You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Europe
Bloody Warsaw Uprising Seeks Its Place in History
2004-07-30
EFL
Lucjan Wisniewski is an unsung hero of one of the last great World War II battles lost by the Allies -- the Warsaw Uprising in 1944. He fought to liberate his country from Nazi rule, but unlike his Western peers, he was prosecuted for doing so afterwards. To this day he keeps one of his battalion's most treasured possessions -- its ragged, blood-stained banner -- rolled up at home. He will finally hand the banner to a museum on Sunday exactly 60 years after Poles took up arms in an attempt to drive the Nazis from Warsaw and save themselves from another totalitarian regime, Stalinist communism.

World leaders, including German Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder and Secretary of State Collin Powell, will also pay tribute to the doomed uprising, long played down by historians and neglected by politicians in Poland and abroad. "After six decades of waiting and agony, our banner will find its rightful place," said Wisniewski, referring to the Warsaw Uprising Museum to be opened on the Aug. 1 anniversary.

Poland's Western allies placed little pressure on Soviet leader Joseph Stalin to aid the uprising, which many Poles felt was a meager reward for their war efforts in engagements like the Battle of Britain and the fight for Italy's Monte Cassino. Outgunned, outnumbered and ignored by Soviet forces, who stopped their advance on the outskirts of Warsaw, the uprising collapsed after 63 days, leaving the city in ruins and more than 160,000 dead. The remnants of the underground Home Army who survived the uprising were interrogated, detained and sometimes executed by Moscow-trained communists determined to impose their rule. "A museum commemorating the uprising was unthinkable for years, and this may be the last anniversary many veterans will attend," said Marcin Roszkowski, one of the museum's organizers.
I didn't realize that the anniversery of that kind of betrayal and brutal slaying of a brave group of people could be celebrated. When are the Ketyn Woods massacres celebrated, maybe I can plan a vacation around the gala affair?
We don't need to celebrate, we need to remember.
Posted by:Super Hose

#4  SH--Respectfully, I haven't made the same mistake. I am aware that the Reds left the Jews to fight on their own and be subsequently massacred because they didn't want anyone in the way when they came through and "liberated" Poland. They were more than content to let all their opponents massacre each other and save them the effort. I know my history--where WWII is concerned, at least!
Posted by: Dar   2004-07-31 12:30:39 AM  

#3  Dar, you have made the same mistake that the State Department did. The State Department released a statement saying that Colin Powell was to attend thought that this ceremony for the Ghetto uprising - this is a different Polish uprising. As happened in many places during WWII before an area was liberated, a radio announcement was made that Warsaw was on the verge of being liberated to encourage partisans to help out the cause. In this case the partisan AK rose but Stalin ordered his troops to hold in place for 30 days. This surprised the partisans and the Germans both. There was a short period of time while the Red Army was holding before the Germans realized their cue and returned to the city to massacre the AK - thus making Stalin's subjugation of Poland all the easier.
Posted by: Super Hose   2004-07-30 10:35:01 PM  

#2  *whew!* I'm glad to see Rantburg is restored! I was afraid all my witty, pithy comments were gone forever!

But seriously, I have to recommend the movie Uprising, which was very well done--especially for a made-for-TV movie--that portrays the Warsaw Ghetto plight and the uprising. Even though David Scwimmer from "Friends" is one of the stars and everyone affects Polish accents to varying degrees of success, I highly recommend the movie for the subject material and respect it pays the real Polish-Jewish heroes.
Posted by: Dar   2004-07-30 5:34:16 PM  

#1  Nice post SH. Someday I hope to go to Poland. I'd like to talk to the guys who forced the crack in the dam.
Posted by: Lucky   2004-07-30 1:21:55 PM  

00:00