You have commented 358 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Politix
Dole Statement regarding new Move-on Ad
2004-09-17
from Drudge
ARLINGTON, VA -- Former Senator Bob Dole issued the following statement:

"As Chairman of the Bush-Cheney Veterans Coalition, and as a veteran, I call on John Kerry to demand that MoveOn.org take down their ad depicting a defeated American soldier. It's one thing to debate whether we should take the fight to the terrorists, but depicting an American soldier in effect surrendering in the battle against the terrorists is beyond the pale. I cannot believe that John Kerry, who reminds us daily of his Vietnam service, would possibly approve the disgusting and demoralizing portrayal of American soldiers fighting for us in Iraq, Afghanistan and around the world.

John Kerry has raised doubts about our troops' ability to maintain security as well as Iraqi's ability to decide their own future through elections. He has called the allies in Iraq "window dressing." This is all reminiscent of his appearance before a Senate Committee in 1971 where he suggested with nothing but second hand information American GIs were committing atrocities and war crimes of the worst kind in Vietnam. This defeatist attitude undermines the great progress and sacrifices of our men and women in the military and the contributions of our allies who are fighting against terror and standing up for freedom around the world. The politics of pessimism that is being pursued by John Kerry and the extreme liberals demonstrates they are consumed by the past with nothing to offer but attacks on the President's agenda for creating a safer world.

John, say it isn't so and denounce this latest effort to divide Americans"
Posted by:Super Hose

#8  More Dole quotes from Mens News Daily
Former U.S. Senator and 1996 Republican presidential nominee Bob Dole, who is serving as Chairman of President Bush's Veterans Coalition, also reacted strongly to the MoveOn.org ad and the lack of any reaction from the Kerry campaign.

"I call on John Kerry to demand that MoveOn.org take down their ad depicting a defeated American soldier," Dole said in a statement. "It's one thing to debate whether we should take the fight to the terrorists, but depicting an American soldier in effect surrendering in the battle against the terrorists is beyond the pale."

Dole said he is surprised Kerry would "approve" of such a "disgusting and demoralizing portrayal of American soldiers" since he "reminds of daily of his Vietnam service."

"John Kerry has raised doubts about our troops' ability to maintain security as well as Iraqi's ability to decide their own future through elections," Dole reminded, explaining that Kerry once called the American allies in Iraq "window dressing."

Recalling Kerry's testimony on Capitol Hill after returning from Vietnam, Dole charged that Kerry has been anti-military ever since.
"This is all reminiscent of his appearance before a Senate Committee in 1971 where he suggested with nothing but second hand information American GIs were committing atrocities and war crimes of the worst kind in Vietnam," Dole noted. "This defeatist attitude undermines the great progress and sacrifices of our men and women in the military and the contributions of our allies who are fighting against terror and standing up for freedom around the world."

Describing Kerry's "politics of pessimism" regarding the war on terror as "extreme," Dole said Kerry and his fellow liberal Democrats are "consumed by the past with nothing to offer but attacks on the President's agenda for creating a safer world."

Appealing directly to Kerry regarding the MoveOn.org ad, Dole asked, "John, say it isn't so and denounce this latest effort to divide Americans."

Posted by: GK   2004-09-17 6:38:59 PM  

#7  From : http://www.strangecosmos.com/content/item/102073.html

moveon.org a.k.a. Mr George Soros :


If I had a brother like you, I'd put myself up for adoption.
------------------------------
I guess you prove that even God makes mistakes sometimes.
------------------------------
Wow! You're a legend in your own mind!

Posted by: BigEd   2004-09-17 12:40:18 PM  

#6  actually its prolly a pic of some grunt just trying to keep his weapon clean and out of the mud. Or maybe he is showing some Iraqis how to properly surrender to U.S. forces. Also "enemy in sight" is depicted w/the weapon at the ready and not upside down.
Posted by: Jarhead   2004-09-17 12:29:53 PM  

#5  This "signal" can mean "enemy in sight". It can also be used to show an enemy what to do to surrender. This is not a picture of an American soldier surrendering.
Posted by: Deacon Blues   2004-09-17 12:15:03 PM  

#4  Any RBers out there who can confirm that the soldier depicted, holding his weapon upside down over his head with both hands, is actually giving a signal (I heard it meant "Enemy in sight").

Posted by: Carl in N.H   2004-09-17 11:56:50 AM  

#3  
I don't think John Kerry can legally demand MoveOn.org do anything.
True, if there were no connection between his campaign and them.

And if you believe there isn't, I can get you a good deal on a bridge. They don't even bother to hide it.

Look at it this way: Bush asked that all 527 ads be stopped (which I disagree with). Kerry's response? Crickets chirping. He just wants ads against him stopped.

As as far as "legally" goes, as eLarson says, Kerry can certainly at the very least publicly state that he disapproves of that message and disassociates his campaign from the moveon crowd.

Again, all we hear are crickets. Quelle surprise.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2004-09-17 10:29:41 AM  

#2   I don't think John Kerry can legally demand MoveOn.org do anything.

No more than Bush can tell the SwiftVets from stopping their ads. Kerry still called on Bush to do it.
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2004-09-17 10:10:55 AM  

#1  I don't think John Kerry can legally demand MoveOn.org do anything. He can certainly decry the message, though. I doubt that he will, though, since MoveOn's new ad dovetails neatly with the story he told in his Winter Soldier days.
Posted by: eLarson   2004-09-17 8:40:55 AM  

00:00