You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Britain
Perhaps the neocons got it right in the Middle East
2005-05-04
A Max Hastings article in al-Guardian.
Those of us who work on the gloomy side of the prediction industry about Iraq, the prospects for Middle East peace, and the sanity of the Bush administration, have been given plenty to think about lately. On the one hand, on Monday the 87th British soldier was killed in Iraq, while suicide bombs and armed clashes have accounted for more than 40 Iraqi deaths since last week. On the other, the Bush administration is in triumphalist mode. A friend who visited the White House recently described the president's buoyant account of his Iraqi crusade, which highlighted the fact that a national government has been formed. Some progress is claimed towards normalisation in Shia and Kurdish regions. Syrian withdrawal gives Lebanon a chance of making something of democracy. Washington asserts that it is involving itself more than ever in the Middle East peace process.

None of these claims should be dismissed out of hand.
In fact, Max, they're manifestly true. A new government is in place. Lebanon is in the process of healing itself. Kurds and Shi'a are getting along. What's not to like about this?
The greatest danger for those of us who dislike George Bush is that our instincts may tip over into a desire to see his foreign policy objectives fail. No reasonable person can oppose the president's commitment to Islamic democracy.
But a lot of unreasonable ones are opposed, and Bush's reasonable opponents haven't separated themselves from the moonbats and kooks very well.
Most western Bushophobes are motivated not by dissent about objectives, ...
Posted by:Steve White

#6  That was a righteous fiskings, Steve. Well done!
Posted by: BH   2005-05-04 14:40  

#5  Sounds a lot like ''We may get back into power, so we'd better get a proper handle on issues, instead of continously dropping them on our feet''.
Posted by: Pappy   2005-05-04 10:48  

#4  The key question, surely, is how far the Shia and Kurd majority is moving towards the creation of a working society. Evidence on this is mixed. Journalists are able to travel so little outside the Baghdad enclave that the world depends for information chiefly on western military and diplomatic sources.


He could always read Chrenkoff. Or Rantburg.

Nice comments, Steve.
Posted by: Seafarious   2005-05-04 09:19  

#3  A ''Bushophobe?'' Haven't heard that term yet, but I like it. It's about time they should be scared of us members of the VRWC.
Posted by: BA   2005-05-04 09:09  

#2  Good ideas are always simple and facts are always facts. Nuance is a state to which those whose ideas can not be reconciled with the facts, retreat.
Posted by: phil_b   2005-05-04 02:38  

#1  Excellent in-line, there, Dr Steve!

We've all guessed it must suck to have a few neurons but be caught up in the BDS Kool Aid Krowd. Here we have some proof. There's more angst and prevarication than fact in this piece - demonstrating the presence of multiple, if still misfiring, neurons. There's also a big dose of MSM ego which still blinds the author to the answers, but he is beginning to realize crow pie is on the menu. His dilemma is to try to continue the BDS bravado and bullshit while, simultaneously, picking out the feathers stuck in his teeth.

Sucks to be you, fool, but welcome to reality.
Posted by: .com   2005-05-04 02:04  

00:00