You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq-Jordan
Fallujah Gunmen Celebrate U.S. Pullback
2004-05-02
This was expected.
Gunmen waved their weapons in Fallujah's streets and outside car windows Saturday, cheering what they called a victory as U.S. forces pulled back. But the Marines insisted they weren't going far and a new Iraqi force taking the front line will root out die-hard insurgents. The new "Fallujah Brigade," put together by Iraqi generals from Saddam Hussein's ousted regime, likely will include some former army soldiers who fought American forces over the past month, Marine Lt. Gen. James Conway said. He promised, however, that anyone who has "blood on their hands" would not be allowed to stay in the force. Another military official acknowledged that the United States didn't know who the individual members of the force were and that its fighters and commanders still had to be vetted to ensure that they are not connected to crimes of the Saddam regime. The force's leadership could be changed soon because of the screening process.
Not a completely baked idea, eh?
Scores of Iraqis gathered in the streets Saturday morning, some flashing "V" for victory signs and raising the Iraqi flag. Motorists drove through the streets, shouting "Islam, it's your day!" and "We redeem Islam with our blood!" Some were masked with kuffeyahs and raised automatic weapons, members of the insurgency that put up stiff resistance against the Marines. Some guerrillas drove through the city, honking horns and waving their guns out the windows.
Demonstrates the superb discipline of Marine snipers -- I would have potted two or three of these jokers just on general principles.
The new "Fallujah Brigade," led by Maj. Gen. Jassim Mohammed Saleh, fanned out and imposed a cordon around nearly the entire southern half of Fallujah, replacing Marines who were pulling back to set up a second cordon, some five miles from the city.
Yep, let the FPA secure the area the Marines have already taken, so the Marines can get on with more important work.
The willingness to install a relatively unknown armed force with ties to the ousted regime at the forefront of the Fallujah standoff was a sign of U.S. eagerness to find a way out of the siege, which raised an international outcry and angered many Iraqi leaders who supported the United States. A U.S. officer said the Fallujah model, though not a "hard and fast" policy, might be applied elsewhere.
First see if it works here. I have my doubts...
The force came about suddenly - a dramatic reversal less than a week after the United States was threatening to launch a new offensive into Fallujah. The former generals approached Marine commanders and offered to take over security duties in the city using their own former soldiers, the military official said.
Who, keep in mind, are much better at ruthlessly suppressing the population than they are at fighting wars...
Conway, commander of the 1st Marine Expeditionary Force, insisted that the U.S. withdrawal did not mean a let-up in the pursuit of the guerrillas. He said Saleh - who served in Saddam Hussein's Republican Guard and as a commander of the Iraqi army's 38th Infantry Division - has presented a plan to confront the city's hard-core militants. "They understand our view that these people must be killed or captured," Conway said. "They have not flinched. And their commander has said as much to his assembly of officers."
One way to find out.
Conway said the Iraqi force will be made up of 1,100 fighters, mostly former army soldiers. Another senior U.S. military official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said about 700 fighters had been gathered under the force so far. Former Iraqi generals are putting together the force, and the ex-soldiers have been their "recruiting pool," Conway said. Conway said he was not concerned that the Iraqi forces, which will be under his overall command, might carry out atrocities or resort to unlawful methods in its hunt for insurgents. But he said Marines would be quick to stop them if they did. "We don't see any extremism in any fashion in this group of Iraqi general officers," he said. "We're not concerned about that at this point. ... There will be no horrific acts." By Saturday, all 700 Marines of the 1st Battalion, 5th Regiment had pulled out of the industrial zone in southern Fallujah, their main forward base in the city. If all goes well on Fallujah's south side, the Iraqi force will next replace Marines in the north within a few days, the official said. "We are not leaving, we will be right there behind them and will move in if things go wrong," the official said.
Posted by:Steve White

#10  In case some of you haven't, check out....

http://belmontclub.blogspot.com/

It may have a calming affect....

Posted by: WUZZALIB   2004-05-02 2:11:21 PM  

#9  #7 Dakotah

"My understanding is months ago the Army pulled out of Fallujah to allow the locals to be in charge of security."

Can you now see the similarity with the Israeli experience that led to Jenin?
One must come to terms with the Levantine mentality.
Posted by: Cynic   2004-05-02 1:21:47 PM  

#8  Straight out of the Small Wars Manual. But I don't think the USMC has ever done a small war thing in an arab state. May need to update the SWM.
Posted by: Shipman   2004-05-02 12:21:35 PM  

#7  I don't see the logic of this. My understanding is months ago the Army pulled out of Fallujah to allow the locals to be in charge of security. The result was we had no control of the city and this eventually led to the murder of the four contractors. Now it appears we're following the same model. I understand the reluctance to fight in the city - it would be a military victory, but a public relations disaster - but I have zero faith in the Iraqis policing themselves in this area.
Posted by: Dakotah   2004-05-02 9:06:23 AM  

#6  Big, big mistake letting Iraqis take control of Fallujah security. There is a proverb in arabic (but it really should be among muslims)that goes like this: Me and my brother against my cousin, my cousin and I against a stranger (in this case infidel). #5 is right: Never, ever trust a muslim, even if he/she looks to be on your side. Always count on him/her to revert back to tribal-brotherhood-islam loyalty garbage.
Posted by: Anonymous4617   2004-05-02 8:50:21 AM  

#5  This whole thing still confuses me. On the one hand it makes sense for Iraqis to start taking responsibility for security. But I don't trust them. This Iraqi general could just set up his own little mafia fiefdom in Fallujah. If the towns are to be off limits to Americans, what's to prevent this "model" from degenerating into little fiefdoms ruled by local warlords everywhere? And BTW, is Sadr now going to be the warlord/ mafia don of Najaf?
Posted by: virginian   2004-05-02 8:37:29 AM  

#4  By the way, I hope the Fallujah Brigade is taking pictures of all the celebratants so they know who to shoot later.
Posted by: RWV   2004-05-02 2:25:18 AM  

#3  This is a case of the Marines preempting the State Dept. The "Fallujah Brigade" is a fig leaf. If they can't or won't deal with the bad guys, the Marines are still in Grim Reaper formation ready to mow them down. The big advantage is it forestalls any half-baked notions that might have come out of State.
Posted by: RWV   2004-05-02 2:23:55 AM  

#2  So they have given up the southern section. This has been a really interesting time. I hope the jibadies get wacked. If not it's pay later. But then again it's their dirty carpet.
Posted by: Lucky   2004-05-02 2:08:22 AM  

#1  At some point in time soon, I'd like to see this Iraqi force senbt in to go get those insurgents still remaining. If they do the job capably, fine, consider it for use in other locations. If not, then no more pussyfooting around. Send in the Marines full-bore and do what has to be done to kill off whoever is left, and if that includes flattening the remaining area, then do it and do it immediately. The sensitivity approach isn't paying off where it needs to.
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2004-05-02 1:48:45 AM  

00:00