You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Short Attention Span Theater-
Study Blames Diesel for Deaths....
2005-02-24
Diesel pollution is responsible for more deaths than drunk drivers and homicides, according to a new study that estimates how many premature deaths, asthma attacks and heart attacks are caused by diesel pollution in every U.S. county. Nationwide, diesel pollution causes 21,000 premature deaths each year, including 475 in Massachusetts and 81 in Middlesex County, robbing those who die of an average of 14 years of their lives, according to the report by the Boston-based Clean Air Task Force. Residents in nearby Suffolk County suffer the third highest risk of exposure to diesel pollution in the nation, researchers found.

The numbers point to a failure of New England states to curb emissions, said Michael Stoddard, an attorney for Environment Northeast, a group that distributed the new report in New England. "No state in New England currently has a systematic plan in place to address this problem," Stoddard, director of ENE's New England Diesel Initiative, said yesterday. "We have legislation about power plants. We have legislation about drunk drivers. We have legislation against firearm violations. Here's something that's in the same class in terms of impact."

To determine diesel pollution's health effects in each U.S. county, the Clean Air Task Force said it employed methodology the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency uses to assess the health benefits of new rules. The group also used the EPA's county-by-county estimates of diesel emissions. The report compares the estimated 21,000 diesel pollution deaths with the 17,000 annual deaths caused by drunk driving and the nation's 20,000 annual homicides. The analysis concludes diesel pollution has widespread impacts in Massachusetts, including 727 nonfatal heart attacks per year, 9,925 asthma attacks, 43 cancer deaths, 289 cases of chronic bronchitis and 61,842 lost days of work. The effects include 43 premature deaths in Norfolk County, which includes Franklin, Bellingham, Millis and Wellesley, and 23 premature deaths in Worcester County, which includes Milford, Upton and Uxbridge.
*snipped, more cooked stats and voodoo science at link ie cumulative effect assumed but not proven or supported, selective analysis of causation, etc.

In any case, we can now tell the eco-wackies their diesel problem is solved:



Ford Nucleon, 1958

This is only a pipsqueak 4-wheeler but the technology could obviously be adapted to power buses, trucks, tractors; heck, even submarines. ;)
It's quiet, smooth, and runs fifty thousand miles on one fill-up.
Homicidal right-wing SUV drivers would think twice about t-boning it and, best of all, it will not emit any planet-destroying CO2 (unless it melts down and the tires/occupants catch fire).

Beat the heat with the cool blue glow of uranium.
Posted by:Atomic Conspiracy

#13  Vin, you murdering bastard!

Oh, wait....
Posted by: mojo   2005-02-24 5:31:17 PM  

#12  or Pitch Black. Vin's good at the one thing he does well - action films
Posted by: Frank G   2005-02-24 4:25:16 PM  

#11  Next thing you know they will recycle this stuff.......http://www.dhmo.org/
Posted by: Dorf   2005-02-24 4:10:12 PM  

#10  Exposure to oxygen causes cancer. People should be prohibited from consuming it.
Posted by: Dishman   2005-02-24 3:54:55 PM  

#9  This just in.....exposure to sunlight causes cancer. Thousands die annually. Government regulations pending.
Posted by: Spemble Whaimp3884   2005-02-24 2:19:48 PM  

#8  "Mix biodiesel fuel into those existing diesel engines (except during winter) and I bet those numbers change drastically."
Whatever gave you the idea that biodiesel is inherently clean, rjschwarz? We could refine petroleum-based fuel further too -- it's just that nobody wants to pay the price.
Posted by: Tom   2005-02-24 1:46:38 PM  

#7  Now, now . . . Chronicles of Riddick was not that bad. Vinnie might not have given an Oscar performance, but for his normal stuff, this was above average.
Posted by: Omavinter Pheart2665   2005-02-24 1:37:38 PM  

#6  Study Blames Diesel for Deaths....

If you saw Chronicles of Riddick I'm sure you're probably brain dead at a minimum...
Posted by: Raj   2005-02-24 1:14:32 PM  

#5  Mix biodiesel fuel into those existing diesel engines (except during winter) and I bet those numbers change drastically. Such a move would also require no changes to existing diesel engines.

Since the Clean Air Task Force isn't looking for solutions and simply wants to ban diesel I have to wonder about their motivation and source of funding.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2005-02-24 12:10:33 PM  

#4  In other news, Mother Nature is blamed for cellular atrophy, resulting in the fact that every living thing dies. Lawyers eyeing global class-action suit.
Posted by: .com   2005-02-24 10:57:44 AM  

#3  Seems to me that groups like the Clean Air Task Force won't be satisfied until we're all riding horses again, and even then would probably complain that equine flatulence is some sort of pollution problem.
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2005-02-24 10:44:22 AM  

#2  We already have emission regulations for diesels, and they get stricter every year.

The problem I always see is that diesels need to be tuned up more often, the tune-up costs more, and the emissions get much worse if you let it go. I think the city of Tucson holds a raffle every year to see which of their buses gets a tune-up. I am always behind one of the losers. People who had the VW diesels of the 70s and 80s found out that while the fuel economy is nice, having to pay hundreds of dollars every 12,000 miles for a tune-up negates it. So, they would let it slide and you would see Rabbits with black smudges on their back ends.
Posted by: Jackal   2005-02-24 8:09:29 AM  

#1  The studies are BS. If they want to study Diesel they have to go to Europe where it is much more widely used. I bet they can't find any proof for what they are trying to state as fact.
Posted by: Sock Puppet of Doom   2005-02-24 8:05:45 AM  

00:00