Article

2004-04-30 Iraq-Jordan

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by someone 2004-04-30 3:16:15 AM|| || Front Page|| [6 views since 2007-05-07] Top

#1 Well, I figure it's like a few years ago when Powell went to visit Arafart in his garage. At the time, I was mighty pi$$ed. It was right after a terrible suicide attack and it seemed then that we were rewarding terror, caving, showimg how weak we were, and so on. Look, the Marines and their 10+ to 1 kill ratio aren't going far and there's still going to be plenty of recon going on (Predator, etc...). This is going to be a test.

Posted by John G 2004-04-30 9:21:17 AM|| 2004-04-30 9:21:17 AM|| Front Page Top

#2 I think someone's comment regards which part of Fallujah might (empasis: might) be planned for turnover to Iraqis is important. Read Wretchard's posts of today & (particularly) yesterday and picture the SE Industrial area of Fallujah, and it might make sense. Regards the Golan section, only joint actions might make sense.

If there is any truth to this endless LLL press speculation (read: Wishful Thinking) of a general disengagement, then I smell the State Dept - and a potentially disastrous change in policy.

We are doing it right. Puhfuckingleeze ignore the dipshits and fools who do not and never will understand either war nor Arabs.

Posted by .com 2004-04-30 9:31:58 AM|| 2004-04-30 9:31:58 AM|| Front Page Top

#3 IMHO... You're just going to end up back in there fighting the Fundies backed up by an extra thousand Iraqi troops. As soon as the Iraqis get in there the fundies will put them under the Islamo-hypno ray and bingo they'll be shooting at the Marines again... Election year or not, if this situation occurs- paint an arclight box over the Golan neighbourhood and show them some real hellfire. The fuss will die down in a year or two.

It may have been said before but it's awfully funny how the number of large bombings has fallen since Fallujah has been surrounded.

Posted by Howard UK 2004-04-30 9:59:02 AM|| 2004-04-30 9:59:02 AM|| Front Page Top

#4 It may have been said before but it's awfully funny how the number of large bombings has fallen since Fallujah has been surrounded.

which is why its hard to believe that some kind of cordon wont be maintained. But looking at the Israeli experience in the territories, there are cordons and there are cordons. Withdrawing from the center city while maintaining checkpoints around the city is virtually SOP for the IDF. Its VERY hard to believe that something like that wont be in effect here, despite the reports.

Posted by Liberalhawk 2004-04-30 10:05:52 AM|| 2004-04-30 10:05:52 AM|| Front Page Top

#5 This is a big mistake. First they Al-J will spin this as a 'win' for the fundies (and I am not sure it isn't) and we are just arming 1,100 more of the enemy...

Will they even need to give up the people responsible for the 4 contractors? Hello??? Remember them???

Posted by CrazyFool 2004-04-30 10:19:43 AM|| 2004-04-30 10:19:43 AM|| Front Page Top

#6 Stratfor says this is an attempt to put pressure on Sistani "see, we CAN work with the Sunnis, if you leave us no choice" Wheels within wheels. Wait and see.

Posted by Liberalhawk 2004-04-30 10:53:21 AM|| 2004-04-30 10:53:21 AM|| Front Page Top

#7 Reuters - U.S. Marines will maintain some positions in and around Falluja as an Iraqi battalion takes over the restive town, a Marines statement said Friday.

"Until the battalion's units demonstrate a capability to man designated checkpoints and positions, Marines will continue to maintain a presence in and around Falluja," the statement said.

"The coalition objectives remain unchanged -- to eliminate armed groups, collect and positively control all heavy weapons and turn over foreign fighters and disarm anti-Iraqi insurgents in Falluja."

A former general in Saddam Hussein's Republican Guard said Friday he was forming a new force with U.S. agreement to restore stability to the town, but fresh clashes showed that a month of fighting with Sunni Muslim insurgents was not over.

The statement from the Marines said the new Iraqi force would help track down those who killed four American contractors on March 31 and the people who mutilated their bodies, the incident which led to the Marine siege.

The Iraqi force would also help find those who overran Falluja's police station, killed more than 20 policemen and freed prisoners in February, it said.

Once found, those responsible would be tried in Iraqi courts, it said.

Posted by Liberalhawk 2004-04-30 11:26:22 AM|| 2004-04-30 11:26:22 AM|| Front Page Top

#8 Once found, those responsible would be tried in Iraqi courts, it said.

Kinda hard to try a guy with a hole in his stomach and missing half his head.

Posted by Charles 2004-04-30 12:15:13 PM|| 2004-04-30 12:15:13 PM|| Front Page Top

#9 The only way we know that the Fundi's aren't going to attack us again is to kill them now. They are not going to be "turned". We have to complete this job now. If Iraqi's under our supervision can take some of the duties in the quiet sectors of the city, fine. If the cordon starts to weaken or we see one ounce of complicity between those forces and the Fundi's, then we bring in the B-1's and B-52's. Flatten the Fallujah and start over in about 20 years.

Posted by remote man 2004-04-30 1:07:47 PM|| 2004-04-30 1:07:47 PM|| Front Page Top

#10 If we flatten Fallujah from the air, the whole country will rise (except for the Kurds). We'd need about 600,000 troops on the ground to control that. Which we dont got available. Unless youre planning to level Baghdad as well?

Look, it may not make sense to you and me that folks from Baghdad to Basra who dont care to actively support the insurgents, would do so if we pounded Fallujah to bits, but thats the way folks are. When the Soviets went into Afghanistan, the original opposition was fairly limited. Then, in an attempt to crush the opposition, they killed a huge bunch of people in Herat. After that the thing flared out of control, and they never got it back under control.

Posted by Liberalhawk 2004-04-30 4:01:00 PM|| 2004-04-30 4:01:00 PM|| Front Page Top

17:01 Mark Espinola
14:26 Seafarious
14:08 Anonymous6089
12:57 Frank G
12:30 .com
12:14 Anonymous5203
00:06 cingold
23:41 Anonymous4731
11:52 Robert Crawford
11:45 Infidel Bob
11:43 Infidel Bob
07:06 B
06:59 Dave D.
06:49 Anonymous4617
06:29 Bulldog
05:21 Anonymous4617
05:15 Bulldog
03:26 Mark Espinola
02:45 ex-lib
01:21 ex-lib
01:19 Tresho
00:33 Super Hose
00:33 Paul Moloney
00:32 Super Hose