues, including slavery. Wasn't fun for the 'pro' side, but gave us lessons in reasoning and critical thinking. Our African-American senior class treasurer argued on the pro-slavery side (her choice). She did quite well, was very persuasive and was not offended. This was, as she said, 'an exercise'.

But we were 100 years after. This assignment, not so much.
Posted by Mullah Richard 2017-04-04 10:38||   2017-04-04 10:38|| Front Page Top

#3 Taking an arbitrary side in a debate is a good exercise, but if you want to do something *really* edgy, have the kids argue for Trump over Hillary for Prez.
Posted by SteveS 2017-04-04 11:49||   2017-04-04 11:49|| Front Page Top

#4 SteveS, we want the kids to understand how to conduct a civil debate, not kill each others off.
Posted by Seeking cure for ignorance 2017-04-04 12:21||   2017-04-04 12:21|| Front Page Top

#5 My own favorite composition subject is "Why Israel needs more WMD?"
Posted by g(r)omgoru 2017-04-04 12:37||   2017-04-04 12:37|| Front Page Top

#6 "Why Israel needs more WMD?"

Very few reasons they would need them.

Iran, Iraq, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Turkey.
Not many reasons at all.... :p
Posted by DarthVader 2017-04-04 12:48||   2017-04-04 12:48|| Front Page Top

#7 I would only be impressed if the assignment was to present arguments in favor of burning the instructor alive.
Posted by Anguper Hupomosing9418 2017-04-04 13:17||   2017-04-04 13:17|| Front Page Top

#8 Depends upon how the teacher grades. Are they an anti-semite looking for automatons to write what they think the teacher wants, or is the teacher looking for conviction and rebellions.

I think John QC's line is almost perfect.

There is no sane argument that justifies the Holocaust.

Then go into the practicalities of diverting resources (trains, building, housing, etc) in the middle of a war to the death when displacing living populations would have put a burden on your enemy who would feel obligated to feed and care for them. Or embracing the Jews and Gypsies and getting them to help in the war effort (6 million more hands in the factories/front lines) by promising them a homeland or something, while vilifying the Russians instead. Might have had an atomic bomb before anyone else if they hadn't scared of or killed some of their brightest minds.

Then end with the same line. There is no sane argument that justifies the Holocaust, it was possibly the stupidest policy decision of an administration filled with stupid policy decisions.

Then see how the teacher grades the paper.
Posted by rjschwarz 2017-04-04 17:37||   2017-04-04 17:37|| Front Page Top

#9 The assignment has been cancelled, according to The Times of Israel:

A homework assignment that asked students in an upstate New York school district to argue for or against the Final Solution, from the perspective of a Nazi official, was withdrawn and will not be assigned again.

"This is an exercise on expanding your point of view by going outside your comfort zone and training your brain to find the evidence necessary to prove a point, even if it is existentially and philosophically against what you believe,” the instructions for the assignment said.

Two students who complained about the exercise were given an alternative task.

But the students, Archer Shurtliff and Jordan April, took their complaint further and called for the teacher to apologize and for the school district to permanently ban the assignment, the Syracuse.com website reported. Neither of the students, both 17, is Jewish.

On Monday, New York State Education Department Commissioner MaryEllen Elia said the assignment has been permanently scratched.

“Since first learning of the assignment, I’ve done my homework to determine the facts in this situation,” Elia said in a statement. “I spoke with district officials about this serious matter. We agree the assignment should not have been given. The teacher apologized and the assignment will not be used in the future.”
Posted by trailing wife 2017-04-04 21:58||   2017-04-04 21:58|| Front Page Top

21:59 3dc
21:58 trailing wife
20:57 Blossom Unains5562
20:53 Blossom Unains5562
20:33 Mullah Richard
20:09 Pappy
20:07 Pappy
19:49 Rob Crawford
19:01 Rex Mundi
18:10 newc
18:08 Winky Dribble5968
18:06 Winky Dribble5968
17:57 Frank G
17:51 Glenmore
17:37 rjschwarz
17:29 rjschwarz
17:26 rjschwarz
17:25 lord garth
17:25 rjschwarz
17:16 Crusader
15:55 Glenmore
15:53 Glenmore
15:14 AlanC
15:03 AlanC









Paypal:
Google
Search WWW Search rantburg.com