You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Fifth Column
Women’s rights in Mideast? How about here in U.S.?
2003-12-09
by Dina Rabadi -- Special to The Bee
Shirin Ebadi will receive the Nobel Peace Prize in Stockholm on Wednesday for her work fighting for democracy and the rights of women and children in Iran. The honor will reinforce the emerging importance of human rights — and in particular women’s rights — globally. America could use her.
Ah yes America, that tyrannical country that clamps women/blacks/gays in irons.
Even with the political history and atmosphere of Iran, Ebadi and other women there have made impressive improvements in their society — in some cases surpassing the state of women in the United States. Iran, for example, has 14 women in its 270 seat-parliament. That’s better representation than women in the U.S. Senate.
The are 2nd class citizens in a no power parliament. hmmm
As the Bush administration continues to threaten the reproductive rights of women, as women vote for a governor with a history of alleged sexual harassment, as 80 percent of fourth-grade girls continue to diet (www.nowfoundation.org), as women continue to make up the majority of those in poverty, we need to look at the condition of women in our own country before looking down on the status of women in the Middle East.
“Reproductive rights” = Abortion. I am not sure which Bush policy that “threatens” their right to kill fetuses?
Too bad many American women don’t seem to care.
Maybe they don't see the "problem" the same way the writer does?
Women such as Rosette McClave, 34, who was profiled in Boston Globe columnist Derrick Z. Jackson’s piece entitled, "A few uplifting messages from Arnold’s sponsors." McClave said the stories about Schwarzenegger’s sexual misconduct on movie sets "had no effect on me. What I care about was that Arnold was not part of the old guard."
First get Bush on Abortion and Arnold on groping. A two-fer!
According to a 1998 Time/CNN poll, more than 50 percent of American women between the ages of 18 and 34 say they are simpatico with feminist values, but do not necessarily call themselves feminists. These are young women such as Laura, a recent graduate of the Rhode Island School of Design and an aspiring film director, who said: "I’m not a feminist. If you’re talented enough and work hard enough, it won’t matter if you’re a woman or not. I don’t want to sit around and whine about being a woman. I just want to focus on doing my work."
Sounds like Laura isn’t oppressed or discouraged because she is a female
Whats wrong with her?
"How many female directors can you name?" I asked her. She paused, said nothing. Not surprising: Women are 7 percent of all directors working on the top 250 films of 2002, according to professor Martha M. Lauzen, School of Communication, San Diego State University. Even if Laura were given the opportunity to direct a film, chances are she would still have to deal with the wage gap — as do most American women. The Institute of Women’s Policy Research’s 2002 report, "The Status of Women in the States", indicates that women earn 73 cents for every $1 earned by men. The numbers are lowest in Wyoming, where women earn only 64.4 percent of men’s wages.
I earn 30% less than my counterparts in private business
Boo friggin hoo. With success comes the $$$ (men and women).
Perhaps American women have become too selfish, or scared. Many choosing to evaluate the need for feminism — defined as the theory that women should have political, economic and social rights equal to men — base their responses on their own experiences. If they don’t experience sexism, then no one else does. Others are scared that if they speak up and say, "I should be paid more," they will lose their jobs. Scared that if they tell their boyfriend, "Don’t treat me that way," he will leave them. Scared that if they say, "I am a feminist because systems in this country do not yet guarantee equality," they will be stereotyped as butch, anti-family and male-hating.
Women such as Shirin have faced worse obstacles: banned from work, imprisoned, humiliated. In other Middle Eastern countries, fighting for human rights — women’s rights — has meant torture, rape, even death. Now does losing a boyfriend seem so bad?
Now I am confused which is worse: U.S. or Middle East?
Comparing the U.S. records on Human Rights (and women’s rights) and the record of ANY Muslim country is laughable. They aren’t even in the same universe. Yes women are allowed to serve in the Iranian Parliament and there is NO law forbidding any Women for running for any office in the U.S. Also Member of Congress (male or Female) actually have the authority to write and change laws. Unlike their Iranian counterparts. I have two Daughters and I can’t think of a better country that I want my Girls to grow up in. No imprisonment, humiliation, or torture at the hands of the Government. Show of hands, how many female Ranters are itching to move to Iran, Syria, Saudi Arabia, or any other Muslim country?

