| Submit your comments on this article |
| Iraq-Jordan |
| Watchdog: Probe Needed Into U.S. Action in Falluja |
| 2004-04-13 |
| Right on time. Appears our "watchdog" is blind in one eye. A U.S. military offensive in Falluja last week in which 600 Iraqis may have died has raised concerns about excessive use of force and needs immediate investigation, a leading human rights group said Tuesday. Civilians who fled the fighting described the streets of Falluja as being littered with bodies, including women and children, and Iraqi politicians have accused U.S. forces of meting out collective punishment on the city’s residents. No mention of the puppies or little bunny rabbits... "The questions being asked are very legitimate. When you cordon off a town and hear many stories that are very worrisome about civilians being killed it needs to be examined," said Hania Mufti, a senior researcher for Human Rights Watch, a New York-based rights group. How about mutilated, charcoled, corpses hanging from bridges? What? Where? "There is enough from the footage we’ve seen and from what has been said about what went on in Falluja to warrant a very serious investigation. We are deeply concerned about the consistent reports we are getting about women, children and unarmed civilians being killed," Mufti told Reuters. Hope this isn’t as horrific as the infamous Jenin Massacre... She stressed that most of the information received so far was anecdotal and said no conclusions could be drawn until a full investigation could be conducted. You know... bullshit. "I can’t say whether any crimes have been committed ... but we’ll certainly be looking into whether there was excessive use of force and whether the methods used by the military were acceptable," she said. "We would call on the U.S. military to be as cooperative as possible with our investigation." And I would tell Ms. Mufti to fuck off and die. U.S. Marines launched an offensive against Falluja, a city of about 300,000 people 30 miles west of Baghdad, eight days ago to crack down on guerrillas and find those responsible for killing and burning four U.S. security guards March 31. The fighting was some of the fiercest Iraq has seen since U.S.-led forces launched the war that overthrew Saddam Hussein a year ago. For the past three days, Falluja has been under a tenuous truce. The director of Falluja’s general hospital has said more than 600 Iraqis were killed and some 1,200 were wounded in the battle. U.S. forces also suffered a heavy toll, with at least 70 soldiers killed in the past 12 days, many in Falluja. The U.S. military has rejected allegations that its soldiers fired indiscriminately or used excessive force. ...but who believes them, right? Certainly not HRW. "I could see many bodies in the streets. Hundreds were lying in the street. Relatives were too scared to get them," said Samir Rabee, who escaped with relatives and eight other families in the back of a refrigeration truck. Hundreds? Thousands? Millions? Billions? Trillions? Mufti said it would probably be another few days before investigators could travel to the city, and then only if the U.S. offensive had not resumed. Take your time, hon. We’ll still be there. |
| Posted by:tu3031 |
| #7 Just 600 dead...damn I was hoping for at least 100 times that!! For every one of ours I was thinking 100 of them, but that's just me. |
| Posted by: Long Hair Republican 2004-04-14 12:06:46 AM |
| #6 Has anyone done research into the salaries these WTF? Ms. Mufti? I can barely put into words my disgust with such |
| Posted by: Raj 2004-04-13 11:18:36 PM |
| #5 Prediction: reporting on HRW will invariably have to mention atrocities committed against the 4 Americans killed by the Fallujahans. Most Americans will think we were justified regardless of collateral damage and some Arabs might even understand the cause/effect cycle at least for a bit. |
| Posted by: JAB 2004-04-13 11:10:15 PM |
| #4 Sure HRW, Right after you investigate slavery in Sudan, Female mutilation in Saudi Arabia / Pakistan / Iran / Africa /etc... , the murder of newborn babies in North Korea (because they might be of 'inpure' North Korean / Chinese blood), Political prisoners in China and North Korea, all the mass graves in Iraq (and probably Iran now as well). Once you investigate all those offenses which are already on your plate then you will be more then welcome to visit Falluja. Until then SHUT THE FUCK UP! (pardon my 'french'). |
| Posted by: CrazyFool 2004-04-13 9:40:19 PM |
#3 Probe Needed Into U.S. Action in FallujaIt certainly is - as to why the Marines haven't killed more terrorists, both foreign and domestic. Yes, HRW, you go into Fallujah and show us how to properly and politely deal with murdering terrorist scum. Make sure your wills are up to date first. And don't expect us to come rescue you; we know you wouldn't approve of our actions. Wankers. |
| Posted by: Barbara Skolaut 2004-04-13 9:18:04 PM |
| #2 The trick here is to send the human rights watch investigators into Fallujah ahead of the Marines, so they can show the Marines how to do things the right way, and also help in locating any unexploded IED's. |
| Posted by: Matt 2004-04-13 8:45:11 PM |
| #1 Hey, I welcome this probe. But I predict that when the outcome doesn't show the Marines are to blame, we'll never hear about this again. Same thing if it is discovered the militants used civilians as shields, hid in schools, mosques, houses, and so on. |
| Posted by: Rafael 2004-04-13 8:33:13 PM |