You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
China-Japan-Koreas
Another North Korean bargaining chip in the nuclear crisis
2004-12-01
North Korea is holding South Korean construction cranes, bulldozers, road graders, dump trucks and almost 200 cars hostage at the site of a suspended power plant project as a bargaining chip in the international standoff over its bid to develop nuclear weapons.
"One false move and the Daewoo gets it!"
The South Korean companies that own the construction equipment are dismayed since North Korea has refused to back down on demands for compensation for the suspension of the power-plant program. The Korean Peninsula Energy Development Organization (KEDO), the New York-based consortium set up to build safe power plants in North Korea in exchange for Pyongyang's agreement to dismantle its weapons program, says no progress has been made on the impasse.
"Put the crusher down and step away!"
"Never!"
Construction of two 1,000-megawatt light-water reactors to replace North Korea's Russian-model, plutonium-producing nuclear plants was suspended in 2003 after the United States raised suspicions that Pyongyang also concealed a secret program to enrich uranium to weapons grade. The freeze on the nuclear plant project was extended last week for another year, effective Dec. 1, by KEDO, which is led by the United States, Japan, South Korea, and the European Union. The Bush administration has been contending that the project has ``no future,'' as the State Department said a year ago.
"T'hell with it! Let 'em keep the graders. We're outta there!"
"But those are our graders!"
"Then you negotiate with them!"
South Korea and Japan, which are most heavily invested in construction of the $4.6 billion nuclear plant project about 125 miles north of the 38th parallel on North Korea's east coast near Sinpo, hope to keep it on the table to entice North Korea back into disarmament talks. KEDO's extension of the freeze noted that ``the future of the project will be assessed and decided by the Executive Board before the expiration of the suspension period,'' suggesting it will be revived or killed based on North Korea's willingness to rejoin disarmament talks in coming months.
"He's holding his breath again."
"Ignore him. He does that all the time. Nothing ever happens."
But in the meantime, North Korea has barred the removal of 93 pieces of heavy construction equipment, including three cranes, plus bulldozers, steam shovels, dump trucks, road graders and forklifts, and about 190 South Korean cars and some buses from the site at Kumho, demanding that the United States pay unspecified ``compensation'' for the suspension of the program.
"Money! Give us compensation for all we've invested!"
"Piss off. All that stuff is charitable contributions. You can have your Kimmie posters back. That's all you kicked in."
Pyongyang has threatened to go in and seize the equipment along with computers, office equipment and any technical documents still on the site, but has made no move to do so. KEDO's executive director, Charles Kartman, raised the issue in talks with North Korea prior to the consortium's announcement Nov. 26 of the extension of the freeze on construction. KEDO spokesman Brian Kremer confirmed on Monday that no progress has been made recently on breaking the impasse, but added, ``We're certainly hopeful that KEDO can resolve this issue.''
"Yeah. We raised the issue. But they were so whacked out on white slag we couldn't get any sense out of them."
The South Korean companies with the most equipment at stake are Hyundai, Doosan, Daewoo and Dong-ah, which subcontracted with Korean Electric Power Co. to provide construction work. A spokesman for the four major Korean subcontractors, speaking in Seoul on condition of anonymity, said the seized equipment amounted to a major loss and said the situation was ``awkward'' for the construction consortium since they had not been compensated for it. Their equipment had been shipped from South Korea directly to a port at Kumo, avoiding the difficulty of negotiating road access through the almost hermetically sealed North Korea. KEDO is continuing to pay leasing fees to the South Korean companies ``for equipment that is not being used. We have a budget that we have to live within,'' Kremer said.
"We have a project manager who was last seen clutching a gin bottle and weeping in a gutter in Pusan..."
The reduced KEDO staff at the Kumho site is maintaining the partially built project and caring for the equipment and vehicles. The major and lesser subcontractors had sought to retrieve their equipment when the nuclear project was shelved about a year ago, when the project was a third of the way toward completion. But a North Korean Foreign Ministry spokesman said at the time, ``We will never allow the U.S. to take out facilities, equipment and materials for the light water reactor construction and technical documents now in the Kumho area unless the U.S. pays a penalty.''

``Our measure has nothing to do with subcontractors participating in the light water reactor construction,'' the Foreign Ministry spokesman said, quoted by North Korea's official news agency. The value of the vehicles and equipment perhaps in the tens of millions of dollars is a small fraction of the overall $4.6 billion estimated cost of the Kumho reactor project, which is 70 percent funded by South Korea. But the impasse over removal of the equipment is emblematic of the conflicting political demands from the United States, South Korea and Japan, which the KEDO project is entangled in.
Posted by:tipper

#5  AP- Consider it "a good object lesson". Rantburg has never been drink-safe.
Posted by: Dishman   2004-12-01 5:13:41 PM  

#4  When you make deals with psychopaths, expect to get burned. The SKor companies expected to do quite well in Nork, but, well sh*t happens. Losing the construction spread will be a good object lesson for South Koreans. They will not learn unless they bear the cost.

The whole reason that this deal went south is that the Norks violated their agreement not to produce plutonium, so the Norks will also pay a price for welching on the deal.

The US hopefully has learned that the Norks are liars and thieves, but we knew that going in. Everyone can thank Bubba for sucking everyone into this fiasco.

So that is how I see it: an expensive object lesson for SKor. Maybe the SKor govt can bail out the SKor contractors. The KEDO project is a dead skunk in the middle of the road.

A final note: Fred---your comments had me spraying turkey and dressing leftovers on the screen. Thanks a lot....
Posted by: Alaska Paul   2004-12-01 4:20:00 PM  

#3  Sounds like time for some Tomahawk negotiation, and compensation to the South Korean construction teams. A dozen Tomahawks should do the trick. Let the NKors have the scrap metal.
Posted by: Old Patriot   2004-12-01 3:29:43 PM  

#2  As far as the Greens go, their real beef is not with nuclear power, but with Western Civilization. So long a barbarians build the things, they're cool with it.
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2004-12-01 9:22:32 AM  

#1  I've asked before but never gotten an answer.

Where are the Kyoto types and Greenie protestors of all these new nuke plants? Iran is busily building nuclear generating plants with promises of EU (and JFK) help, NK is / was having us build them these "safe" nuke plants and never a peep from the environmentalists.

Any guesses at the reaction if GWB announced a program to build another 20 or so nuke plants to cut down on coal / oil / gas electric generation?

Where are those Rainbow Wimps when you need them?
Posted by: AlanC   2004-12-01 9:20:42 AM  

00:00