Just another bikini=burka=lap dancing polemic.

Yawn!

Call me when you're really oppressed.
Posted by:Cyber Sarge (VRWC CA Chapter)

#13   Wage myth.Independent studies have repeatedly shown that women are paid pretty equally with men if time worked is factored in.The wage gap exists because women will take substantial time off when having children.This results in a career being several years behind a male of same age.IF anyone starts whining about huge wage gap,ask what job anywhere in US has differ starting pay for males and females.
Posted by: Stephen   2003-12-9 10:06:13 PM  

#12  ab: Thanks for the addition. Okay, so maybe we're not dumb or lazy, but I will have to accept sloppy :)

ruprecht: My thoughts exactly, maybe the Inane Jordanian was only counting Dems...

I wonder how many readers of the Bee read that screed, nodding their heads sagely...

Pathetic.
Posted by: Carl in NH   2003-12-9 9:46:35 PM  

#11  Even if you fail to count the women in the US Senate that have R's next to their names (just as conservative African Americans are not truly African Americans in the eyes of the left) you come up with 8/100 or 8%.
Posted by: ruprecht   2003-12-9 7:26:38 PM  

#10  Iran, for example, has 14 women in its 270 seat-parliament. That’s better representation than women in the U.S. Senate.

Don't forget Blanche Lincoln (D-AR) - 14 women Senators
Posted by: ab   2003-12-9 6:59:44 PM  

#9  That’s better representation than women in the U.S. Senate." ??

Math is so hard.
Posted by: Barbie   2003-12-9 6:40:08 PM  

#8  Dar, are you talking about the picture? Unfortunately, in all fairness, I think the exact instance was she murdered her husband. Whether that was a justifiable homicide in my eyes, or in yours, I cannot say. Nevertheless, Taliban knew how they saw it.
Posted by: Glenn (not Reynolds)   2003-12-9 6:04:24 PM  

#7  "Iran, for example, has 14 women in its 270 seat-parliament. That’s better representation than women in the U.S. Senate."

???

Female rep in Iran: 14 / 270 ~ 5 %

Female Senators in the US: 13 / 100 ~ 13%

Barbara Boxer (D - CA)
Maria Cantwell (D - WA)
Hillary Clinton (D - NY)
Susan Collins - (R - ME)
Elizabeth Dole (R - NC)
Diane Feinstein (D - CA)
Kay Hutchinson (R - TX)
Mary Landrieu (D - LA)
Barbara Mikulski (D - MD)
Lisa Murkowski (R - AK)
Patty Murray (D - WA)
Olympia Snowe (R - ME)
Debbie Stabenow (D - MI)

http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm

Where do these f*ing journalists get their cheek ? Do they really think we are so dumb and lazy ?
Posted by: Carl in N.H.   2003-12-9 6:02:54 PM  

#6  Dar, I suspect that like her Paleo cousin she was probably raped by her brothers, became pregnant, and then refused to commit suicide. These people boil my blood!
Posted by: Cyber Sarge (VRWC CA Chapter)   2003-12-9 4:14:00 PM  

#5  Damn, Fred, that's disturbing!

What heinous crime did this poor woman commit? Driving a car? Talking back to her husband? Showing an ankle? Being raped?
Posted by: Dar   2003-12-9 3:58:44 PM  

#4  Dina Rabadi is a Jordanian immigrant to America who sounds like she would be happier in Iran. It's a pity she won't actually move there, given the lofty status of the fairer sex in Iran.
Posted by: Zhang Fei   2003-12-9 2:58:55 PM  

#3  Leaving out President Clinton and his sexual harrasment and possible rape of numerous women makes this look like a bit like a shrill partisan attack.
Posted by: ruprecht   2003-12-9 2:38:23 PM  

#2  Nora Ephron came to mind immediately. Barbra Streisand. Those chick flicks aren't directing themselves.
Posted by: BH   2003-12-9 2:12:07 PM  

#1  as 80 percent of fourth-grade girls continue to diet

Waitaminnit. Last I heard, people were bitching because American school kids are too fat. Now they're supposed to stop dieting?
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2003-12-9 2:09:39 PM  

00:00