You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Politix
Lileks on Iraq as Vietnam
2004-04-09
What, you haven't read it yet today?

I am struck once again by the incomparable hold VIETNAM has over some people. They don’t seem to realize how the use of this inapt example demonstrates their inability to grasp the nature of new and different conflicts. When I was in college, El Salvador was Vietnam. When I was in Washington, Kuwait was Vietnam. Afghanistan was briefly Vietnam when we hadn’t won the war after a week. It’s Warholian: in the future, all conflicts will be Vietnam for 15 minutes.

Vietnam was an anomaly. Vietnam was perhaps the least typical war we’ve ever fought, but somehow it’s become the Gold Standard for wars – because, one suspects, it became inextricably bound up with Nixon, that black hole of human perfidy, and it coincided with the golden glory years of so many old boomers who now clog the arteries of the media and academe. A gross overgeneralization, I know. But it’s a fatal conceit. If you’re always fighting the last war you’ll lose the next one. Even worse: Vietnam was several wars ago.

So now we’re fighting Iranian-backed forces in their backyard. This is not a new war. It began the day the “students” swarmed the US Embassy in Tehran. And Senator Kerry worries that a military response to these thugs will inflame the Muslim world against us? If so, that speaks volumes about the Muslim world he seems to know so much about – by his logic they prefer death and defeat to comity and cooperation.

If that’s truly the case, then it’s best we face it now.
Posted by:Steve

#3  Anon - beautifully written and definitely on point!
Posted by: Nancy   2004-04-09 9:29:16 PM  

#2  hey! I just used a similar quote myself!! Maybe that's because those of us who didn't establish our entire identity on opposing the Vietnam war think of the Vietnam war in terms of those piles of skulls in the killing fields, rather than flowers in our hair at a local love in.

These people remind me of, I don't know...residents of someplace like Vicksburg circa 1900. If we all sat around a room, and were able to replay a video of the ol' life on a plantation those circa 1900 people might still see the beauty of the architecture, dresses, wine and food and wish it could be that way again. But you know - I suspect that most born after that time would instead notice the slaves, the humans who didn't look quite human - the broken men and women, living like beasts, whose faces would cause us pain just to look upon.

And so it is with Vietnam. They see only the mint julip, and hear the beauty of the negro spiritual's as they sing in the fields. The rest of us see the suffering that made it all possible and feel ashamed....and steel ourselves to assure that it will never be allowed to happen again.
Posted by: anon   2004-04-09 4:33:21 PM  

#1  "it coincided with the golden glory years of so many old boomers who now clog the arteries of the media and academe"

-absolutely perfect quote. Good article, thanx Steve.
Posted by: Jarhead   2004-04-09 12:19:15 PM  

00:00